<?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?>
<rss version="2.0" xmlns:content="http://purl.org/rss/1.0/modules/content/" xmlns:wfw="http://wellformedweb.org/CommentAPI/" xmlns:dc="http://purl.org/dc/elements/1.1/" >

<channel><title><![CDATA[Tyler J. Bateman - Academic Methods Blog]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog]]></link><description><![CDATA[Academic Methods Blog]]></description><pubDate>Thu, 29 Oct 2026 22:34:27 -0700</pubDate><generator>Weebly</generator><item><title><![CDATA[A Method for Literature Reviews with Web of Science]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-method-for-literature-reviews-with-web-of-science]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-method-for-literature-reviews-with-web-of-science#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 21:06:46 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-method-for-literature-reviews-with-web-of-science</guid><description><![CDATA[A greatly appreciate the database Web of Science. In this post, I show how I find literature with it.      In this guide, I show you how to use Web of Science to search for articles by discipline, with a little detour into Journal Citation Reports which helped me to build some search terms I will use here.&nbsp;I currently work at the University of New Mexico (UNM), so the post will be slightly geared toward that university. But if you are not affiliated with UNM, then just adapt this to your ow [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">A greatly appreciate the database Web of Science. In this post, I show how I find literature with it.</div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph">In this guide, I show you how to use Web of Science to search for articles by discipline, with a little detour into Journal Citation Reports which helped me to build some search terms I will use here.&nbsp;<br /><br />I currently work at the University of New Mexico (UNM), so the post will be slightly geared toward that university. But if you are not affiliated with UNM, then just adapt this to your own university. If you don't have access to Web of Science at the moment, this post just won't be that helpful &ndash; I hope you can get access! But if you don't have access to Web of Science, you may have access to databases with similar functions like Scopus, and then it will be essentially the same even if it looks different.<br /><br /><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 1</font><br /><br />Go to your university's website for Web of Science (if it has access to this database)<br /><br />e.g., for UNM:<br /><a href="https://www-webofscience-com.libproxy.unm.edu/wos/alldb/basic-search">https://www-webofscience-com.libproxy.unm.edu/wos/alldb/basic-search</a>&nbsp; &nbsp;<br /><br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Step 2</font><br />Login to your library. E.g., at UNM, you'll be at this screen:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-10-36_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 3</font><br /><br />You have arrived! Web of Science looks like this:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-10-59_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 4.1.</font><br /><br />I like to use Web of Science with a discipline-specific search term. So Step 4 here is a set of steps.&nbsp;<br /><br />Go to Journal Citation Reports (you should have access to this if you have access to Web of Science).<br /><br />E.g., at UNM, search in a search engine:<br /><br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-14-00_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span style="color:rgb(218, 128, 68)"><font size="6">Step 4.2.</font></span><br /><br />Then go to the website that is about this kind of thing at your university and click on Journal Citation Reports:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-15-01_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 4.3.</font><br /><br />Search for the discipline you want to make the search term for:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-19-33_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 4.4.</font> <br /><br />Now using your judgment and knowledge of the field, and the impact factor, make up a search term, lining it with "OR" Boolean operators.&nbsp;<br /><br />So in this step, you go through the field and you figure out what journals are good journals. This list that you get when you do a search:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-21-27_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">is organized by the "JIF", the "Journal Impact Factor", which is how many times each article is cited, on average, in the journal. The JIF is usually a pretty good metric of journal quality. Not perfect. It isn't like the Annals of Tourism Research is understood by everyone to be the top journal in sociology. Rather, the top journal in sociology is widely understood to be a tie between the <em>American Sociological Review</em> and the <em>American Journal of Sociology</em>, despite neither of those being the top of the JIF ranking here. So true status is a combination of JIF and how people understand the journals in real life.<br /><br />Anyway, so you don't have to do this, but I like to pre-clean my search results by going to Journal Citation Reports and making up my own search term. So the end product, when you look at a Journal Citation Reports output, is something like this, for sociology:<br /><br /><font color="#24678d">&ldquo;ACTA SOCIOLOGICA&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AGRICULTURE AND HUMAN VALUES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CULTURAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN SOCIOLOGIST&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ANNUAL REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;BODY SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;BRITISH JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CANADIAN JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CANADIAN REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CHINESE SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CITY COMMUNITY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CRITICAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CULTURAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CURRENT SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;DISCOURSE &amp; SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;DU BOIS REVIEW SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH ON RACE&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ECONOMY AND SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ETHNIC AND RACIAL STUDIES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ETHNOGRAPHY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL THEORY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;EUROPEAN SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;FOOD CULTURE SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;GENDER &amp; SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INFORMATION COMMUNICATION SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF COMPARATIVE SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL POLITICAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL REVIEW FOR THE SOCIOLOGY OF SPORT&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JAPANESE JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF CONSUMER CULTURE&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY ETHNOGRAPHY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF HEALTH SOCIAL BEHAVIOUR&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF MARRIAGE AND FAMILY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;MEDIA CULTURE SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;MEN AND MASCULINITIES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;MOBILIZATION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;NATIONS AND NATIONALISM&rdquo; OR "POETICS" OR &ldquo;POLITICS SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;POPULATION AND DEVELOPMENT REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;QUALITATIVE RESEARCH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;RACE AND SOCIAL PROBLEMS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;RURAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR SEXUALITIES OR &ldquo;SOCIAL FORCES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL JUSTICE RESEARCH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL MOVEMENT STUDIES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL NETWORKS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL PROBLEMS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL SCIENCE QUARTERLY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL SCIENCE RESEARCH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIETY NATURAL RESOURCES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIETY AND MENTAL HEALTH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGIA RURALIS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL FORUM&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL INQUIRY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL METHODS RESEARCH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL QUARTERLY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL SCIENCE&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL SPECTRUM&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL THEORY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY THE JOURNAL OF THE BRITISH SOCIOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY COMPASS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY OF EDUCATION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY OF HEALTH ILLNESS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY OF RACE AND ETHNICITY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY OF RELIGION&rdquo; OR SOCIUS OR &ldquo;SYMBOLIC INTERACTION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;THEORY AND SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;WORK AND OCCUPATIONS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;YOUTH SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE QUARTERLY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ENVIRONMENTAL POLITICS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo;</font><br /><br /><br /><strong><font size="5">Or, here is one that focuses on the more elite journals in sociology:</font></strong><br /><br /><font color="#da8044">&ldquo;AMERICAN JOURNAL OF CULTURAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;AMERICAN SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ANNUAL REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;BRITISH JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CANADIAN JOURNAL OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CANADIAN REVIEW OF SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CITY COMMUNITY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CRITICAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CULTURAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;CURRENT SOCIOLOGY OR &ldquo;ENVIRONMENTAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ETHNIC AND RACIAL STUDIES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ETHNOGRAPHY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;EUROPEAN JOURNAL OF SOCIAL THEORY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;EUROPEAN SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;GENDER &amp; SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;INTERNATIONAL SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF CONSUMER CULTURE&rdquo; OR &ldquo;JOURNAL OF CONTEMPORARY ETHNOGRAPHY OR &ldquo;POETICS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;QUALITATIVE SOCIOLOGY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL FORCES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL PROBLEMS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIAL SCIENCE QUARTERLY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIETY AND MENTAL HEALTH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL FORUM&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL METHODS RESEARCH&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVES&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL QUARTERLY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL REVIEW&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL SCIENCE&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGICAL THEORY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY THE JOURNAL OF THE BRITISH SOCIOLOGICAL ASSOCIATION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;SOCIOLOGY COMPASS&rdquo; OR SOCIUS OR &ldquo;SYMBOLIC INTERACTION&rdquo; OR &ldquo;THEORY AND SOCIETY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;THEORY AND SOCIAL INQUIRY&rdquo; OR &ldquo;WORK AND OCCUPATIONS&rdquo; OR &ldquo;ADMINISTRATIVE SCIENCE QUARTERLY&rdquo;<br /><br />&#8203;</font></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 5</font><br /><br />Go back to Web of Science.<br /><br />Click "add row".<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-25-24_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 6</font><br /><br />Click the part that says &ldquo;All Fields&rdquo; in the new row you just made<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-25-43_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 7</font><br /><br />From the drop down menu, choose &ldquo;Publication Titles&rdquo;<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-26-24_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 8</font><br /><br />Now it should look like this<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-27-26_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 9</font><br /><br />Paste the journal search term&nbsp;</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-28-31_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 10</font><br /><br />Now you can search for whatever you want in the first box and you&rsquo;ll search only good quality journals. Of course, you can use whatever discipline you like, and customize the search term however makes sense for you. I'm not trying to say the term I developed above is the "right" sociology term. Customize it to suit your needs and preferences.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-30-29_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="6" color="#da8044">Step 11</font><br /><br />Look at your results.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-31-22_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 12</font><br /><br />It is usually a good practice to restrict your search to the last 10-15 years.<br /><br />&#8203;Step 12.1. Click<strong><font color="#da8044"> &ldquo;See all&rdquo;</font></strong> under the &ldquo;Publication Years&rdquo; pane</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-32-37_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font size="5" color="#da8044">Step 12.2.</font><br /><br />Click the last 10-15 years and then click "refine".</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-34-06_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Then you have only recent articles. Your goal should be to enter recent conversations, which is why doing this is helpful.&nbsp;&#8203;Now you have articles only from good quality journals from the last decade or so.</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-15-34-49_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span style="color:rgb(218, 128, 68)"><font size="6">Step 13</font></span><br /><br /><span>Now you need to choose how you want to sort all of the articles. The default on Web of Science as of September 2026 is "Relevance". That is often helpful. The other helpful method is to sort them by "Highest cited first", so you can see which are more influential. You can see the first two in the relevance ranking in the previous picture there. This is the influence ranking:</span></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-b_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-17-52-24_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now it is ordered by most influential:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-17-54-27_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Obviously, if you really wanted to know which one is most influential per unit time, you would divide each citation number by the number of years, but they don't have that, and I'm not doing that manually! So you just scroll through and keep an eye on the date. Obviously something cited more often and also more recent is relatively more influential.<br /><br />You don't have to do it this way, from most to least cited. It can just be informative to see the most influential work. And if you're starting a literature review on climate change, clearly Dietz et al. 2020 is a good place to start, as it is a review article from the <em>Annual Review of Sociology</em>&nbsp;(a high status journal) and is the most cited per unit time, at least in terms of these top 3 articles.<br />&#8203;</div>  <div class="paragraph"><span style="color:rgb(218, 128, 68)"><font size="6">yStep 14</font></span><br /><br />Now I'll just show how to download an article this way. Maybe that is easy for you, but in case it isn't.<br /><br />I think it is ideal to <u><strong>download</strong></u> the articles. I know many undergraduates only read PDFs in a browser, which was quite surprising to me when I found out. I think it is better to have <u><strong>a folder for each class</strong></u>, on your computer, where you download PDFs for an store them. I personally keep all of my PDFs in Zotero, but you need to pay for that. But if you just keep them in folders on your computer, one folder for each class, that is a pretty simple structure that will allow you to use PDF annotation tools and just keep track of what you've found better. I strongly encourage undergraduates to do this (and of course graduate students, although I would encourage you to use Zotero or Mendeley or whatever other reference manager you like that allows you to keep the PDFs in it, instead).<br /><br />Here are the steps for downloading. Clearly the steps are going to be a bit different for different universities, but this is what it looks like at UNM.<br /><br /><font color="#da8044" size="6">Step 14.1. Click one of the articles</font></div>  <div class="paragraph">So for example, if we click the first one in this list:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-16-38_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">We see the following, and click "Find@<font color="#248d6c">[YourUniversity]</font>" to get the link to the article (<font color="#da8044">Step 14.2</font>):</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-17-32_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Then University of New Mexico has this intermediate step of going through another page, this step is going to look different for different universities, if they have this intermediate step at all (I'm fairly sure when I was at University of Toronto there wasn't this extra step) (<font color="#da8044">Step 14.3</font>):</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-19-13_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br /><br />&#8203;Then just click PDF (<font color="#da8044">Step 14.4.</font>):</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-22-05_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">And I do encourage you to download it, so that you can annotate and remember what you have done in terms of your work finding articles (<font color="#da8044">Step 14.5.</font>) and then organize it well in your computer (<font color="#da8044">Step 14.6.</font>):</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-24-19_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span>In addition, various forms of unusual things can sometimes happen, and you may have to troubleshoot. For example, if we choose the second one from the list:</span></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-17-54b_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span>We see this as with last time:</span></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-17-58ab_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><strong><font color="#248d6c"><br /><br />&#8203;But then it says that the item isn't available:</font></strong></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-02-24_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Often university databases have little errors all over the place. In this case, if we just click the DOI, it takes us to the article:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-02b_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-04-06_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-06-20_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">But another tip when it comes to finding articles is that if your university says its database doesn't have a particular article, when you have searched for the individual article directly, you can usually find it by <u><strong>searching for the journal</strong></u>.<br /><br />So let's pretend that when I clicked that DOI link just now it didn't work to bring up the article.<br /><br />Then I could do <u><strong>a search for the journal itself</strong></u> at my library and find the article. Then find the article with the volume and issue number.<br /><br />Caveat:&nbsp;Some journals are just usually not purchased by universities. I have never, for example, been at a university that had a subscription to the <em>American Journal of Cultural Sociology</em>. It is just lacking in many databases. But you can at least check.<br /><br />&#8203;For something as standard as the <em>Annual Review of Sociology</em>, they definitely will have it at most R1s (and hopefully other places too) in a journals database search. So, if you wanted to find it via the journal, go to your library's website and click the equivalent of what I have here saying "journals only" or something to that effect:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-08-52_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br /><strong><font color="#248d6c">Here I'm searching for the <em>Annual Review of Sociology</em>:</font></strong></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-10-13_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Of course we do indeed have such a standard journal:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-10-45_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-11-41_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Then we need to figure out what volume to look inside, since we see this at the journal:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-14-14_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">If we look back at the citation <u><strong>we can see which volume this article is in</strong></u>. Easy for an Annual Review that only does one issue per year, but in most cases we will also look for the issue number as well. But yes you can see the volume is 46:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-13-14_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So click 46:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-14b_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">And scroll down to find the article:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-18-15-13_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br /><br />So that is the method I use to check sociology literatures to find articles. You can of course adapt this to other fields. You don't, also, necessarily have to use the "publication titles" row, and just do a more general search. But in sociology, it is generally important to know what is sociology and what isn't, and put them in explicit but separated conversation, especially when the journal you are submitting to is a generalist sociology journal like <em>Social Forces</em> or <em>Qualitative Sociology</em> or <em>Sociological Forum</em> etc.<br /><br />In any case, I hope this is useful and helps you figure out your own literature search methods. Happy searching (and reading)!</div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Plagiarism: When to Cite to Avoid it]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/plagiarism-when-to-cite-to-avoid-it]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/plagiarism-when-to-cite-to-avoid-it#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 21:00:16 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/plagiarism-when-to-cite-to-avoid-it</guid><description><![CDATA[This post is about how to avoid plagiarism when bringing direct quotes into your writing. TLDR: if you copy and paste 3+ words from any source, just put quotation marks around it and provide a page number citation, and nobody has to have a giant headache over your work.      You definitely need to cite, with a page number, for example &ldquo;(Davis 1995:4)&rdquo;, IF you use any direct quotes in your writing. It is plagiarism and is a major academic offense if you include other people&rsquo;s ex [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">This post is about how to avoid plagiarism when bringing direct quotes into your writing. TLDR: if you copy and paste 3+ words from any source, just put quotation marks around it and provide a page number citation, and nobody has to have a giant headache over your work.</div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span style="color:rgb(62, 62, 62); font-weight:400">You definitely need to cite, with a page number, for example &ldquo;(Davis 1995:4)&rdquo;, </span><strong style="color:rgb(62, 62, 62)">IF you use any direct quotes in your writing.</strong><span style="color:rgb(62, 62, 62); font-weight:400"> It is plagiarism and is a major academic offense if you include other people&rsquo;s exact words in your writing and fail to cite with quotes and a page number. The most common plagiarism case I see (</span><strong style="color:rgb(62, 62, 62)">and I see it almost every semester</strong><span style="font-weight: 400;">) is when someone takes exact words from a reading and <strong style=""><font color="#a82e2e">doesn&rsquo;t put quotation marks around them and doesn&rsquo;t include a page citation</font></strong>, even though they include the vaguer citation.</span>&nbsp;<br /><br />So let&rsquo;s use this passage as an example, from Davis (1995) (see the reference at the end of this guide) (the following is a direct passage from his article):<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#3a96b8">&ldquo;Once again, both politicians and the press have allowed the essential landuse issue&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled proliferation of fire suburbs&mdash;to be camouflaged in a neutral discourse of natural hazards and public safety.&rdquo;</font> (this is from p.33 of his article).<br /><br />So let&rsquo;s then imagine you want to incorporate that idea into your writing.<br />&nbsp;<br />So e.g., this is WRONG/PLAGIARISM (<strong>This is the most common form of plagiarism I see</strong>): <br /><br /><font color="#a82e2e">As Davis argues, politicians and the press have allowed the essential landuse issue&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled proliferation of fire suburbs&mdash;to be camouflaged in a neutral discourse of natural hazards and public safety (Davis 1995). This is the most common form of plagiarism I see, and as I said above, I see it very often. What has happened here is that there is a citation, but this text is a direct quote, so it needs quotation marks and a page number in the citation.</font><br />&nbsp;<br />This is the CORRECT/<strong>NON-</strong>PLAGIARIZED way to deal with that last sentence: <br /><br /><font color="#248d6c">As Davis argues, &ldquo;politicians and the press have allowed the essential landuse issue&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled proliferation of fire suburbs&mdash;to be camouflaged in a neutral discourse of natural hazards and public safety&rdquo; (Davis 1995:33).</font><br />&nbsp;<br />This is also CORRECT: <br /><br /><font color="#248d6c">As Davis (1993:33) argues, &ldquo;politicians and the press have allowed the essential landuse issue&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled proliferation of fire suburbs&mdash;to be camouflaged in a neutral discourse of natural hazards and public safety&rdquo;.</font><br />&nbsp;<br />But you shouldn&rsquo;t have that many direct quotes in most social science assignments. If you have like 10 or something for a term paper, that is fine. But if there are large parts of your paper that are just quoted text, that&rsquo;s a problem. Usually, when I see people using a lot of direct quotes, it means they haven&rsquo;t really understood a source.<br />&nbsp;<br />A good general rule is if you are using <strong>3 or more words in order</strong> from the sentence you are trying to paraphrase, then you need to quote it and put a page number in the citation.<br />&nbsp;<br />So this, for example, is also WRONG/PLAGIARISM: &nbsp;<br /><br /><font color="#a82e2e">As Davis (1993:33) argues, politicians and the press &ldquo;have allowed the essential landuse issue&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled proliferation of fire suburbs&mdash;to be camouflaged in a neutral discourse of natural hazards and public safety&rdquo;. It is plagiarism because "<strong>politicians and the press</strong>" should also be part of the quotation.</font><br />&nbsp;<br />This is also WRONG/PLAGIARISM: <br /><br /><font color="#a82e2e">As Davis (1993) argues, politicians and the press have enabled the problematic land use&mdash;the rampant, uncontrolled expansion of fire neighbourhoods&mdash;to be hidden in a neutral discourse of natural risks and safety. Why is that wrong? Because in that sentence, all the person has done is changed out some of the words of the sentence&mdash;the whole sentence is clearly still basically copy and pasted.</font><br />&nbsp;<br />Do NOT copy and paste someone else&rsquo;s sentence into your writing, change a few words or rearrange the sentence a bit, and call it finished. That&rsquo;s still plagiarism. The syntax is still 100% plagiarized, even if a few of the words are different.<br />&nbsp;<br />A better approach: Either just use quotation marks and give a page number (really, not that hard!!!) or: read the thing you want to cite. Wait 15 seconds to 3 minutes. Then write what it said. You will likely use different words than the words the source used but will still be able to convey the idea that you want to write about. This is a method I've sometimes used for not plagiarizing, when I want to paraphrase rather than use a direct quote. When I use direct quotes, I <em>always</em> put quotations around the quote and provide a page number citation. This also means you have to take notes in a way where you keep the page numbers. I have a note-taking method where I always write the page numbers for direct quotes beside any such quotes in my notes. Then if I want to use a direct quote I don&rsquo;t have to go back to the source, I can just use my notes.<br />&nbsp;<br />Basically, <strong>write in your own words, and if you do use a direct quote, use quotation marks and give a page number</strong>. Please, save everyone a headache. Some online sources will not have a clear page number, but just do your best at an estimate of the page number or at the very least make sure to include the quotation marks and make a footnote or something indicating that there are no page numbers for this source (thus showing that you understand they should be included with direct quotes).<br /><br />Avoiding plagiarism is not difficult. Please, for the sake of everyone not wasting their time, avoid it.<br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Good Writing: Basics]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/good-writing-basics]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/good-writing-basics#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 20:21:13 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/good-writing-basics</guid><description><![CDATA[Many students come to university without a strong grasp of academic writing style conventions. Some of them are also not well-known, such as around Indigenous peoples. Here I provide some of the rules of academic writing that are often assessed but not as often taught.&nbsp;      If you want to get a sense of other style conventions, beyond what I talk about here, a good guide is Strunk and White, Elements of Style (a book).Affect&nbsp;"Affect" is almost always used as a verb, while "effect" is  [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">Many students come to university without a strong grasp of academic writing style conventions. Some of them are also not well-known, such as around Indigenous peoples. Here I provide some of the rules of academic writing that are often assessed but not as often taught.&nbsp;</div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">If you want to get a sense of other style conventions, beyond what I talk about here, a good guide is Strunk and White, Elements of Style (a book).<br /><br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Affect&nbsp;</font><br />"Affect" is almost always used as a verb, while "effect" is almost always used as a noun.<br />&nbsp;<br />For example:<br />&nbsp;<br />Sea level rise from climate change will <strong>affect </strong>many people.<ul><li>Sea level rise is &ldquo;doing&rdquo; something here, so &ldquo;affect&rdquo; is being used as a verb.</li></ul> &nbsp;<br />One <strong>effect</strong> of climate change will be sea level rise.<ul><li>Here effect is being used as a noun: sea level rise is some-&ldquo;thing&rdquo; that will happen.</li></ul> &nbsp;<br />To get a more complete explanation, see:<br />&nbsp;<br /><a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/affect-vs-effect-usage-difference">https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/affect-vs-effect-usage-difference</a><br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Apostrophes&nbsp;</font><br />(e.g., the mistake of "iPhones&rsquo;s are framed")<br />&nbsp;<br />I think this site is useful for reviewing apostrophe use: <a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/apostrophe/">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/apostrophe/</a><br />&nbsp;<br />There are many apostrophe errors in student writing. If you're new to academic writing, you will need to practice. You probably will not get it perfect, and that&rsquo;s ok!<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044">Assertions vs. If/Then</font><br />In general, it's best to try to avoid saying we "need to" or we "must" or we "should" do something unless you say what we need to or must do it "for". So instead of an assertion, we would have an "if, then" format to the sentence. The sociologist&rsquo;s job (*I am a sociologist, and teach sociology) is to tell people what will happen in the social world "if" certain conditions exist. We can have personal opinions about what should happen, but the sociologist&rsquo;s job is to say what will likely happen in particular conditions. The "if, then" format reflects this. For example, say a study shows that environmental education in childhood leads to adults later supporting environmental stewardship actions. Then you could say, &ldquo;if&rdquo; we want to have a society where more people are engaging in stewardship actions, &ldquo;then&rdquo; we &ldquo;must&rdquo; give schools more funding for environmental education.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Breadth and Depth</font><br />One thing to keep in mind, which is important in all academic writing, is balancing breadth and depth. Sometimes, undergraduate papers include a bit too much breadth and not enough depth. By this I mean that there are many concepts <em>mentioned</em>, but definitions are more scarce and deep engagement with the concepts is also scarce.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Citations to more than one source: Combine them all within one set of parentheses&nbsp;</font><br />It is conventional in academic writing style to combine all sources within one set of parentheses if you want to cite more than one source at the end of a sentence. Sounds straightfoward, but many undergraduates miss this.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>For example, this is not correct in terms of academic conventions:</strong><br />&nbsp;<br />When people participate in a playful activity, such as birdwatching, they often gain a moral commitment to taking care of aspects of that activity, such as people who enjoy birdwatching becoming bird conservationists (Bargheer 2018) (Cherry 2019).<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>But this is correct:</strong><br />&nbsp;<br />When people participate in a playful activity, such as birdwatching, they often gain a moral commitment to taking care of aspects of that activity, such as people who enjoy birdwatching becoming bird conservationists (Bargheer 2018; Cherry 2019).<br />&nbsp;<br />The exact punctuation separating individual sources within the set of parentheses won&rsquo;t always be the same. Sometimes it is a semicolon, other times it is a comma. You can check the rules of the citation style you are using to find out which punctuation is appropriate, or just use software like Zotero to automatically format it.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Colloquial&nbsp;</font><br />Try to not be too colloquial. In academic writing, we try not to be excessively formal, but we try not to be too informal either. It&rsquo;s good to be clear and direct. But it if something sounds too informal, adjust.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Commas&nbsp;</font><br />If you want to use commas as a pause when you are writing a draft, that is ok, but try to edit extra commas out when you are editing. See these links for some tips on how to edit out incorrect commas:<ol><li><a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/index.html">https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/index.html</a></li><li><a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/extended_rules_for_commas.html">https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/extended_rules_for_commas.html</a></li></ol> &nbsp;<br />Sometimes students also have <strong>missing commas</strong>. In general, see these links for some tips on comma use:<br /><br /><ol><li><a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/index.html">https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/index.html</a></li><li><a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/extended_rules_for_commas.html">https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/punctuation/commas/extended_rules_for_commas.html</a></li></ol> &nbsp;<br />Students typically write with some <strong>comma splices,</strong> which you want to avoid. See guides on that here:<br /><br /><ol><li><a href="https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/maybe-you-like-comma-splices-maybe-you-dont">https://www.merriam-webster.com/grammar/maybe-you-like-comma-splices-maybe-you-dont</a></li><li><a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/punctuation-capitalization/comma-splice/">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/punctuation-capitalization/comma-splice/</a></li></ol> &nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Contractions&nbsp;</font><br />It is best to avoid contractions in academic writing. When you are editing, to conform to academic style, change things like &ldquo;don&rsquo;t&rdquo; this to "does not". I understand that it is easier to write contractions when you&rsquo;re in the middle of writing&mdash;I think that is common. But then at the editing stage, remove the contractions.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Clarity&nbsp;</font><br />One thing that I&rsquo;ve learned about writing is that accomplished writers actually edit their work a great deal, often rewriting things to make them as clear as possible (even re-writing entire papers). I tend to just edit a lot, but I try in general to be as clear as possible so that my writing is accessible as possible. One way to write clearly is to imagine someone you know who you respect and like, and who is a generally educated person (e.g., someone who reads the newspaper, or keeps up with world news, or is a frequent user of a library, or an undergraduate in their 3rd or 4th years of university) but who doesn&rsquo;t know about this exact topic. Then I imagine writing for that person, writing in a way that I think is as clear as possible. This doesn&rsquo;t mean you have to avoid all specialized terminology. But it does mean that if you do use specialized terms, that you define them, and then the reader can continue on reading while understanding it all. Try reading it out loud to yourself as a stage in editing (I do this, not talking loudly, but softly to myself!), and imagining whether this "general educated reader" you&rsquo;re imagining would get your point.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Developing countries&nbsp;</font><br />Typically these days it is more conventional in academic prose to say &ldquo;Global North&rdquo; and &ldquo;Global South&rdquo; since &ldquo;developed&rdquo; and &ldquo;developing&rdquo; melds a theory of modernization onto colonial relations. There is a theory called &ldquo;modernization theory&rdquo; that proposes society moves along a pretty specific track, in all societies everywhere, so that you could have &ldquo;developed&rdquo; and &ldquo;developing&rdquo; countries&mdash;they&rsquo;re just at different points on the modernization track. But Global North and Global South are more consonant with postcolonial and decolonizing studies that take a critical stance toward modernization theory.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">et al.&nbsp;</font><br />"et al." is all lowercase with a period after the "al." This is because &ldquo;al.&rdquo; stands for &ldquo;alia&rdquo;, so it is an abbreviation, and one usually adds a period after abbreviations, like i.e. or U.S. &ldquo;et&rdquo; just means &ldquo;and&rdquo;, so it is *not* an abbreviation. As a result, &ldquo;et al.&rdquo; has no punctuation after the &ldquo;et&rdquo; because &ldquo;et&rdquo; is an entire word.<br />&nbsp;<br />Please see the following resources for the correct use of &ldquo;et al.&rdquo;:<ol><li><a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/et-al/">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/et-al/</a></li><li><a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/et_al.#English">https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/et_al.#English</a></li></ol> &nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">E.g. vs. I.e.&nbsp;</font><br />The use of i.e. is sometimes incorrect in student writing. I.e. is not used to list an example. Rather, &ldquo;i.e.&rdquo; is used to basically say, &ldquo;what I mean is X&rdquo;. In other words, &ldquo;i.e. is used to explain, clarify or rephrase a statement&rdquo; (<a href="https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/i.e." target="_blank">https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/i.e.</a>). E.g., is used to give an example. But why &ldquo;e.g.&rdquo; and not &ldquo;ex.&rdquo;? Where&rsquo;s the &ldquo;g&rdquo; in &ldquo;example&rdquo;? The &ldquo;g&rdquo; comes from the Latin roots: &ldquo;E.g. stands for exempli gratia and means &ldquo;for example.&rdquo; I.e. is the abbreviation for id est and means &ldquo;in other words&rdquo;&rdquo; (<a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/know-your-latin-i-e-vs-e-g/">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/know-your-latin-i-e-vs-e-g/</a>).<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Extra space between paragraphs&nbsp;</font><br />Sometimes when students double space a paper, they add an extra space between the paragraphs, which should be removed. In a double spaced paper, the space between the paragraphs is the same within paragraphs. You just indent each paragraph (you just indent the first line).<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Flow and Writing&nbsp;</font><br />One important aspect of good writing is its flow of the writing. One way to address flow is to read your writing out loud or listen to it by running it through an app like Natural Reader. It is good to write in a way that is also nice to hear. What I mean is that writing should in many ways sound like talking to someone. If it seems so formal that you&rsquo;re not even sure what it means when you say it out loud, then you should edit your writing to sound a bit closer to how it would sound to explain your ideas to a friend. Academic writing shouldn&rsquo;t be too informal, but sometimes students try to make their writing sound so formal that it starts to lose flow. It starts to sound disjointed. So if you think about trying to explain your writing to a friend, and like tell your friend you&rsquo;re going to explain it in a relatively formal way, and then say it out loud to yourself, this will help you edit your writing to make it flow better.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Font &ndash; Using a Standard Font&nbsp;</font><br />In academic writing, it is better to use a standard font, such as Times New Roman, Arial, or Helvetica. It&rsquo;s just an unnecessary distraction to use another font, especially one that is quite noticeable. If you want to write it that way, that&rsquo;s fine, but when you are about to submit, please change the font to a standard font.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Font &ndash; Consistency&nbsp;</font><br />It is conventional in academic (and most types of professional) style to make sure that the font you&rsquo;re using is the same across the whole document. So please make sure your academic documents have the same font throughout.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Fragments&nbsp;</font><br />Student writing tends to be full of sentence fragments. We speak in sentence fragments, often. But it is not correct, in terms of the conventions of academic style, to write with sentence fragments.<br /><br />So part of the conventions of academic style is not writing with sentence fragments. Student writing often has sentence fragments in it &ndash; just something to work on as you continue writing in this academic context. These links describe how to do avoid using sentence fragments as sentences.<ol><li><a href="https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/mechanics/sentence_fragments.html">https://owl.purdue.edu/owl/general_writing/mechanics/sentence_fragments.html</a></li><li><a href="https://writingcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/fragments-and-run-ons/">https://writingcenter.unc.edu/tips-and-tools/fragments-and-run-ons/</a></li></ol> &nbsp;<br />In other words, sometimes students write without complete sentences. A complete sentence is the opposite of a sentence fragment.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Grammarly&mdash;do a Grammarly editing pass&nbsp;</font><br />One way I have used to remove errors from my own writing is Grammarly. There is a website called &ldquo;Grammarly&rdquo; that you can use to check your paper for small grammatical errors before submitting. There is a paid version of Grammarly, but there is a free version and for general document editing. For my purposes, there is no need to use the paid version. I use the free version, which allows me to copy and paste my paper into Grammarly to identify errors that I have missed. I do this before I submit important documents. So I go through the Grammarly report that is produced by the website, and in Microsoft Word I find the errors that Grammarly has pointed out and I think through each one (sometimes the &ldquo;error&rdquo; Grammarly points out is just fine as it is, but for things like spelling, comma use, and other minor errors, Grammarly is great for catching things that I miss). The free version is genuinely helpful for catching little grammatical and spelling mistakes.<br />&nbsp;<br />Alternatively, if you have a good friend who is an excellent English editor (maybe a student who is majoring in English), then they could also read it over for you to help you fix these minor grammatical errors. You could also try methods like saving the document as a PDF and then reading it to yourself out loud, which often also helps identify errors that we miss in Microsoft Word when we are just reading silently in our heads. Finding small grammatical errors is important, because they can add up and tarnish the overall impression someone has of your document&mdash;too many grammatical errors and the document is not very professional as a whole.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Growth Mindset Feedback&nbsp;</font><br />When you take feedback about your writing, it is very important to take it in the spirit of the growth mindset. I realize not all professors have a growth mindset: some of them are pretty harsh and think that you are either smart or not. But I don&rsquo;t believe that. I think that what you do has an enormous influence on who you are and who you will become. There is research behind this idea, it is not just my opinion, as another post on this blog makes clear (e.g., as in the book <em>Mindset: The New Psychology of Success</em>).<br />&nbsp;<br />The following is a comment that I paste into notes I give students when I&rsquo;m critiquing their writing, i.e., telling them about other parts of this chapter. So when you are learning about the conventions of academic style, I think keeping a comment like this in mind is important:<br />&nbsp;<br />Please note that I tend to give a lot of comments. I **don&rsquo;t** do this to indicate something fundamentally wrong with you. Academic, professional, and general writing conventions have to be learned through trial and error. The other way to learn them, beyond trial and error, is to consult books on writing conventions, such as <em>The Elements of Style</em> by Strunk and White. In any case, I&rsquo;ve been in academia for over 15 years, so I&rsquo;ve been learning the conventions for a long time, and so I know more of them than you do. My comments are meant to help you learn the (often hidden and untaught) rules of academia. There are lot of these rules, so it is completely normal to need to learn a lot of them every time you write and get feedback from someone who is more senior to you in academia. I&rsquo;m still learning these rules: when I send my own papers to more senior academics, they always have something to say that can help me learn more of the rules. So the following comments are meant to help you learn a few more of these rules, in the spirit of the growth mindset, **not** to indicate anything fundamentally wrong with you.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Hyphen/Dash&nbsp;</font><br />Sometimes students use hyphens where they should be using dashes, such as when using parenthetical comments. A parenthetical comment&mdash;a common part of writing&mdash;is a part of the sentence that could be separated out with parentheses, even if it is separated by something else in the sentence, such as dashes. That last sentence shows how to use em dashes properly to set off a parenthetical comment.<br /><br />So you can either use em dashes with no spaces, or en dashes with spaces, to set off parenthetical comments in your writing. The hyphen won't do here!<br /><br />First, an example with the &ldquo;em dash&rdquo; (e.g., see: <a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/why-you-should-love-the-em-dash/" target="_blank">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/why-you-should-love-the-em-dash/</a>). This is a dash that is the about the size of an &ldquo;M&rdquo; character (&mdash;). There are keyboard shortcuts for em dashes&mdash;on a Mac, Shift+Option+Hyphen and on Windows, Ctrl+Alt+Hyphen. So when you have a parenthetical comment that you want to break up with dashes, you can do it with an em dash. <br />So for example, if I said this: &ldquo;<strong>Environmental sociology&mdash;the study of the community in the widest sense (Bell and Ashwood 2016)&mdash;can help us understand the issue of climate change</strong>&rdquo;, the &ldquo;em dash&rdquo; is being used to set off the &ldquo;parenthetical comment&rdquo; (<a href="http://www.grammar-once-and-for-all.com/punctuation/parenthetical-expressions/" target="_blank">http://www.grammar-once-and-for-all.com/punctuation/parenthetical-expressions/</a> ). <br /><br />Example with the "en dash": This is almost the same as the em dash situation, but you put spaces around the en dash ("&ndash;"). The en dash is smaller than an em dash, but larger than a hyphen. So you can see this, I'll put an em dash, en dash, and hyphen here: &mdash; &ndash; -<br />Ok so, the example with en dashes:&nbsp;<span>&ldquo;<strong>Environmental sociology &ndash; the study of the community in the widest sense (Bell and Ashwood 2016) &ndash; can help us understand the issue of climate change</strong>&rdquo;. Note the <strong>spaces</strong> around the dashes.<br /><br /><strong>INCORRECT </strong>(hyphens!):&nbsp;&ldquo;Environmental sociology-the study of the community in the widest sense (Bell and Ashwood 2016)-can help us understand the issue of climate change&rdquo;.<br /></span><strong>INCORRECT </strong><span>(hyphens with spaces!): </span><span>&ldquo;Environmental sociology - the study of the community in the widest sense (Bell and Ashwood 2016) - can help us understand the issue of climate change&rdquo;.</span><br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">&ldquo;Our&rdquo; Indigenous people&nbsp;</font><br />The phrase &ldquo;our Indigenous people&rdquo; or &ldquo;our Indigenous&rdquo; is particularly fought against by Indigenous peoples. To say &ldquo;our&rdquo; or "our own" is to imply ownership of Indigenous peoples by Canadians or USians/'Americans', as many Indigenous scholars have emphasized. "Indigenous peoples in the land now known as the United States/Canada" is one option for the correct phrasing here, or "Indigenous peoples of Turtle Island", although not all Indigenous peoples in the land that is sometimes called "Turtle Island" would call it that (so there is plurality in what to call the land, as well). "Indigenous peoples in the land now known as Canada/the United States" works, though, from what I have seen.<br />So also do *not* say "our Indigenous communities". They are "Indigenous Peoples" and they are their own. Indigenous scholars often emphasize this fact &ndash; see for example Chelsea Vowel, <em>Indigenous Writes</em>, a book.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Indigenous Style: Basics&nbsp;</font><br /><br /><em>1. Say &ldquo;Indigenous Peoples&rdquo; or &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo;.</em><br /><br />Unless you are yourself Indigenous and reject the label of &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo;, do not say "natives&rdquo;, &ldquo;Aboriginals&rdquo;, or any other term. The shift in language to &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo; in academic and public discourse happened around the time of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada&rsquo;s final report (Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada 2015) and the publication of the United Nations Declaration of the Rights of Indigenous Peoples (2007). (And&nbsp; if you are Indigenous and are rejecting the term, briefly stating that for your professor/TA will likely be appreciated). &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo; is plural for a reason: there are many different Indigenous groups in Canada, the US, and elsewhere, and reducing them all to one &ldquo;people&rdquo; is problematic. Indigenous scholars often refer to this problematic reducing of Indigenous peoples to one group making them a &ldquo;monolith&rdquo;&mdash;Indigenous peoples are plural peoples.<br />&nbsp;<br />So it is important to say &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo;, rather than any alternatives you may have used *or might think to use*, such as &ldquo;the natives&rdquo;, &ldquo;the aboriginals&rdquo;, &ldquo;the indigenous&rdquo;, &ldquo;the indigenous society&rdquo;, &ldquo;indigenous populations&rdquo;, etc.. To help give some more background to this, in the following quote, <strong>Linda Tuhiwai Smith</strong>, an Indigenous woman, describes why we say &ldquo;Indigenous peoples&rdquo; rather than &ldquo;Indigenous people&rdquo;/&ldquo;indigenous populations&rdquo;/&ldquo;the indigenous&rdquo; or other such terms. *Please note* that she chooses to not capitalize &ldquo;Indigenous&rdquo; here, but she is Indigenous, and that is up to her (as it is for you if you are Indigenous). But you should usually capitalize "Indigenous" just like one capitalizes &ldquo;Peruvian&rdquo;, &ldquo;Canadian&rdquo;, etc.: <strong>"The term &lsquo;indigenous&rsquo; is problematic in that it appears to collectivize many distinct populations whose experiences under imperialism have been vastly different ... &lsquo;indigenous peoples&rsquo; is a relatively recent term which emerged in the 1970s out of the struggles primarily of the American Indian Movement (AIM), and the Canadian Indian Brotherhood. It is a term that internationalizes the experiences, the issues and the struggles of some of the world&rsquo;s colonized peoples. The final &lsquo;s&rsquo; in &lsquo;peoples&rsquo; has been argued for quite vigorously by indigenous activists because of the right of peoples to self-determination. It is also used as a way of recognizing that there are real differences between different indigenous peoples. The term has enabled the collective voices of colonized people to be expressed strategically in the international arena."</strong> (Linda Tuhiwai Smith [1999] 2012, from the book Decolonizing Methodologies, p.7).<br />&nbsp;<br /><em>2. It is conventional in academic writing, and in the broader world to a large degree these days, to capitalize &ldquo;Indigenous&rdquo;.</em><br /><br />Unless you are Indigenous and reject the capitalization of Indigenous, please capitalize it. You wouldn&rsquo;t say, &ldquo;east asian&rdquo; or &ldquo;european&rdquo; when referring a group of people, so we usually don&rsquo;t say &ldquo;indigenous&rdquo;.<br />&nbsp;<br /><em>3. There is no single Indigenous perspective.</em><br /><br />So, don't say things like "the Indigenous perspective".<br /><br />If you&rsquo;re talking about a specific nation, like the Anishinaabe, then you can say &ldquo;an Anishinaabe perspective&rdquo;, but even then, since the Anishinaabe is a confederacy, it would be hard to say what THE single Anishinaabe perspective is. So &ldquo;an&rdquo; Anishinaabe perspective is better than &ldquo;the&rdquo; Anishinaabe perspective because allows you to maintain the plurality of Indigenous peoples in your writing. This is again this issue of avoiding reducing Indigenous peoples to a &ldquo;monolith&rdquo;, to one single entity.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Mac + Ken + dr + ick&nbsp;</font><br />Ok this is a very specific one, if you're learning about/teaching the book&nbsp;<em>Better Safe than Sorry&nbsp;</em>by Norah MacKendrick,&nbsp;but take this as a moment to remember to check to make sure the authors' names you write are correctly spelled:<br /><br />The author of <em>Better Safe than Sorry</em> is Norah &ldquo;MacKendrick&rdquo; (said &ldquo;ma-ken-drick&rdquo;) not &ldquo;McKendrick&rdquo; (which would sound like &ldquo;mic-kendrick&rdquo;), &ldquo;Mackendrick&rdquo; (which would sound like &ldquo;mack-endrick&rdquo;), &ldquo;Macnendrick&rdquo;, or another version! You could think, &ldquo;Mac&rdquo; the computer, &ldquo;Ken&rdquo; the Barbie doll, and &ldquo;dr. ick&rdquo; to think about someone with a PhD (a &ldquo;dr&rdquo;) studying the &ldquo;icky&rdquo; chemicals inside consumer products and food. I don&rsquo;t know if that funny mnemonic device helps, but it&rsquo;s clearly a hard name to spell, based on work students have submitted to me. About a third of students devise very creative spellings and capitalizations of Norah MacKendrick&rsquo;s name. Mac + Ken + dr + ick.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Matter of Fact&nbsp;</font><br />In the academic writing style, it is conventional to cite <u><strong>whenever</strong></u> you say something that makes a claim about how something happens in the world. When a statement is "a matter of fact", it is conventional in social science to provide a citation that shows that this matter of fact about the world is true. How do you know it's true? We want to know. In academic writing, we want to know <u><strong>how you know what you know</strong></u>. We solve this problem with citations.<br />&nbsp;<br />So, anything that you say that is a fact about the world should be cited. Your professors/TAs will thank you if you do that. The writing we do in academic contexts is not journalism, where we assume that the journalist probably checked their sources. The writing we do in academia requires you to tell us where you&rsquo;re getting any information you discuss.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Nounification&nbsp;</font><br />Where you can, it is best when editing to try to remove unnecessary nouns like &ldquo;comprehension&rdquo; or &ldquo;implementation&rdquo;. Try to find a way to use verbs instead: &ldquo;comprehend&rdquo; and &ldquo;implement&rdquo; rather than &ldquo;comprehension&rdquo; and &ldquo;implementation&rdquo;. It takes some restructuring of the sentence, but it can usually be done. This is one of the principles of good writing style.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Parenthetical comments and commas&nbsp;</font><br /><font color="#2a2a2a">If you make a &ldquo;parenthetical comment,&rdquo; use commas to set it off. Parenthetical comments are conventionally enclosed within commas (a comma on each side of the text). A way to find out if something in the middle of any sentence is a parenthetical comment is that you can check what would happen if you took the part of the sentence out&mdash;would you still have a complete sentence? If so, then you have likely found a parenthetical comment. Or, could you put the text in the middle of the sentence within parentheses, and then the sentence would still make sense? Then it's a parenthetical comment. With parenthetical comments, you can take them out of the sentence and you would still have a complete sentence. You can review this grammatical issue here:<br /><br /><a href="http://www.grammar-once-and-for-all.com/punctuation/parenthetical-expressions/" target="_blank">http://www.grammar-once-and-for-all.com/punctuation/parenthetical-expressions/</a></font><br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5" color="#da8044">Periods and Citations&nbsp;</font><br />The position of the period in relationship to a citation is an academic writing convention that is important to learn. The period comes after the citation, not before.<br />&nbsp;<br />So in academic writing, this is **incorrect** in terms of the convention of how to use periods in relation to the citation:<br />&nbsp;<br />When people participate in a playful activity, such as birdwatching, they often gain a moral commitment to taking care of aspects of that activity, such as people who enjoy birdwatching becoming bird conservationists. (Bargheer 2018; Cherry 2019)<br />&nbsp;<br />And this is the **correct** version (the citations here are in American Sociological Association style):<br />&nbsp;<br />When people participate in a playful activity, such as birdwatching, they often gain a moral commitment to taking care of aspects of that activity, such as people who enjoy birdwatching becoming bird conservationists (Bargheer 2018; Cherry 2019).<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5" color="#da8044">Plagiarism&nbsp;</font><br />In general, if an article/book/website has a sentence in it, you cannot simply copy and paste that sentence into your paper, change a few words in the sentence, and leave it at that. Any sentence that has been copy and pasted into your paper needs quotes around it and then a page number in the citation (no page numbers for websites, obviously). IF YOU COPY AND PASTE, JUST CITE IT. PLEASE. SAVE US ALL THE HEADACHE.<br /><br />You need to use your own wording if you are <strong>not</strong> going to use quotation marks. In general, avoiding using THREE words in a row from another person. Two words is ok. But if you have two words and then you change one word and then two more, etc., for a whole sentence, that is still plagiarism&mdash;in general, just don&rsquo;t copy and paste other peoples&rsquo; sentences into your paper <u><strong>unless you are going to use quotation marks and provide a page citation, which is perfectly fine to do</strong></u>. Better to make a citation error than to plagiarize.<br /><br />To avoid plagiarism, what you can do is this: read the thing you want to cite. Then, without looking at it, write out what you think it said. It is almost certain that you won&rsquo;t be able to remember the exact wording and you&rsquo;ll put it into your own words. Or just use quotes around the copy and pasted text and list the page number, in the format of the citation style you need to use. In any case, you need to find a way to avoid this kind of plagiarism.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5" color="#da8044">Proofread&nbsp;</font><br />In general, I encourage you to proofread. I usually read through what I&rsquo;ve written at least twice before submitting something. The number of errors we don&rsquo;t think we are making when we&rsquo;re writing is often surprising!<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044"><font size="5">Quote as a whole sentence</font></font><br />It is conventional in academic writing to introduce all quotes with your own writing. So something like, As [author] discusses, &ldquo;quote&rdquo;, is the minimum amount of your own writing that should be included. So, e.g., you could say:<br />&nbsp;<br />As Bourdieu (1990:55) argues, &ldquo;the habitus is an infinite capacity for generating products &ndash; thoughts, perceptions, expressions and actions.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br /><u><strong>You include some of your own writing at the start of the sentence</strong></u>, so that the sentence isn&rsquo;t entirely a quote from someone else.&nbsp;<br /><br />Do NOT just paste in an entire quote as a sentence. That is not the convention.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5" color="#da8044">Quotes need Page Number Citations&nbsp;</font><br />If you quote a source, in the sense that it is a direct quote, word for word, citation styles require you to add a page number within your citation.<br />&nbsp;<br />So, to give an example, instead of this:<br />&nbsp;<br />The word &ldquo;birding&rdquo; refers to, &ldquo;the active walking around, looking for birds, and identifying them by sight and sound&rdquo; (Cherry 2<font color="#c23b3b">019).</font><br />&nbsp;<br />We would do this:<br />&nbsp;<br />The word &ldquo;birding&rdquo; refers to, &ldquo;the active walking around, looking for birds, and identifying them by sight and sound&rdquo; (Cherry 20<font color="#5fa233">19:18).</font><br />&nbsp;<br />(That quote is from this book: Cherry, Elizabeth R. 2019. For the Birds: Protecting Wildlife through the Naturalist Gaze. New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press.)<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5" color="#da8044">Reference List&nbsp;</font><br />It is conventional in academic style to have the reference list ordered by author, alphabetically.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#da8044" size="5">Reference List Indent&nbsp;</font><br />The most conventional way to report a reference list is to provide a &lsquo;hanging indent&rsquo;. If you search YouTube or your favourite search engine for "hanging indent", you can see some examples. The first line of each reference should start at the same place as the text above it starts. Then the second/third lines are indented. So the first line should start about 1 inch or so from the margin, just like your text. The first line of the references should start at the same distance from the edge of the page as the title, such as &ldquo;References&rdquo;. The first line of each reference shouldn&rsquo;t like &ldquo;dip&rdquo; into the edge of the margin. It should start at the same distance from the edge of the page as the title of the reference list, and then the indent comes only in the second/third lines.<br />&nbsp;<br />So for example, we could have these references in a reference list:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-14-52-22_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span>And each one is the same distance from the edge of the page as the title, which is in this case is &ldquo;References&rdquo;. They don&rsquo;t &ldquo;dip&rdquo; into the margin.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font color="#da8044" size="5">Scare Quotes&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>Don&rsquo;t use quotation marks in the &ldquo;scare quotes&rdquo; way, like I just did there with the term &ldquo;scare quotes&rdquo;. This is a common error in undergraduate writing. In general, when you have a concept to discuss, you don&rsquo;t need to put it in quotation marks. If you are using quotation marks as scare quotes, to show that you have some kind of critique of the idea, it is better to make the argument rather than using scare quotes to make the argument.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">Semi-colons&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>Semicolons are often used incorrectly in undergraduate writing (review: <a href="https://www.grammarly.com/blog/semicolon/" target="_blank">https://www.grammarly.com/blog/semicolon/</a>). In general, when you are an undergraduate, I recommend not using semicolons. They are very difficult to use properly, even for professors, who often need professional editors to help them edit semicolons properly. Incorrectly used semicolons can really distract from seeing clearly what the paper is saying. For some reason, undergraduates try to use a lot of semicolons in their writing, even though it is such a difficult punctuation mark to use.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">Subscript&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>The &ldquo;2&rdquo; in &ldquo;CO2&rdquo; should be subscripted, as should the &ldquo;2&rdquo; in &ldquo;N2O&rdquo;, if you use either of these. E.g., if you look up CO2 etc. on Wikipedia they&rsquo;ll have it subscripted. It&rsquo;s the normal way to represent things in chemistry, and we need to follow those conventions to create good dialogue between disciplines! If chemists insisted on pronouncing &ldquo;Weber&rdquo; as &ldquo;Webber&rdquo; (pronounced &ldquo;Ve-ber&rdquo;), sociologists would be up in arms.<br /><br />(I can't use subscripts in the formatting tool on this blog. If this is not clear, please look it up).</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">This what?&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>If you use &ldquo;This&rdquo; at the start of the sentence, you should say something about what &ldquo;This&rdquo; is. So instead of saying something like,</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>&ldquo;The sociological imagination involves thinking about the structural level, such as corporate lobbying efforts. This is an important part of how environmental problems continue to occur.&rdquo;</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>You could say,</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>&ldquo;The sociological imagination involves thinking about the structural level, such as corporate lobbying efforts. This **corporate lobbying** is an important part of how environmental problems continue to occur.&rdquo;</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>So if you use &ldquo;This&rdquo; at the start of the sentence, that is ok. But answer: &ldquo;This what?&rdquo;</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font color="#da8044" size="5">Title of a book italics and Title Case&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>When you include the title of a book in your writing, it is more conventional in academic style to italicize it, and put it into title case. If you don&rsquo;t know what title case is, it is the style where most words have the first letter capitalized.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>So there is a book called </span><em>For the Birds: Protecting Wildlife Through the Naturlaist Gaze. </em><span>If you are referring to this book and want to say its title in your writing, it would not be conventional in terms of academic writing style to say something like,</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>&ldquo;In the book for the birds: protecting wildlife through the naturalist gaze, Elizabeth Cherry discusses how the pleasure of observing birds is an important part of protecting the environment&rdquo;.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>Rather, to conform to academic style conventions, you would put the book&rsquo;s title in title case and you would italicize it saying,</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>&ldquo;In the book </span><em>For the Birds: Protecting Wildlife through the Naturalist Gaze,</em><span> Elizabeth Cherry discusses how the pleasure of observing birds is an important part of protecting the environment&rdquo;.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>So with book titles, if you really want to say them in the text of your writing, to use academic style conventions, you don&rsquo;t put them in quotes, and you don&rsquo;t just leave them lowercase. You would use quotes only for more minor publications like journal articles or newspaper articles, and for all publications you would use title case.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>That being said, at the same time, it isn&rsquo;t usually needed at all to say a source&rsquo;s full title in your writing. I realize textbooks often do this, so undergraduates may think it is conventional in academic writing. But in most academic writing we do not write out the full title of something. The reader just wants to know what the source says; they don&rsquo;t really need to know what the source is called.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">Title case when you&rsquo;re writing a title for a policy brief or other professional document&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>You should use title case when making a title for a professional document. Title case means that you capitalize the first letter of most words. Sentence case, which is the &lsquo;case&rsquo; I&rsquo;m using in this sentence, only involves capitalizing the first letter in the sentence, other than proper nouns and the pronoun &ldquo;I&rdquo;. I think you know what lower case and upper case is. In general, then, just be careful about case when you write a title. You can sometimes use sentence case in a title, but then you should also capitalize the first letter of the word that comes after a colon, if you put a colon in the middle of your title, as many people do.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">Title of an article in your writing</font></span><br /><span>When you include the title of an article in your writing, such as a journal article or news article, it should be in title case, meaning that each major word of the title has the first letter capitalized. And then it should be in quotes, not italicized. These guidelines for capitalization and italics are consistent across APA, American Sociological Association, and Chicago Author-Date styles.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>That being said, at the same time, it isn&rsquo;t usually needed at all to say a source&rsquo;s full title in your writing. I realize textbooks often do this, so undergraduates may think it is conventional in academic writing. But in most academic writing we do not write out the full title of something. The reader just wants to know what the source says; they don&rsquo;t really need to know what the source is called. So it is best to just put the source in a citation at the end of your sentence and not mention the title of the source, so that we can focus on the point you are making, rather than the title of one of your sources.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font size="5" color="#da8044">Whereas&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>&ldquo;Whereas&rdquo; is often used incorrectly in undergraduate writing. In general, there are two correct ways to use the word &ldquo;whereas&rdquo;. In one correct way, &ldquo;whereas&rdquo; comes at the start of the sentence, and is always of this general format: &ldquo;Whereas X, Y&rdquo;, where Y is a contrast to X. So for example, &ldquo;Whereas the term &ldquo;climate change&rdquo; may appear to mean that global warming is no longer happening, the term is meant to attest to the complexity of climate even while the Earth&rsquo;s annual temperature is still rising.&rdquo; So the two parts of the sentence, when using &ldquo;whereas&rdquo; this way, are always to some degree a contrast. So the general form is something like, &ldquo;Whereas X (something that has one quality), Y (something that has the opposite quality)&rdquo;. The &ldquo;Y&rdquo; is usually more true than the &ldquo;X&rdquo;, as in the sentence that was used as an example there. The other correct use of &ldquo;whereas&rdquo; is also in this contrast sort of way, but mid-sentence (e.g., see https://grammarist.com/usage/whereas/). In any case, most students use &ldquo;whereas&rdquo; at the start of sentences without thinking about this required contrast when using &ldquo;whereas&rdquo;. Make sure you check to make sure you&rsquo;re using it properly, if you choose to use it. If you use it incorrectly, the document looks less professional.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span><font color="#da8044" size="5">Year in Citations&nbsp;</font></span><br /><span>In APA, Chicago Author-Date, and American Sociological Association styles, the year should always be reported. Usually, for a source that might appear to not have a date, finding a date is possible, such as in looking at the url for a website or just using the current year for websites that are themselves current and continuously updated.<br /><br />There you have the most common errors I see in undergraduate writing. I hope this post reads ok &ndash; I developed these as standard comments I give to undergraduate students in their writing, since these errors come up so often. I did work on the writing so that it sounds more general. In any case, I hope this is helpful! If there's something I should add, please let me know (tylerbateman@unm.edu as of 1 Sept 2026).</span>&#8203;<br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Self-Compassion: The Importance of being Kind to Yourself]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/self-compassion-the-importance-of-being-kind-to-yourself]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/self-compassion-the-importance-of-being-kind-to-yourself#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 20:08:57 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/self-compassion-the-importance-of-being-kind-to-yourself</guid><description><![CDATA[So the growth mindset (discussed in the previous post on this blog) says that you can improve your skills. But if you take a bit too much to that idea, you might burn out. Burning out meaning that you get so exhausted from trying to improve in many areas of your life that you get very anxious, depressed, stressed out, angry, etc. So yes, it is indeed the case that you can improve your skills at what you want to improve at. But it is also important, as you do that, to be kind to yourself.      Wh [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><span>So the growth mindset (discussed in the previous post on this blog) says that you can improve your skills. But if you take a bit too much to that idea, you might burn out. Burning out meaning that you get so exhausted from trying to improve in many areas of your life that you get very anxious, depressed, stressed out, angry, etc. </span><span>So yes, it is indeed the case that you can improve your skills at what you want to improve at. But it is also important, as you do that, to be kind to yourself.</span></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">What does it mean to be kind to yourself? The first place to look is often the self-talk that we have with ourselves. Do you find yourself saying things to yourself like, &ldquo;You&rsquo;re such an idiot!&rdquo; That is an example of self-critical internal talk, and is not self-compassionate.<br />&nbsp;<br />One of the people who has done the most psychological research on the topic of self-compassion is Kristin Neff. She has two excellent books on the topic, <em>Self-Compassion </em>and <em>Fearless Self-Compassion</em>. She also has, with another author, Christopher Germer, a workbook for self-compassion. There is also an 8-week Mindful Self-Compassion program, if you have the money and time, in which you can learn about this in a group with others. The Center for Mindful Self-Compassion has various trainings to help people develop self-compassion.<br />&nbsp;<br />Kristin Neff&nbsp; says self-compassion involves 3 elements: mindfulness, having a sense of common humanity, and self-kindness.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font color="#248d6c" size="5">Mindfulness&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />Neff starts by saying that self-compassion involves mindfulness because, &ldquo;you can&rsquo;t heal what you can&rsquo;t feel&rdquo;. Meaning that you need to be able to notice what is happening to you in your life if you are going to be able to be self-compassionate in a good way. Mindfulness has a lot of meanings of course in the 21st century. But let&rsquo;s just say, for the purposes of brevity here, that it means just noticing your bodily sensations, what you are hearing, and what you are seeing, without feeding any storylines pop up as you notice those things.<br />&nbsp;<br />Being able to pay attention to the moment like this has many benefits, and there are many online resources, such as the transcribed talks at the Ottawa Zen community called White Wind Zen Centre (https://wwzc.org/texts-and-translations), if you want to learn more from a source that links all the way back to the founding of Buddhism. If you want a place to start there, I recommend the Dharma Talk called The Meaning of Mindfulness (https://wwzc.org/dharma-text/meaning-mindfulness). Another good source is the Insight Meditation Center in Redwood City, California, which has an enormous library of audio talks about mindfulness (https://www.audiodharma.org/). You could also read about how Neff talks about it in her books, or there are 1000 other resources these days, but I recommend getting them from Buddhist sources which incorporate millennia of practical research and development. I think another good introduction is a book by Brad Warner called <em>Letters to a Dead Friend about Zen</em>.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5" color="#248d6c">Common humanity&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />Neff talks about common humanity as an important part of self-compassion. She does this because the opposite &ndash; feeling like you are all alone and the problem you are facing only applies to you &ndash; causes serious mental health issues, which was well-documented in research before she wrote about common humanity. Realizing that everyone fails at what they think is important sometimes is critical. It is part of life to go through hard times. Everyone goes through such times. So it is important to not feel like you&rsquo;re the only person in the world having the certain issue you have &ndash; feeling connected to others is a critical part of working through difficulties, even if they are people you have never met.<br />&nbsp;<br />My own critical take on this part is: why does this have to apply only to humanity? As someone who has developed relationships with wild creatures and who thinks about those relationships professionally, it is certainly out of seeing the similarities between us that compassion develops for the plight of, say, endangered species. In general, I do not understand why we need to restrict our circle of understanding to humans. Animals of all kinds try to do things that sometimes fail. Mammals especially are known to mourn for lost loved ones, such as among elephants and various whale and dolphin species, and not only them. I understand that humans try to do things that other animals don&rsquo;t try to do, like get a job, but I wish she just had like one sentence in her books saying that we can expand our circle of concern to all creatures.&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5" color="#248d6c">Self-Kindness&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />Neff also says self-kindness is part of self-compassion. In some ways, really, it is a sort of synonym. What is kindness? One way that people who write about self-compassion say that you can identify kindness is by imagining what a really good friend would say to comfort, console, and encourage you.<br />&nbsp;<br />If you fail at something, and then find yourself saying things like, &ldquo;you&rsquo;re such an idiot&rdquo;, then there is some work you could do on your internal self-talk. I&rsquo;ve certainly had my problems with excessively critical self-talk, and I&rsquo;d like to say they are all in the past, but it still happens often. So when you mess up, self-kindness is trying to talk in your mind to yourself in ways that are consoling and encouraging. So instead of explaining your failure by saying, &ldquo;You&rsquo;re such an idiot&rdquo;, you could explain the failure by saying something like, &ldquo;You tried very hard, but [describe some circumstance that made it very hard to succeed in this], and [maybe describe some method you used that wasn&rsquo;t effective], but [to improve maybe now I&rsquo;ll try this other thing]&rdquo;. Something like that could be how you explain your failing with kinder self-talk. So you can see how the growth mindset fits into this, if you read my previous post. Instead of explaining your failures based on fundamental and horrible flaws about yourself, you explain them by reference to the circumstances you have to work through and the methods you are using, and to find a hopeful path to the future you make a plan about how to succeed in the future, learning from the failure.<br />&nbsp;<br />So the growth mindset and self-compassion are actually linked. When you fail at something, the self-talk you have can be about how you can improve for the future, rather than (erroneously) depicting yourself as fundamentally wrong/bad/problematic. When you mess up, you can say, &ldquo;Ok, I was trying my best but it didn&rsquo;t work out. What can I improve to do better next time?&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />In her book <em>Self-Compassion</em>, Neff talks about bumping into a friend and then asking her friend if she was pregnant, and her friend said, &ldquo;I&rsquo;ve just put on some weight lately&rdquo;. Neff was very embarrassed, but at that moment, she could have really given herself a hard time with harsh and mean internal talk. Instead, she has learned how to comfort herself with kind internal talk instead of being mean to herself internally. (Also, of course, it's ok to have put on weight lately! She didn't mean to sound judgmental in an often anti-fat society, but anyway). <br /><br />So the point of bringing this up is to say: even when you make a mistake, you can be kind to yourself. And try to rectify the situation as much as you can. But you could say something like, &ldquo;<font color="#3387a2">I don&rsquo;t want to make people feel bad. I&rsquo;m against anti-fatness that stigmatizes people who have been gaining weight. But some people are understandably very sensitive to being told they are gaining weight, especially through something that can seem like a joke like &lsquo;are you pregnant&rsquo;. In any case, in the future I&rsquo;m not going to assume someone is pregnant and ask them about this, given that we are living in a world that is so anti-fat. I&rsquo;ll wait for them to bring it up</font>&rdquo;. So you make some resolution that helps you to avoid the situation in the future, and you don&rsquo;t explain it by referring to your idiocy or some other fundamental horrible quality that you might ascribe to yourself in that moment.<br />&nbsp;<br />So compassion has to do with what we do when we are struggling or experiencing difficulty. Compassion means treating yourself, during hard times, kindly. And a quick path to it is asking yourself: what the best friend say to me at this time? That way, you start to be that best friend <strong><u>to yourself</u></strong>. It is of course great if you can find really supportive relationships. But you can always be a very supportive relationship for yourself, and you can be there for yourself 24/7, unlike any other person probably.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5" color="#248d6c">Facing Discrimination&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />This is all important beyond academia too. For example, self-Judgment leads to worse mental health outcomes in the face of discrimination (Wyatt and Ampadu 2022). Self-Care, in contrast, is associated with greater wellness in the face of discrimination.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5" color="#248d6c">A three step self-compassion process&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />I appreciate the film&nbsp;<em>In the Heights</em>. In the film, they talk about how the different people in the community have a sue&ntilde;ito, a &ldquo;little dream&rdquo;. Someone has a dream in the film, for example, to become a fashion designer. Another person dreams of moving to the Dominican Republic.<br />&nbsp;<br />I think the first step for self-compassion is figuring out what your &lsquo;little dream is&rsquo;, or said in another way, what your ideal life is. What do you want your life to be like? It doesn't have to be a fully fleshed out grand vision of saving the world single-handedly while being wealthy and living to 100 in perfect health. But just some little dream you have, at least some dream developed. If you don&rsquo;t know where you&rsquo;re going, you&rsquo;re not going to get there.<br />&nbsp;<br />So I think the first step is blocking out some time every week to think about what your ideal life is, what your &lsquo;sue&ntilde;ito&rsquo; is. Once you&rsquo;ve done that for a few weeks, you&rsquo;ll have some parts of it. But it is probably an endless thing, so doing this every so often, until you figure it out, is maybe a good idea. It will take a long time to figure it all out, probably! It is really important to have a vision for where you want to go.<br />&nbsp;<br />Then, I think, you&rsquo;re ready to do self-compassion. I think this is the three steps of self-compassion, after you know what your ideal life / sue&ntilde;ito is:<br />&nbsp;<br />So: You encounter a failure in your life. You mess up. You fail. You don&rsquo;t meet your expectations. Then you do self compassion:<br />&nbsp;<br />1. Sympathy (&ldquo;I&rsquo;m really sorry this happened. You tried your best given everything. You have a lot going on and you&rsquo;re doing your best to make everything work out, and I&rsquo;m sorry this didn&rsquo;t go well.&rdquo;)<br />&nbsp;<br />2. Think of your &ldquo;little dream&rdquo; / sue&ntilde;ito (i.e., does it matter enough to make a change?)<br />&nbsp;<br />3. Learn from the experience and make a plan to improve the skills you need to move closer to your &ldquo;little dream&rdquo; (growth mindset move)<br />&nbsp;<br />I haven&rsquo;t read about that exact process in any book. But I think that is basically how you do it!<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5">Further Reading</font></strong><br /><br />If you want to read more about self-compassion, here are some resources:<br />&nbsp;<ol><li>Brown, Valerie, Marisela B. Gomez, and Kaira Jewel Lingo. 2024. <em>Healing Our Way Home: Black Buddhist Teachings on Ancestors, Joy, and Liberation</em>. Berkeley, CA: Parallax Press.</li><li>King, Ruth. 2018. Mindful of Race: Transforming Racism from the inside Out. Boulder, CO: Sounds True, Inc.</li><li>Owens, Lama Rod. 2020. <em>Love and Rage: The Path of Liberation through Anger</em>. Berkeley: North Atlantic Books.</li><li>Neff, Kristin. 2015. Self-Compassion: The Proven Power of Being Kind to Yourself. New York, NY: Harper-Collins.</li><li>Neff, Kristin. 2003a. &ldquo;Self-Compassion: An Alternative Conceptualization of a Healthy Attitude toward Oneself.&rdquo; <em>Self and Identity</em> 2(2):85&ndash;101.</li><li>Neff, Kristin. 2003b. &ldquo;The Development and Validation of a Scale to Measure Self-Compassion.&rdquo; <em>Self and Identity</em> 2(3):223&ndash;50.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D. 2011. &ldquo;Self-Compassion, Self-Esteem, and Well-Being.&rdquo; <em>Social and Personality Psychology Compass</em> 5(1):1&ndash;12. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1751-9004.2010.00330.x">10.1111/j.1751-9004.2010.00330.x</a>.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., and Christopher K. Germer. 2013. &ldquo;A Pilot Study and Randomized Controlled Trial of the Mindful Self-Compassion Program.&rdquo; <em>Journal of Clinical Psychology</em> 69(1):28&ndash;44. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1002/jclp.21923">10.1002/jclp.21923</a>.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., Ya-Ping Hsieh, and Kullaya Dejitterat. 2005. &ldquo;Self-Compassion, Achievement Goals, and Coping with Academic Failure.&rdquo; <em>Self and Identity</em> 4(3):263&ndash;87.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., Kristin L. Kirkpatrick, and Stephanie S. Rude. 2007. &ldquo;Self-Compassion and Adaptive Psychological Functioning.&rdquo; <em>Journal of Research in Personality</em> 41(1):139&ndash;54.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., and Pittman McGehee. 2010. &ldquo;Self-Compassion and Psychological Resilience among Adolescents and Young Adults.&rdquo; <em>Self and Identity</em> 9(3):225&ndash;40.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., Kullaya Pisitsungkagarn, and Ya-Ping Hseih. 2008. &ldquo;Self-Compassion and Self-Construal in the United States, Thailand, and Taiwan.&rdquo; <em>Journal of Cross-Cultural Psychology</em> 39(3):267&ndash;85.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., Stephanie S. Rude, and Kristin L. Kirkpatrick. 2007. &ldquo;An Examination of Self-Compassion in Relation to Positive Psychological Functioning and Personality Traits.&rdquo; <em>Journal of Research in Personality</em> 41(4):908&ndash;16. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jrp.2006.08.002">10.1016/j.jrp.2006.08.002</a>.</li><li>Neff, Kristin D., and Roos Vonk. 2009. &ldquo;Self-Compassion versus Global Self-Esteem: Two Different Ways of Relating to Oneself.&rdquo; <em>Journal of Personality</em> 77(1):23&ndash;50.</li><li>Williams, Angel Kyodo, Rod Owens, and Jasmine Syedullah. 2016. <em>Radical Dharma: Talking Race, Love, and Liberation</em>. Berkeley, California: North Atlantic Books.</li><li>Wyatt, Janan P., and Gifty G. Ampadu. 2022. &ldquo;Reclaiming Self-Care: Self-Care as a Social Justice Tool for Black Wellness.&rdquo; <em>Community Mental Health Journal</em> 58(2):213&ndash;21. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1007/s10597-021-00884-9">10.1007/s10597-021-00884-9</a>.</li><li>Yarnell, Lisa M., and Kristin D. Neff. 2013. &ldquo;Self-Compassion, Interpersonal Conflict Resolutions, and Well-Being.&rdquo; <em>Self and Identity</em> 12(2):146&ndash;59. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1080/15298868.2011.649545">10.1080/15298868.2011.649545</a>.</li><li>Zessin, Ulli, Oliver Dickh&auml;user, and Sven Garbade. 2015. &ldquo;The Relationship Between Self&#8208;Compassion and Well&#8208;Being: A Meta&#8208;Analysis.&rdquo; <em>Applied Psychology: Health and Well-Being</em> 7(3):340&ndash;64. doi:<a href="https://doi.org/10.1111/aphw.12051">10.1111/aphw.12051</a>.</li></ol>&nbsp;<br /><strong><font size="5">Video</font></strong><br /><br />YouTube: Dare to Rewire Your Brain for Self-Compassion | Weiyang Xie | TEDxUND (<a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eiEMVA8AIJw">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eiEMVA8AIJw</a>)<br /><br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[The Growth Mindset: The Assumption of this Blog]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/the-growth-mindset-the-assumption-of-this-blog]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/the-growth-mindset-the-assumption-of-this-blog#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 01 Sep 2026 19:32:42 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/the-growth-mindset-the-assumption-of-this-blog</guid><description><![CDATA[This blog in general is premised on the idea that you can improve your skills. But what do we know about whether that is true?      I cannot remember how I first learned about the growth mindset. I somehow stumbled across it when I was an undergraduate student, and I found it very helpful. I had often had debates with friends about whether people could become more intelligent, and it helped to show me, with research, that this was indeed possible.&#8203;Some people in academic environments think [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><span>This blog in general is premised on the idea that you can improve your skills. But what do we know about whether that is true?</span></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span>I cannot remember how I first learned about the growth mindset. I somehow stumbled across it when I was an undergraduate student, and I found it very helpful. I had often had debates with friends about whether people could become more intelligent, and it helped to show me, with research, that this was indeed possible.</span><br /><br />&#8203;Some people in academic environments think that if you are smart, you don&rsquo;t have to study. But the truth is, if you do not study, then you do not receive the grades as you could have received, and you close doors on yourself for your future. Even very smart people need to study &ndash; you ca not know things you have not studied.<br />&nbsp;<br />You become more intelligent when you learn how to study and work more effectively &ndash; research shows this (as reviewed by Dweck, <em>Mindset: The New Psychology of Success</em>). The people who receive high grades in university are those who have learned how to learn, learned how to write well, and who have learned the other skills needed to produce excellent work.<br />&nbsp;<br />Carol Dweck (in her popular book <em>Mindset</em>&nbsp;and in many other publications, such as her academic book <em>Self-Theories</em>) builds on knowledge of neuroplasticity &ndash; neuroplasticity means that your brain changes &ndash; to show that people who learn how to improve at what they do are the people who usually succeed. It is the people who <em><strong>try hard, practice, and improve</strong></em> who are the greatest successes. It is the people who learn from failures who succeed.<br /><br />Something Dweck has found in her research is that about half of people have a growth mindset: when they encounter challenges or failures, they become motivated to learn something new and improve. About half of people, in contrast, have a fixed mindset: when they encounter challenges or failures, they think that they are not meant to do something, and give up. Those with the fixed mindset carry with them a latent understanding of genetic determinism &ndash; they think they are inherently good at certain things and not at others, and that they should stick with what they are good at. In terms of intelligence, people with the fixed mindset believe that they have a fixed amount of intelligence, and that the situations life throws at them will uncover what their level of intelligence is. In contrast, people with the growth mindset think of their skills and intelligence as something that can be improved. What the research on these has found is that what you believe in this context becomes true, since people with the fixed mindset do not try to improve and people with the growth mindset do, and in fact humans have a remarkable amount of neuroplasticity and we can in fact improve over time if we try to.<br />&nbsp;<br />But at the same time, a believe that you can improve isn't enough. The ability to learn from failures is a skill. We are not born with a highly developed ability to learn from failures, failures which are often quite complex and lead us to doubt ourselves. If we want to learn from failures, we have to learn how to learn from failures.&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />Despite my appreciation of the growth mindset idea, I have some reservations about how the growth mindset is usually portrayed. It is not a very structural theory, at least as portrayed by Dweck. As a sociologist, I wonder: who tends to have the growth mindset? Do particular races or particular class groups tend to have it more often, because of social privileges or lack of those privileges? My guess is that social privileges give people more of a sense that they can improve their skills.<br />&nbsp;<br />And who does the growth mindset tend to be more true for, in the real world? People with more social privileges &ndash; such as more time and money on their hands &ndash; have a greater ability to improve their skills. If you want to improve the quality of your writing, but you are struggling to make financial ends meet each month, and are in university and working (perhaps a full time job or multiple part time jobs), you are not going to have much time to look into how exactly one improves their writing skills, and to practice improving their writing, for example. So it seems to me that there are some people, because of structural advantages, who are able to grow more.<br />&nbsp;<br />But I also think that a lack of social privileges does not stop you from having the growth mindset and benefitting from it. I think the most difficult part is getting access to the knowledge of the growth mindset, and which I'm doing here, and many people do in addition to my efforts of course. Once you know this is the way things are, nobody can tell you that you are just not cut out for something. There is real plasticity in how much people can change. You can become more intelligent. You can become more skilled at making professional documents, taking tests and exams, public speaking, reading, and anything else. While your circumstances do matter, recognizing that you are not fixed is liberating, still. Feedback you receive on your work does <strong><u>not</u></strong> reveal whether you are smart or not. Who you happen to be at this moment does <strong><u>not</u></strong> define everything about what you can achieve. Rather, the decisions you make about improving your skills and abilities is what matters most.<br />&nbsp;<br />It is the methods you use, and the skills you have in using those methods, that determine the quality of your academic and other professional work. As a result, this post is essentially the starting point of this entire blog, even though it isn't exactly posted at the beginning of it. If you don&rsquo;t believe that you can improve your skills, abilities, and methods, then there is no point in trying. But there <strong><u>IS</u></strong> a major point in trying. Anyone you see who is succeeding at something has <u><em><strong>methods</strong></em></u> behind what they are doing that are leading to their success. You can learn those methods. You can improve your skill at using those methods. And as a result, you can improve your performance at whatever that thing is.<br />&nbsp;<br />In Carol Dweck&rsquo;s book, <em>Mindset: The New Psychology of Success</em>, she doesn&rsquo;t only focus on academic contexts. She also shows that across many areas of life, such as sports and business, having a growth mindset is a critical feature of success. I think it is an important book, and I recommend reading it. It tells you that you can indeed change a great deal about who you are, if you want to do that. You aren&rsquo;t fixed in how you are at this moment.<br />&nbsp;<br />Despite my appreciation for the <em>Mindset</em> book, I have one other critique of the growth mindset, which is connected to my first critique describe above, about social privileges. This second critique is that in a sense, you are fixed at any given time. Yes, ok, we can all improve our skills and methods. But since we only have a fixed amount of time in the week/day/our life, and there may be many demands on our time, we can only really try to improve in a certain limited number of areas at any one time. We can&rsquo;t become better at everything all at once, because there are only so much time available to us.<br />&nbsp;<br />So the growth mindset is connected to something else I&rsquo;m interested in as a professional/academic method, which is planning. Planning methods are some of the most important tools you have in creating your success. If you want to get better at anything &ndash; using the growth mindset idea as a guide &ndash; you need a plan for it. You need time for it allocated in your week, or some repeating task that you actually get to in your task system. That is only the first step though, because after you make the time or prioritize the task (to improve at whatever you want to improve at), you have to figure out what you are going to do in that time, and not everything you do to try to improve will be equally effective.<br />&nbsp;<br />So, given that there are only so many hours in the week, in a very real sense your abilities are fixed for most things at a given time. But they are not fixed in a genetic way &ndash; that is the point that always still stands, with growth mindset thinking. So do not let anyone tell you that you are just one way, and that you will be that way for the rest of your life. Do not let anyone (including yourself!) judge you as worthless forever because of your performance at any one time. You can improve, even if you can only realistically improve in a certain limited number of areas at any one time.<br />&nbsp;<br />And there is more time in the week than you may be admitting. With careful planning, everyone can find pockets of time in the week to improve their skills.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font color="#248d6c" size="5">Balancing &ldquo;Cultivation&rdquo; and Enjoyment&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />I also want to touch on a critical topic here, which is balancing what I&rsquo;ll call &ldquo;cultivation&rdquo; and enjoyment. &ldquo;Cultivation&rdquo; is what the growth mindset says you can do: you can do things that help you improve. Farmers cultivate plants not necessarily because they are having the best time of their lives, but because the <em><strong>result</strong></em> of the cultivation is a very good thing. For the farmer, it gives them a livelihood. It gives them the financial resources that allow them to live their life, and in many cases, farmers also (or primarily, depending on the context) cultivate food for themselves as well. But you &ldquo;cultivate&rdquo; something for its result, not for the enjoyment it gives you (I'm sure there are many farmers who do appreciate their work, of course, and do enjoy it, though).<br />&nbsp;<br />The &ldquo;growth mindset&rdquo; stuff is cultivation. It is not necessarily fun to learn how to become a better writer, test-taker, public speaker, or reader. But the <em><strong>result</strong></em> of this activity is what we really care about. We want to improve how we do things, and so we engage in activities that help us cultivate ourselves.<br />&nbsp;<br />So if you are doing some of these improvement activities and you&rsquo;re like, &ldquo;this is really not enjoyable at all&rdquo;, that is not a problem. That is normal for cultivation activities. That is the point of talking about this. Maybe you do really enjoy learning about how to improve at something, and then that's great. But if you do not enjoy it, I think that is normal.<br />&nbsp;<br />In this blog, I am not going to only advocate to only do things that aren not enjoyable. Life should be enjoyable! So whenever you are thinking about adding some &ldquo;cultivation&rdquo;-type activities to your week, I recommend that you also make sure there are some enjoyable activities in your week as well.<br />&nbsp;<br />I make sure that I also plan in time for things that are purely enjoyable. Otherwise, if you get really excited about the growth mindset, all your free time can become &ldquo;cultivation&rdquo; activities, and that can just lead to an emotionally distressing life. You can end up feeling a bit inadequate! In some ways, wanting to improve at things is a negative judgment of yourself: you think something needs improving, i.e., that something is not ideal at the moment. So if you are doing too much of this, you can end up being a bit negative about yourself. I think it is extremely important to try to keep a balance between positive and negative thoughts about yourself, and to actually spend some time every day thinking of at least one good thing about yourself (if you struggle with that balance). In any case, since trying to improve your skills is a bit of a negative practice, I think it could lead people to become a bit depressed if they, in addition, do not find the cultivation activities they happen to be doing fun, and I&rsquo;d be surprised if they were fun (but that&rsquo;s great if they happen to be!).<br />&nbsp;<br />So cultivation activities might not be fun, but that&rsquo;s ok. But make sure you do plan in activities that feel like pure play to you, that are fun, enjoyable, and emotionally rewarding.<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong><font color="#248d6c" size="5">A Key Move of the Growth Mindset: Orienting to Failure Differently&nbsp;</font></strong><br /><br />A key move of the growth mindset is to orient to failure differently. Let&rsquo;s take public speaking as an example.<br />&nbsp;<br />Say you give a big presentation to an audience of 100 people, and everyone thinks it was a very bad presentation &ndash; that you did not do it well.<br />&nbsp;<br />If you were <strong><u>not</u></strong> using the growth mindset, you would look at your failed presentation and say something like, &ldquo;I&rsquo;m just stupid, I guess&rdquo;, or &ldquo;I just can&rsquo;t do this apparently&rdquo;, or &ldquo;I wasn&rsquo;t born with the ability to do this, so I should just give up now&rdquo;, or &ldquo;I&rsquo;m not a born speaker&rdquo;, or &ldquo;I&rsquo;m fundamentally worthless and should just give up&rdquo;.<br />&nbsp;<br />If we use the growth mindset, in contrast, we might think like this: &ldquo;Ok, I clearly did not know how to do this well. What incorrect knowledge was my failure based on? How can I improve at this? Are there books, or online videos on YouTube (or anywhere else online), or other resources I could work with to help me get better? How could I develop and improve my presentation skills? I can do this, but I need to improve my methods&rdquo;.<br />&nbsp;<br />So instead of thinking you&rsquo;re just stupid or weren&rsquo;t born a natural presenter, you figure out what went wrong and how you can build the skills that allow you to be successful in future presentations.<br />&nbsp;<br />As you deal with failure, it is also so important to be kind to yourself. That is why I also think self-compassion is extremely important, and I plan to write about that on this blog soon.<br /><br /><strong><font color="#248d6c" size="5">University of New Mexico</font></strong><br /><br />I currently work at the University of New Mexico as an assistant professor, and in one of my first semesters here I enrolled in a program they have called the Student Experience Project. This is a multi-university project aimed at improving teaching (https://studentexperienceproject.org/).<br /><br />I was pleasantly surprised when, in this program, they discussed the growth mindset. It is central to the Student Experience Project program. Something they said there was that teaching is increasingly understood as needing to incorporate the growth mindset, and that faculty have a responsibility to convey this to students.<br /><br />The University of New Mexico (UNM) has also recently developed a teaching and learning framework, where the growth mindset has a central place. They have this image that summarizes the framework (accessible here:&nbsp;https://ctl.unm.edu/framework/index.html):</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-09-01-at-14-03-43_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">You can see that "Embrace a Culture of Growth" is one of the principles, and that is the growth mindset principle.<br /><br />I say this about UNM as examples, beyond what you can find on YouTube or in most publications about the growth mindset, of this being normalized and used on a daily basis.<br /><br /></div>  <div class="paragraph"><strong><font size="5" color="#248d6c">Two videos about the growth mindset that you may be interested to check out:</font></strong><br /><br /><span>Ali Abdaal, someone who makes his living out of helping people improve their skills, has a helpful YouTube video summarizing the ideas from Carol Dweck&rsquo;s book </span><em>Mindset: The New Psychology of Success</em><span>. The video is called, &ldquo;The Mindset Shift that Changed My Life&rdquo; (</span><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L11WCsRqrIg">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L11WCsRqrIg</a><span>).</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>Carol Dweck has also given some talks that are available online about the growth mindset, such as a video from Stanford Alumni called, &ldquo;Developing a Growth Mindset with Carol Dweck&rdquo; (</span><a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiiEeMN7vbQ">https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hiiEeMN7vbQ</a><span>).</span></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[American Sociological Association Style Guide]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/american-sociological-association-style-guide]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/american-sociological-association-style-guide#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Fri, 28 Aug 2026 23:53:46 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/american-sociological-association-style-guide</guid><description><![CDATA[Sometimes the official ASA citation guide (from the American Sociological Association: https://my.asanet.org/cv5/cgi-bin/msascartdll.dll/ProductInfo?productcd=ASAOE701S22) is strangely sparse on certain important details. I made this guide to fill in some of those gaps and give you the information you really need to know. The University of Toronto Mississauga Department of Sociology has also made an excellent citation guide (link current to August 2026: https://www.utm.utoronto.ca/rgasc/media/28 [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><span>Sometimes the official ASA citation guide (from the American Sociological Association: </span><a href="https://my.asanet.org/cv5/cgi-bin/msascartdll.dll/ProductInfo?productcd=ASAOE701S22">https://my.asanet.org/cv5/cgi-bin/msascartdll.dll/ProductInfo?productcd=ASAOE701S22</a><span>) is strangely sparse on certain important details. I made this guide to fill in some of those gaps and give you the information you really need to know. The University of Toronto Mississauga Department of Sociology has also made an excellent citation guide (link current to August 2026: </span><a href="https://www.utm.utoronto.ca/rgasc/media/2836/download?inline" target="_blank">https://www.utm.utoronto.ca/rgasc/media/2836/download?inline</a><span>) but it does not cover everything that I do here.</span></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;"><br /><a>Note on automatic reference list generators</a>&nbsp;<br />I use Zotero (but you can use Mendeley or other such things too such as Readcube), so that I don&rsquo;t have to write out my references each time, although <strong>I do have to check my reference list carefully each time against the official rules because often I have some mistakes in the information I put into Zotero, like putting "California" instead of "CA" in the location of a book</strong>, or other such minor errors. Mendeley also works very well, but I like Zotero for a few reasons (such as that it is a nonprofit run by a university). I do recommend using one of these automatic reference generators. The advantage is that you only have to put the information about a reference into the software <strong><em>once,</em></strong> rather than every time you want to cite/reference it. <strong>But you still have to check your reference list very carefully each time.</strong><br />&nbsp;<br />An important note though: whenever I generate the reference list with Zotero, I cut it out of the Word document and paste it into Text Edit (a simple word processor on Mac, but there are corollaries on PC) to get rid of the field codes, the complicated code that was used to generate the list that is somehow embedded in the reference list (this is the reference list mind you, NOT the citations&mdash;I leave the field code citations in the document always, because they allow me to auto-generate the reference list). Then I copy the reference list from Text Edit and paste it back into the Word Document, and then it is just a simple text list instead of being the strange field code thing that Zotero (and Mendeley) will paste in. I&rsquo;ve found this prevents my Word document from crashing, as these reference list field codes sometimes take up a lot of RAM apparently.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="6"><a>In-Text Citations</a>&nbsp;</font><br /><font size="4">This guide will show you how to use ASA style, as I stated above. So the following only pertains to ASA style.</font><br /><font size="4">&nbsp;</font><br /><a>BASIC CITATION FORMULA: Author and Date with *NO* comma</a>&nbsp;<br />So, the basic format for ASA citation is something like: (Davis 1995)<br />&nbsp;<br />If you want to cite multiple authors, they&rsquo;re listed alphabetically with semicolons between them: (Bateman et al. 2019; Bourdieu 1990; Davis 1995; Johnston 2015)<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Two authors</a>&nbsp;<br />For two authors, we use the word &ldquo;and&rdquo; between them: (Johnston and Baumann 2007)<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Three authors</a>&nbsp;<br />For 3 authors, we list the 3 authors the first time, and then after that, we just say &ldquo;et al.&rdquo; So the first time we cite the 3 authored article, we would say, (Bateman, Baumann, and Johnston 2019), and then after we cite it that first time, we would just say (Bateman et al. 2019).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Four or more authors</a>&nbsp;<br />For four or more authors, we just say &ldquo;et al.&rdquo; even the first time. E.g., (Bourdieu et al. 2000).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Page Numbers</a>&nbsp;<br />The cite a page number in ASA style, you use a colon, and then <strong>no space after the colon</strong>, and then the page number. For example, (Bateman, Baumann, and Johnston 2019:7) if it was the first time that source was being cited in a text, and then if we also cited it again later we would say, (Bateman et al. 2019:11).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Video Time Stamps</a>&nbsp;<br />To cite a minute and second number for a documentary or video in ASA style, ASA style says that we default to how Chicago style handles this. ASA style is based on Chicago style, so when the ASA doesn&rsquo;t have a specific rule, we use Chicago style. If we were citing a video by Thomas 2020, and we wanted to cite minute 1, second 36 of the video, we would say (Thomas 2020, 01:36) (so that would be minute 1, second 36), for a documentary up to 60 minutes. For a documentary longer than 60 minutes, we would say something like (Pilger 2001, 01:02:19) (so that would be hour 1, minute 2, second 19). So we see this change here, a comma rather than a colon, since it would be quite awkward to say something like (Pilger 2001:01:02:19). So we DON&rsquo;T do that. INSTEAD, we do this: (Pilger 2001, 01:02:19) (we use a comma).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Talking about a video in-text</a>&nbsp;<br />The ASA defaults to the Chicago Manual of Style when referring to how to actually use the title of a film in-text. The Chicago Manual of Style (2017, 17th edition) states that films are italicized when brought up in-text. This is in section 8.189 of the Chicago Manual of Style, 17th edition. The section of the Chicago guide is called &ldquo;Titles for Movies, Television, Radio, and Podcasts&rdquo;.<br /><br />They say that titles for movies should be italicized, when you mention them in the text outside of a citation. Television episodes should be in quotes, not italicized, if mentioned in text, and the entire series would be italicized. For example: "Macondo" if referring to the first episode of the&nbsp;<em>One Hundred Years of Solitude</em>&nbsp;series.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a><font size="6">References</font></a><br /><br /><a>Film</a>&nbsp;<br />You need to find the directors and the studio for films. Personally, I find the directors and the studio for films at letterboxd.com ("letterbox"). I find the city of the studios on Wikipedia. I find the short form of the country (e.g., Switzerland is CH) by going to the Wikipedia page for the country, and then looking at the panel on the right side that has the summary information for the country (like the map, capital, largest city, population, etc.), and near the bottom there is the ISO 3166 code.<br />&nbsp;<br />This is what the ASA 6th edition of the style guide actually says about films: &ldquo;For general guidelines for citations and references for other types of audiovisual media (film, sound recordings, slides, filmstrips, and videos), see <em>The Chicago Manual of Style</em> (2010:764&ndash;769).<br />&nbsp;<br />But that is extremely unhelpful for the case of documentaries.<br />&nbsp;<br />Then, in the actual Chicago Manual of Style itself, they start pasting in Screenshots from AJS as the authoritative use of Chicago style. So I guess if you want to find out how a documentary is cited properly in Chicago style, you need to sift through AJS articles until you find one.<br />&nbsp;<br />So the ASA style guide says: to cite films, check the Chicago style guide. And the Chicago style guide has nothing on that and basically says: check AJS if you want to know more.<br />&nbsp;<br />Given all of that, this is what I have come up with:<br /><br /><span>[Directors]. [Year]. [Title]. [City or cities of publication of the studio(s), with a comma and the province or state code, or if not the US or Canada, the country code, e.g. "Burbank, CA" for Warner Brothers]: [Studio, e.g., Warner Brothers]. [How you accessed it&mdash;Blue-ray Disc, or DVD, or a website link].</span><br /><br /><span>E.g.:</span><br /><br /><span>Chapman, Adam, Sophie Lanfear, Huw Cordey, Hugh Pearson Mandi Stark, and Jeff Wilson. 2019. </span><em>Our Planet</em><span>. Gland, CH and London, UK: World Wide Fund for Nature and Silverback Films. </span><a href="https://www.netflix.com/watch/80094031">https://www.netflix.com/watch/80094031</a><span>.</span><br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Journal Article</a>&nbsp;<br />[Author(s)]. [Year]. ["Title"]. [Journal Title]. [Volume Number(Issue Number):Page&ndash;Numbers]. [doi, if available].<br />&nbsp;<br />Foster, John Bellamy, Brian M. Napoletano, Brett Clark, and Pedro S. Urquijo. 2020. &ldquo;Henri Lefebvre&rsquo;s Marxian Ecological Critique: Recovering a Foundational Contribution to Environmental Sociology.&rdquo; <em>Environmental Sociology</em> 6(1):31&ndash;41. doi: 10.1080/23251042.2019.1670892.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Book</a><br />[Author(s)]. [Year]. [Title]. [City or cities of publication], [the province or state code, or if not the US or Canada, the country code]: [Publisher].<br />&nbsp;<br />It is often hard to find the city and the publisher, but you must do it! Worldcat.org usually has it. E.g., <a href="https://search.worldcat.org/title/1029547384">https://search.worldcat.org/title/1029547384</a><br />&nbsp;<br />Worldcat used to be something you didn&rsquo;t have to sign in to. But AI changed that: it was threatened by AI scraping. So now, you have to sign in. Sorry. It&rsquo;s not that convenient. But it is a pretty fast way to find the place it was published.<br />&nbsp;<br />Examples:<br />&nbsp;<br />Agyeman, Julian, Peter Cole, Randolph Haluza-DeLay, and Pat O&rsquo;Riley. 2009. <em>Speaking for Ourselves: Environmental Justice in Canada. </em>Vancouver, BC and Toronto, ON: UBC Press.<br />&nbsp;<br />Antos, Joe, Ray Coupe, George Douglas, Rich Evans, Trevor Goward, Marianne Ignace, Dennis Lloyd, Roberta Parish, Rosamund Pojar, and Anna Roberts. 1996<em>. Plants of Southern Interior British Columbia.</em> Vancouver, BC: Lone Pine.<br />&nbsp;<br />Asdal, Kristin, Brita Brenna, and Ingunn Moser, eds. 2007. <em>Technoscience: The Politics of Interventions.</em> Oslo, NO: Unipub.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Book Chapter</a>&nbsp;<br />[Author(s) of the chapter]. [Year book was published]. ["Title of the chapter"]. [Pp. PAGE&ndash;NUMBERS] in [Book Title], edited by [Book editor names, with the first name only with the initial, and the full last names]. [City or cities of publication], [the province or state code, or if not the US or Canada, the country code]: [Publisher name].<br />&nbsp;<br />Agyeman, Julian, Robert D. Bullard, and Bob Evans. 2003. &ldquo;Joined-up Thinking: Bringing Together Sustainability, Environmental Justice and Equity.&rdquo; Pp. 1&ndash;16 in <em>Just Sustainabilities: Development in an Unequal World</em>, edited by J. Agyeman, R. D. Bullard, and B. Evans. Cambridge, MA and London, UK: MIT Press and Earthscan.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Magazine Article</a>&nbsp;<br />[Author(s)]. [Year]. ["Title of article"]. [City of publication], [the province or state code, or if not the US or Canada, the country code]: [Publication Title]. [What issue it was published in, for example, the month for a monthly magazine].<br />&nbsp;<br />Muster, Judith. 2013. &ldquo;Rob Stewart: The Outspoken Filmmaker on the Repeal of Toronto&rsquo;s Shark Fin Ban and His New Movie, Revolution.&rdquo; Toronto, ON: <em>Post City Magazines</em>. February.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Newspaper Article</a><br />[Author(s)]. [Year]. ["Title of article"]. [City of publication], [the province or state code, or if not the US or Canada, the country code]: [Publication Title]. [Month] [Day of Month], [Any additional information, like whether it is an editorial, or what edition it was published in, or the page it was published on if you found it in a printed newspaper, or a website link if you read it on a website].<br />&nbsp;<br />Toronto Star. 2010. &ldquo;Should Toronto Be a Province?&rdquo; <em>Toronto Star</em>, March 18, Editorial.&#8232;<br />* Here, the author is the Toronto Star, because it was published by the editors of the Toronto Star (it is an "editorial"). So the authors weren&rsquo;t listed.<br />Zimmer, Carl. 2019. &ldquo;An Ecological &lsquo;Crisis&rsquo; as 2.9 Billion Birds Vanish.&rdquo; New York Times, September 20, Late Edition (East Coast).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Websites</a>&nbsp;<br />This is from the ASA Style Guide (6th edition), which is based on the Chicago Manual of Style:<br />&nbsp;<br />1. WEBSITE + UNKNOWN PUBLICATION DATE + UNKNOWN PUBLISHING LOCATION<br />&nbsp;<br />Citation: (WERA n.d.)<br />&nbsp;<br />Reference:<br />&nbsp;<br />WERA (World Education Research Association). n.d. &ldquo;About WERA.&rdquo; Retrieved June 30, 2018 (https://wera.site-ym.com/?AboutWERA).<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>2. WEBSITE + KNOWN PUBLICATION DATE + UNKNOWN PUBLISHING LOCATION</a><br />EXAMPLE 1<br />&nbsp;<br />Citation: (CEC 2014)<br />&nbsp;<br />Reference: CEC (Council for Exceptional Children). 2014. &ldquo;CEC&rsquo;s Mission Statement.&rdquo; Retrieved June 30, 2018 (https://www.cec.sped.org/About-Us/Mission).<br />&nbsp;<br />EXAMPLE 2<br />&nbsp;<br />Citation: (IBM 2009)<br />&nbsp;<br />Reference:<br />&nbsp;<br />IBM (International Business Machines). 2009. &ldquo;2009 Annual Report.&rdquo; Retrieved June 30, 2018. (<a href="http://www.ibm.com/annualreport/2009/2009_ibm_annual.pdf">http://www.ibm.com/annualreport/2009/2009_ibm_annual.pdf</a>).<br />&nbsp;<br /><font color="#33a27f">3. WEBSITE + KNOWN PUBLICATION DATE + KNOWN PUBLISHING LOCATION</font><br />Citation: (ASA 2006)<br />&nbsp;<br />Reference:<br />&nbsp;<br />ASA (American Sociological Association). 2006. &ldquo;Status Committees.&rdquo; Washington, DC: American Sociological Association. Retrieved June 30, 2018 (http://www.asanet.org/about-asa/governance/asa-committees).<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5"><a>Referencing Social Media</a>&nbsp;</font><br /><br /><a>TikTok</a><br />[Name] [(@)]. [Year]. ["Text with hash tags" [Video]]. TikTok, [Date]. [Link].<br /><br />E.g.:<br /><br />Real Black History (@realblackhistory). &nbsp;2021. "Back to our scheduled programming.. let&rsquo;s talk about double consciousness. #blackhistoryisamericanhistory #webdubois #sociology" [Video]. TikTok, June 29. https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM8Lwe4pw/.<br /><br />Yeet (@asslookinfatma). 2020. "Bro my sociology/psych professors are SO MEAN LIKE PRACTICE WHAT YOU PREACH BRO #xyzbca #sociology #psychology" [Video]. TikTok, November 24. https://vm.tiktok.com/ZM8Lwhvr9/.<br /><br />* Note: I did not have time to check all of "Yeet&rsquo;s" videos. I checked many and they seem to not be offensive. But if any of you already know of any problems there, or if you&rsquo;re for some reason moved to watch more of her videos and find something problematic, please let me know if any of the videos are problematic and I&rsquo;ll remove that one. That particular video was just funny and poignant I thought, for a sociology class. I only condone that single video and do not recommend watching any of the others, as I do not have time to check all of them. You are all adults and I trust you to use discretion when accessing online content.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Tweet</a>&nbsp;<br />[Name] [(@)]. [Year]. ["Text"]. Twitter, [Date, including time posted]. [Link].<br />&nbsp;<br />This example is from the American Sociological Association Guide:<br />&nbsp;<br />Washington Capitals (@Capitals). 2018. &ldquo;THE WASHINGTON CAPITALS ARE THE 2018 #STANLEYCUP CHAMPIONS! #ALLCAPS.&rdquo; Twitter, June 7, 8:06 p.m. <a href="https://twitter.com/Capitals/status/1004922698294652928">https://twitter.com/Capitals/status/1004922698294652928</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />This is another example, that I created:<br /><br />TallBear, Kim (@KimTallBear). 2021. "I harbour no optimism about working with the US settler state government. but i do appreciate the powerful stories @jfkeeler recounts herein about D/Lakota homelands and our co-constituted with bison personhood and Peoplehoods. https://www.sierraclub.org/sierra/can-indigenous-leadership-save-our-national-parks-and-monuments#.YWRw_rSrKQw.twitter @SierraMagazine." Twitter, October 11, 12:23 PM. https://twitter.com/KimTallBear/status/1447613731978899458.<br />&nbsp;<br /><a>Instagram</a><br />[Name] [(@)]. [Year]. ["Text with hash tags, but cut it off if it is a lot of text, more than a couple sentences, with an ellipsis" [Photograph or Video]]. Instagram, [Date]. [Link].<br /><br />If the text is very long, just add some of it and then add an ellipsis (...), as I do in the second reference here.<br />&nbsp;<br />If it is a video, just replace the "[Photograph]" part with "[Video]".<br />&nbsp;<br />Philadelphia Museum of Art (@philamuseum). 2019. &ldquo;It&rsquo;s always wonderful to walk in and see my work in a collection where it&rsquo;s loved, and where people are" [Photograph]. Instagram, December 3. <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/B5oDnnNhOt4/">https://www.instagram.com/p/B5oDnnNhOt4/</a><br />&nbsp;<br />Andrew Budziak (@andrew_budziak). 2021. "HIDING AND PEKIN. This might be one of the most photogenic birds I&rsquo;ve ever seen. This is a Pekin duck ..." [Photograph]. Instagram, October 12. <a href="https://www.instagram.com/p/CU7s4Akgo78">https://www.instagram.com/p/CU7s4Akgo78</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br /><font size="5"><a>My References for this Guide</a>&nbsp;</font><br />Two of the above examples came from the American Psychological Association, so in order to be consistent and do what I&rsquo;m asking you all to do, I&rsquo;m going to list my own references here. The American Sociological Association is very slow to update any official documents for things like TikTok, so I relied on the American Psychological Association, while also looking at the Twitter format that the ASA has actually created. I also made most of these references in ASA (American Sociological Association) style, which is based on Chicago Style. So the ASA references incorporate some elements that are unique to the ASA, but otherwise, they follow Chicago style, so I&rsquo;m citing those two citation guides as well, which I had to check to make this guide. You don&rsquo;t have to look at any of these sources, but I&rsquo;m just trying to practice what I preach here!<br />&nbsp;<br />American Psychological Association. 2021. TikTok References. Accessed October 12, 2021. <a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/tiktok-references">https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/tiktok-references</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />American Psychological Association. 2021. Instagram References. Accessed October 12, 2021. <a href="https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/instagram-references">https://apastyle.apa.org/style-grammar-guidelines/references/examples/instagram-references</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />American Sociological Association. 2019. <em>American Sociological Association Style Guide</em>. 6th ed. Washington, DC: American Sociological Association.<br />&nbsp;<br />Davis, Mike. 1995. &ldquo;The Case For Letting Malibu Burn.&rdquo; <em>Environmental History Review</em> 19(2):1&ndash;36. doi: <a href="https://doi.org/10.2307/3984830">10.2307/3984830</a>.<br />&nbsp;<br />University of Chicago Press. 2017. <em>The Chicago Manual of Style</em>. 17th ed. Chicago, IL: The University of Chicago Press.</div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How I Read, in 2026]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-in-2026]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-in-2026#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 18 Aug 2026 22:40:51 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-in-2026</guid><description><![CDATA[A few years ago I made a post in this blog about how I read at the time. I usually took "piece notes" (in the sense of, a set of notes per each "piece", as in, an article or book chapter) in a mapping style.&nbsp;I still like mapping, but I now have a method that is more efficient. It also has the virtue of not being in a piece-notes view, where we only see notes for one piece at a time. Rather, it is a method where you can read "by-piece", but the outcome is a thematic view.&nbsp;I was inspired [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">A few years ago I made a post in this blog about how I read at the time. I usually took "piece notes" (in the sense of, a set of notes per each "piece", as in, an article or book chapter) in a mapping style.&nbsp;<br /><br />I still like mapping, but I now have a method that is more efficient. It also has the virtue of not being in a piece-notes view, where we only see notes for one piece at a time. Rather, it is a method where you can read "by-piece", but the outcome is a thematic view.&nbsp;<br /><br />I was inspired by qualitative coding programs, and have made a spreadsheet that mimics how those qualitative coding programs work. How I got to where I am from where I started is a relatively long journey, and to try not to overwhelm you I'll take you on that journey one step at a time here.</div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Start with a blank spreadsheet. I prefer Excel to all other spreadsheet software because of its excellent sort function. The sort function is essential to this reading method.</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-16-53-23_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">In this example, I will make the topic research methods, which is a graduate class I'm teaching this semester. Each one of these reading matrices can be whatever level of abstraction you want. You could make them for a single publication (I mean, you could have one for all of the reading you do for a particular journal article/book you're working on), or for a topic area (in the sense of an area that you might return to in different journal articles/books). I wouldn't choose a topic area like "sociology" &ndash; too broad. I think it works well for specific and middle-range general topics. Research methods is a more middle-range general category. You could also have one for cultural sociology &ndash; that is general enough, but not too general. In any case, up to you, but those are my thoughts on level of generality.<br /><br />Let's add one of the sources from this research methods class, "Salsa dancing into the social sciences". I add sources in rows, and themes in columns.&nbsp;</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-16-59-00_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So here I have added a column called "Reference" and then the complete reference for this source.&nbsp;<br /><br />I'll keep this discussion at an intro level for Excel skills for those of you who don't yet have those skills.&nbsp;<br /><br />So the next thing I'm going to do is "Wrap" the entire "Reference" column so that the source wraps to the border of the cell. I'm also going to make the column a bit bigger by dragging the right border of the "E" at the top of the column.&nbsp;<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-video"><div title="Video: video1342956623_733.mp4" class="wsite-video-wrapper wsite-video-height-282 wsite-video-align-left"> 					<div id="wsite-video-container-385641836386820508" class="wsite-video-container" style="margin: 10px 0 10px 0;"> 						<iframe allowtransparency="true" allowfullscreen="true" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" id="video-iframe-385641836386820508" 							src="about:blank"> 						</iframe> 						 						<style> 							#wsite-video-container-385641836386820508{ 								background: url(//www.weebly.com/uploads/b/139636543-791130538474736587/video1342956623_733.jpg); 							}  							#video-iframe-385641836386820508{ 								background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/play-icon.png?1787867913); 							}  							#wsite-video-container-385641836386820508, #video-iframe-385641836386820508{ 								background-repeat: no-repeat; 								background-position:center; 							}  							@media only screen and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (        min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 192dpi), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 2dppx) { 									#video-iframe-385641836386820508{ 										background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/@2x/play-icon.png?1787867913); 										background-repeat: no-repeat; 										background-position:center; 										background-size: 70px 70px; 									} 							} 						</style> 					</div> 				</div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now we are here:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-17-08-45_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I then like to add just the 'citation' to the furthest left, so that I can easily see who the author is.&nbsp;</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-17-11-08_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">As I did that, I realized that this new Excel sheet has an alignment that is 'bottom of the cell'. I like to have everything aligned right and to the top of the cell. So I click the little box in between the "1" of the first row and the "A" of the first column, and then click align right and align top:</div>  <div class="wsite-video"><div title="Video: video1915530123_201.mp4" class="wsite-video-wrapper wsite-video-height-282 wsite-video-align-left"> 					<div id="wsite-video-container-585174124424033479" class="wsite-video-container" style="margin: 10px 0 10px 0;"> 						<iframe allowtransparency="true" allowfullscreen="true" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" id="video-iframe-585174124424033479" 							src="about:blank"> 						</iframe> 						 						<style> 							#wsite-video-container-585174124424033479{ 								background: url(//www.weebly.com/uploads/b/139636543-791130538474736587/video1915530123_201.jpg); 							}  							#video-iframe-585174124424033479{ 								background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/play-icon.png?1787867913); 							}  							#wsite-video-container-585174124424033479, #video-iframe-585174124424033479{ 								background-repeat: no-repeat; 								background-position:center; 							}  							@media only screen and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (        min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 192dpi), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 2dppx) { 									#video-iframe-585174124424033479{ 										background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/@2x/play-icon.png?1787867913); 										background-repeat: no-repeat; 										background-position:center; 										background-size: 70px 70px; 									} 							} 						</style> 					</div> 				</div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now we have this:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-17-15-03_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">In addition to the authors and the reference, I like to also have the number of Google Scholar citations of the source, so that I know how influential it is. I also create a column called "DateGSC" meaning "Date Google Scholar Citations were added" because citations change over time and if that date is quite far in the past, you can then expect that the citations have likely changed, and you may want to update it, if it has been many years. Or not, up to you, but it just gives you more information about when you added the citation number.<br /><br />I also like to know the order in which I added sources, in case I want to recreate the research path I've been on. I can then always see the order in which I read, which I've found can be very useful. I also like to be able to quickly see who the publisher is, and to have the abstract for journal articles. Usually for books, in the "abstract" column I just say "book", but if I happen to want something there, I can go to the publisher website and get the blurb they give from the book there. I'll do that for this book for purposes of example. I do it sometimes. For book chapters, I just say "Book chapter" in the "Abstract" column, no use really trying to give a summary of every book chapter you read there, in my view.<br /><br />To do this, I'm going to insert some columns by click-dragging the top bar.<br />In this video, you can see me add this information. I quickly went to Google Scholar to get the citation count, and went to the website of Harvard University Press for the blurb. Again, a bit excessive for a book, but it's usually very easy and helpful with a journal article to add the abstract, hence the title of the column.<br /><br />I also here had to enforce a height on the cells. I usually use about 100. You do that by click-dragging the gray bar with the numbers on it on the left, and then dragging the little separator between two of them. I chose the first 50 rows because hypothetically we could use that many in a spreadsheet about research methods.</div>  <div class="wsite-video"><div title="Video: video1530266574_238.mp4" class="wsite-video-wrapper wsite-video-height-282 wsite-video-align-left"> 					<div id="wsite-video-container-463432979469771396" class="wsite-video-container" style="margin: 10px 0 10px 0;"> 						<iframe allowtransparency="true" allowfullscreen="true" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" id="video-iframe-463432979469771396" 							src="about:blank"> 						</iframe> 						 						<style> 							#wsite-video-container-463432979469771396{ 								background: url(//www.weebly.com/uploads/b/139636543-791130538474736587/video1530266574_238.jpg); 							}  							#video-iframe-463432979469771396{ 								background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/play-icon.png?1787867913); 							}  							#wsite-video-container-463432979469771396, #video-iframe-463432979469771396{ 								background-repeat: no-repeat; 								background-position:center; 							}  							@media only screen and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (        min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 192dpi), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 2dppx) { 									#video-iframe-463432979469771396{ 										background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/@2x/play-icon.png?1787867913); 										background-repeat: no-repeat; 										background-position:center; 										background-size: 70px 70px; 									} 							} 						</style> 					</div> 				</div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Sorry about the headshot all over the place, even filling the screen in the last seconds there. Also the recording for some reason keeps zooming in! Clearly Zoom isn't the best way to record. I'm going to try Screen Capture on Mac next.<br /><br />In any case, now we have:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-17-29-34_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">The next step is building the thematic columns. The idea with these columns is to make a nested series of themes. I honestly use a spreadsheet with 7, but let's just make 5 to keep things relatively manageable in this example. First I'll make a template column for these 5 nested themes. Also I make a column beside the column called "Template" that I just call "R" meaning "This column refers to the one to the Right". This is used in sorting the sheet. We'll get to that later! There is also a row between the main spreadsheet and the nested columns part of the sheet. That is important, again, for sorting purposes. I've coloured it blue. It is worth saying now, and as many times as I can remember to remind you in this post: in general, you need to make sure the main spreadsheet part (with the "Luker 2008" cell etc.) doesn't have ANY cell without anything in it. Everything always needs something in it. Again, because of sorting. We'll continue to deal with that as we continue on.</div>  <div class="wsite-video"><div title="Video: screen_recording_2026-08-18_at_17.38.59_293.mp4" class="wsite-video-wrapper wsite-video-height-282 wsite-video-align-left"> 					<div id="wsite-video-container-153409712855831141" class="wsite-video-container" style="margin: 10px 0 10px 0;"> 						<iframe allowtransparency="true" allowfullscreen="true" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" id="video-iframe-153409712855831141" 							src="about:blank"> 						</iframe> 						 						<style> 							#wsite-video-container-153409712855831141{ 								background: url(//www.weebly.com/uploads/b/139636543-791130538474736587/screen_recording_2026-08-18_at_17.38.59_293.jpg); 							}  							#video-iframe-153409712855831141{ 								background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/play-icon.png?1787867913); 							}  							#wsite-video-container-153409712855831141, #video-iframe-153409712855831141{ 								background-repeat: no-repeat; 								background-position:center; 							}  							@media only screen and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (        min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 192dpi), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 2dppx) { 									#video-iframe-153409712855831141{ 										background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/@2x/play-icon.png?1787867913); 										background-repeat: no-repeat; 										background-position:center; 										background-size: 70px 70px; 									} 							} 						</style> 					</div> 				</div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now we have this:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-17-43-17_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I really should have also resized that "Template" column to about 35 Excel units, I'll do that in the next one.&nbsp;<br /><br />An any case, it is useful to have a template column when inserting a new category later. But now I'll add some space to start actually categorizing the information in this book.&nbsp;<br /><br />If you start reading this book (which is great, I really appreciate this book!) is that she thinks that making time for fun in your life is actually essential for being a good social scientist. It helps give you time in which to subconsciously process your research, which can lead to insights, and also helps you bring a sense of playfulness to the research itself, enhancing it. So that is a theme. We could add that one, and I'll do that here.&nbsp;<br /><br />In the video just following this paragraph, I add the template column to a few columns. Then I use the Command key on a Mac (I think Control does the same thing on a PC) to select non-continuous columns at once and I resize them simultaneously. Then another part of this reading system is a "clipboard manager", such as the app "Paste" on a Mac, which allows you to copy many things at once and then paste them in the order you want. I messed up a bit here in that the comment I wrote in the last paragraph, which I also add here in bold, I first accidentally added to the quote. But I went and copied a few things from the book just before making this video, because I can't switch screens away from the Mac Screen Capture app or else it will just copy that part of the screen I jump to, which is going to be confusing. But I use a clipboard manager all the time when I use this reading method. They are really useful in my view.</div>  <div class="wsite-video"><div title="Video: screen_recording_2026-08-18_at_17.52.49_983.mp4" class="wsite-video-wrapper wsite-video-height-282 wsite-video-align-left"> 					<div id="wsite-video-container-767616891488499761" class="wsite-video-container" style="margin: 10px 0 10px 0;"> 						<iframe allowtransparency="true" allowfullscreen="true" frameborder="0" scrolling="no" id="video-iframe-767616891488499761" 							src="about:blank"> 						</iframe> 						 						<style> 							#wsite-video-container-767616891488499761{ 								background: url(//www.weebly.com/uploads/b/139636543-791130538474736587/screen_recording_2026-08-18_at_17.52.49_983.jpg); 							}  							#video-iframe-767616891488499761{ 								background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/play-icon.png?1787867913); 							}  							#wsite-video-container-767616891488499761, #video-iframe-767616891488499761{ 								background-repeat: no-repeat; 								background-position:center; 							}  							@media only screen and (-webkit-min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (        min-device-pixel-ratio: 2), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 192dpi), 								only screen and (                min-resolution: 2dppx) { 									#video-iframe-767616891488499761{ 										background: url(//cdn2.editmysite.com/images/util/videojs/@2x/play-icon.png?1787867913); 										background-repeat: no-repeat; 										background-position:center; 										background-size: 70px 70px; 									} 							} 						</style> 					</div> 				</div></div>  <div class="paragraph">You can see in that video that I also like to give multiple rows to the same source, so that I can put more information in while keeping things neat and organized. So I repeat the metadata columns at the front.<br /><br />In that video I also started to use freeze panes in this sheet. It is helpful so that you know which row you are actually on at any one time.&nbsp;<br /><br />&#8203;So now we are here:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-18-05-51_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Clearly the text has started to run off the end of the cells. But this isn't a problem. You can just double click the cell to see all of the text, and go down the cell using the arrow keys.<br /><br />I also forgot there to change the "-1" to "1" for the cells that I actually filled in. I'll do that in the next video.<br /><br />So we could keep reading, and adding more themes. I'll do that to keep developing this a bit. Something she then says is about what she means by "methods", which is useful to keep track of across different sources. I'm also going to add the footnote that she adds at the end of the sentences about this (I'm going to have to start using YouTube for these videos, as Weebly is struggling!):</div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/GdGDPVZkeJc?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So in that video I also made 'template rows'. I also gave my template column some conditional formatting, to make it easier to see what has been filled in and what has not. If you want to know more about conditional formatting in Excel, there are many guides for it online.<br /><br />The "-1" and "zzz" are meant to just sort at the very bottom of any sort function. We're getting closer to the "sort" function! It's an important part of this method but much of the spreadsheet needs to be created for it to come into use.<br /><br />&#8203;Now we are at this point:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-18-31-30_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now I think we can start a discussion about the "nested" nature of the first 5 columns. So far, I haven't done any nesting. But with the comment from Luker about methods, we could start a sub-column of that, for those sources that think methods have something to do with truth.&nbsp;<br /><br />What I like to do with these nested columns is keep a general column ("Methods") and then add more specific columns beside that one, like this:<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/iax-qdwHY7E?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So the concept map we are developing now looks like this, if we were to actually map it:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-18-39-13_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">That is the map starting to form.&nbsp;<br /><br />I do like to map these reading matrices if I have the time, but it isn't necessary. I do NOT add all of the literature and authors: I ONLY map the 5-7 categories that are the top rows. The great virtue of these reading matrices is that they store a great deal of text in a small amount of space and need little reorganizing. The problem for me with doing everything in maps is that the maps need constant reorganizing that ends up taking so much time that it can really slow down my writing. These reading matrices are far more efficient at getting all of the text from different authors in one place. (They also work for qualitative coding!).<br /><br />Next let's add another author, as we need to if we are going to be able to start having the sort function do anything here, and the sort function is an essential feature of this reading method. That is what the "R" columns of "-1" and "1" are for: sorting.<br /><br />I'll add the book Problem-solving Sociology by Monica Prasad. I'll copy some of the metadata with my clipboard manager and then insert it:<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/ZWcQleEXS-E?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Now I'll read that book a bit and add a theme. An important theme in the book is how to relate to theory when you are trying to do problem-solving sociology, so I will add a theme about that. In the video following this paragraph, I add 5 quotations from the book. I also like to make sure I add the page number to each of the citations, so I know exactly where it is in a book and can cite it, if I want to, by page number. I also try to add my own comment before the quote, to help myself figure out how to make sense of it in the future.&nbsp;<span style="background-color: transparent;">You can see in this video, I also went on a little misadventure, trying to change the color scheme of the spreadsheet to the orange color scheme, which I find has very nice muted 'serious' academic colors. But then it was going to change the entire conditional formatting scheme and so I gave up. This sheet is basically stuck in the default office color scheme, which is doesn't have all the nice demure faded colors! Oh well, if you make a sheet like this, you can choose whatever color scheme you like, just make sure you choose it before you start linking your conditional formatting to the colour scheme. I just didn&rsquo;t like the vibrant orange that came out in the template columns and the rows that hadn&rsquo;t been filled in yet. In any case, here's the next step:</span></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/YiSYUlZNOIY?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Next I'll add a column called "currently reading", and I'm finally ready to show you what the sort function does, if you don't know already. Basically when you are reading something, it is nice to have the rows for that article/book at the top of the lower spreadsheet (not the part with the nested columns, the thing below that), so you aren't scrolling constantly. It's essential, actually, to have this "currently reading" column, if this method is going to be efficient. So when you add a new reading, you need to have it at the very top of the lower spreadsheet (the part that starts with "Authors | GSC" etc). This is about to get confusing, so I'm going to be very clear. I'm going to call this the "nested categories part of the spreadsheet":</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-21-06-01_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I'm going to call this the "main part of the spreadsheet":</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-08-18-at-21-06-06_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Ok so you want to be able to have the thing you're currently reading at the very top of the "main part of the spreadsheet". So to do that, we'll use the sort function.<br /><br />I like to put the currently reading column at the very right side of the spreadsheet. So what I do in this next video, just below this paragraph, is add that column and then sort the sheet by that column, using the "R" category.&nbsp;<br /><br />Also another Excel trick I've been using: you can use Command+ArrowKeys (Mac) or Control+ArrowKeys (PC) to move around a spreadsheet very fast, taking you from one end to the other end immediately.<br /><br />Also another Excel thing to keep in mind: MAKE SURE every single part of the "main part of the spreadsheet" is filled in before you start sorting it. If you have some bland cells in the "main part of the spreadsheet" and you start sorting it, it will become completely messed up and you'll destroy everything. I don't really want to explain exactly how/why this happens, it would take a while. If you don't believe me, look it up. That is why I have "zzz" and "-1" everywhere. NOTHING in the "main part of the spreadsheet" is blank for me.<br /><br />You can check if you've missed anything by going to "Go to special blanks". If you can't figure out how to do that, just search in a search engine "Go to special blanks" and there are a lot of tutorials. I'll show you how to do it on Mac but I'm sure the path to get there is a little different on a PC. "Go to special blanks" is going to tell me that I have no blanks. But I'll make some to show you what to do. To fill the blanks that "Go to special blanks" shows you, you just hold Command and then press enter (Mac) or Control and then enter (PC). Also I select the whole sheet here by holding shift+command and then using the right and then down arrow key (control+command should do the same thing on a PC). In any case, this is the "Go to special blanks" procedure:<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/FLRa3rkLz7I?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I wrote "THESE ARE BLANKS" there, and when I did that, they weren't blank for those moments when that text was there, but I deleted the text and then they were "blank". Nothing was in the cells. Anyway, you can see that the "Go to special blanks" operation allowed us to see where all the blanks were. I filled them with an en dash, just as an example of filling them all in at the same time, which I did by typing in an en dash and then holding command+enter (on a Mac). There are MANY tutorials on "Go to special blanks" if this is unclear (sorry, kind of hard to explain!).<br /><br />Ok so we have now made sure that there are no blanks. So we can sort safely.<br /><br />Now in the next video I make a "currently reading" column, set the "current reading" to Prasad 2021, then sort the sheet by "currently reading", sorting by "largest to smallest" number. Then the Prasad reading is going to jump to above the Luker reading, and it will make incorporating it into the spreadsheet easier. Not THAT much of a big deal in a sheet with only 2 readings. But if you have 10, or 100, it really matters. I then sort by Authors alphabetical order to show you the sort function working in another way.</div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/Xvg36S8dMMk?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So now, as you can imagine, you can sort the sheet by any column that you're interested in. So imagine that you have like 20 sources in this sheet, and 5 of them talk about what "methods" are. Then you can sort by that column, and all of the authors who talk about methods will jump to the top of the sheet. Then it is pretty easy to write a few paragraphs in a 'literature review' style about what different authors think the definition of "methods" is.&nbsp;<br /><br />That is basically the method.&nbsp;<br /><br />Here is the file I've been developing in this post:<br /></div>  <div><div style="margin: 10px 0 0 -10px"> <a title="Download file: researchmethods-readingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/researchmethods-readingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx"><img src="//www.weebly.com/weebly/images/file_icons/xls.png" width="36" height="36" style="float: left; position: relative; left: 0px; top: 0px; margin: 0 15px 15px 0; border: 0;" /></a><div style="float: left; text-align: left; position: relative;"><table style="font-size: 12px; font-family: tahoma; line-height: .9;"><tr><td colspan="2"><b> researchmethods-readingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx</b></td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Size:  </td><td>18 kb</td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Type:  </td><td> xlsx</td></tr></table><a title="Download file: researchmethods-readingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/researchmethods-readingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" style="font-weight: bold;">Download File</a></div> </div>  <hr style="clear: both; width: 100%; visibility: hidden"></hr></div>  <div class="paragraph">This is the actual template I'm currently using (file just below this paragraph). I also have some columns here for what kind of source it is (data, research, my comments) and where it comes from. I'm trying to make sure my reading isn't too focused on the USA and England &ndash; not that I don't want to read anything from there, but it is easy to get ethnocentric. I also want to know if something I'm reading is strictly sociology or not, which is helpful when publishing in sociology journals: keeping the distinction clear can be useful. I also put in some conditional formatting for the Google Scholar citations to help me see the general range of citations for any article. I think, for example, that more than 1000 citations is purple background with white text. In any case, this is the current actual template file I use for these reading matrices:</div>  <div><div style="margin: 10px 0 0 -10px"> <a title="Download file: templatereadingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/templatereadingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx"><img src="//www.weebly.com/weebly/images/file_icons/xls.png" width="36" height="36" style="float: left; position: relative; left: 0px; top: 0px; margin: 0 15px 15px 0; border: 0;" /></a><div style="float: left; text-align: left; position: relative;"><table style="font-size: 12px; font-family: tahoma; line-height: .9;"><tr><td colspan="2"><b> templatereadingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx</b></td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Size:  </td><td>61 kb</td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Type:  </td><td> xlsx</td></tr></table><a title="Download file: templatereadingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/templatereadingmatrix-2026-08-18th.xlsx" style="font-weight: bold;">Download File</a></div> </div>  <hr style="clear: both; width: 100%; visibility: hidden"></hr></div>  <div class="paragraph"><strong>MAPPING: </strong>I think it is also worth mentioning that if I have time, I DO map the first 5-7 columns of the sheet, like I started to do above. I do this mapping in Adobe Illustrator, but you can use any number of apps for that. I can't remember very well those rows at the top of the sheet, in the "nested categories" part of the sheet. I CAN remember maps very well. So it helps with longer-term memory for me, to make maps as well as a complement, when I have time. As I said above, I don't map anything in the "main part of the spreadsheet", none of the quotes from any authors etc. ONLY the categories in the top 5-7 rows, in the "nested categories" part of the sheet. I don't have maps for all of my reading matrices, since it does take time. I can sort of remember the nested categories in the matrices, but if I really want to remember them, the map helps a great deal. I know that the topic has general sub-topics within it, and so I open it and look around and find what I'm looking for. But if I have a map too, then I can much more precisely remember what is where and how the matrix is organized.<br /><br /><strong>ONE FOLDER: </strong>Another critical part of this method, for me, is I keep all of these reading matrices in ONE folder. That way, I don't have to spend a lot of time looking around when I want to read. When I used to keep them in a lot of different folders all over the place, I stopped using them because I didn't want to have to put in the effort to find them. Maybe you have another system, but I wanted to say that I found keeping them all in the same place helpful, instead of in various topic- and article- related folders. Since they are all in one folder, I sort of have an "app" of all these reading matrices.<br /><br /><strong>THE GAP BETWEEN THE NESTED CATEGORIES AND MAIN PART OF THE MATRIX:</strong>&nbsp;<span>Also, it is critical to keep in mind that there is a gap between the nested categories part of the spreadsheet and the main part of the spreadsheet. I colored it blue in the spreadsheet I&rsquo;ve been developing in this post. There needs to be a gap between the two. The part you really need to make sure has every cell filled in with something is the main part of the spreadsheet because that is the part you sort. You never sort the nested category part of the spreadsheet. But the reason that the sort function doesn&rsquo;t end up extending from the main part of the spreadsheet to the nested categories part is that there is that gap in between the two, and this row has nothing in it. You want to make sure that the gap row between the nested categories part of the spreadsheet, and the main part of the spreadsheet remains completely blank. Colouring it doesn't 'fill it', it only gets filled if some kind of text or a number is in it, and you don't want any text or numbers in it. If you have any text or numbers in there it will destroy the spreadsheet when you use the sorting function. So just make sure that in between the nested categories part of the spreadsheet and the main part of the spreadsheet there is that gap row. In the following video here I&rsquo;ll just emphasize that there is nothing in that row:</span></div>  <div class="wsite-youtube" style="margin-bottom:10px;margin-top:10px;"><div class="wsite-youtube-wrapper wsite-youtube-size-auto wsite-youtube-align-center"> <div class="wsite-youtube-container">  <iframe src="//www.youtube.com/embed/v6wl6Srnnos?wmode=opaque" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe> </div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><strong>FREEZE PANES: </strong>Another important part of Excel is the "Freeze Panes" function. I used it to freeze the first column and all of the nested categories, so that as we move around the spreadsheet, those parts are frozen. I also have a large external monitor in my office, so I can freeze a lot of panes and still have it be useful, as you can see in the actual reading matrix I use, the second file I added a few paragraphs ago. But if you have to use a laptop screen only, then you probably want to freeze less panes, such as only freezing the first column, but you'll still want all of the nested categories frozen. If this is all confusing, there are many tutorials about how to use freeze panes online.&nbsp;</div>  <div class="paragraph">So that's essentially it! That is the starting point for seeing how this method works.&nbsp;<br /><br />The great virtue of this method is that you read "by-piece" but the outcome is a THEMATIC structure. It is the most efficient method I have found for making that happen. One typically does read "by-piece", but having an automatic thematic structure develop as you read is extremely valuable. As I said in the introduction, I learned to think like that in qualitative coding software (e.g., Atlas.ti). But I found that software always to be a bit clunky, it is proprietary of course so you need to keep paying them a great deal, they have character limits all over the place (like only a certain number of words for each comment on a code), and they force you to import all of the text documents into a single file, so the files get extremely large, especially if you try to use them for reading. So this Excel-based method was a way to do what qualitative coding software does, but in a way where the files are relatively small (usually &lt;1MB), and where a very large amount of information can be stored in an organized way. As I introduced above, a clipboard manager (such as Paste on Mac) makes this method even more efficient, because you can copy multiple things (such as a quote that spans two pages) in a PDF and then you DONT have to switch back and forth between the spreadsheet and the reading, you can paste the two parts of the quote from the clipboard manager.&nbsp;<br /><br />Everyone has their own reading system, but I hope this post helps you develop yours. Happy reading! <br /><br />(If you have any questions about this, or think there is a discussion missing from this post, please let me know [tylerbateman@unm.edu]).</div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Teaching with Problem Solving]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/teaching-with-problem-solving]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/teaching-with-problem-solving#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Mon, 02 Feb 2026 23:18:18 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/teaching-with-problem-solving</guid><description><![CDATA[ 	 		 			 				 					 						  This is a post for educators who are interested in using problem-solving sociology in their classes, and either have not done so before and are interested in it, or who are looking to develop their methods. I hope you find something useful here!This post is based on a short talk I am giving as part of a panel organized by the problem-solving sociology community.&nbsp;As of the day this is written, this problem solving's website is:&#8203;https://www.problemsolvingsoc [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div><div class="wsite-multicol"><div class="wsite-multicol-table-wrap" style="margin:0 -15px;"> 	<table class="wsite-multicol-table"> 		<tbody class="wsite-multicol-tbody"> 			<tr class="wsite-multicol-tr"> 				<td class="wsite-multicol-col" style="width:50%; padding:0 15px;"> 					 						  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">This is a post for educators who are interested in using problem-solving sociology in their classes, and either have not done so before and are interested in it, or who are looking to develop their methods. I hope you find something useful here!<br />This post is based on a short talk I am giving as part of a panel organized by the problem-solving sociology community.&nbsp;<br />As of the day this is written, this problem solving's website is:&#8203;<font size="3">https://www.problemsolvingsociology.com/</font></div>   					 				</td>				<td class="wsite-multicol-col" style="width:50%; padding:0 15px;"> 					 						  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0px;margin-right:10px;text-align:right"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-02-02-at-16-19-44_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>   					 				</td>			</tr> 		</tbody> 	</table> </div></div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I have a few linked files that go with this post, you can see them <u><a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgDh_UpfJ8wpTpg-aZAMstYvAZoSjECGMFhcU0s2DXuazaU?e=KBzP8Y" target="_blank">at this link</a>, </u>and I also provide links throughout to the various individual documents.<br /></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#3387a2" size="6">introduction</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><span style="color:rgb(0, 0, 0)">First, as a settler, I recognize and thank the Indigenous peoples of this continent for their ongoing work as stewards of the land and for creating critical spaces of engagement. I'm writing this in Albuquerque in New Mexico, and I recognize that New Mexico is, and always has been, an Indigenous place. Albuquerque is on the homelands of the Pueblo of Sandia.</span><br /><br />I have taught with the problem solving approach at two universities and at the 400 and 300 level. I started with a class called "Sociology of the Environment and Social Justice" at the University of Toronto and I have taught Environmental Justice and Environmental Sociology at the University of New Mexico.</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screenshot-2026-02-04-at-11-40-27_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Immediately above, you can see some of the deliverables that my students have produced in classes where we work with the problem-solving framework. Here you can see <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtmR8q6QUGc" target="_blank">a video we produced based on primary data</a>, and <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgDoMm5wtf2sTpjovQsVaCBEATCEn2LmX02AGmouQwG3__w?e=h7Taaf" target="_blank">policy briefs we produced on library materials</a>. In this post, I&rsquo;ll describe how I moved from making videos in groups, such as in that video you can see on screen, to creating policy briefs. I&rsquo;ll talk about the stages I have gone through as I have taught with problem solving, and I hope my cautionary tales will help as you think about incorporating problem solving into your own classes, or developing how you already do it.<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#3387a2" size="6">problem-solving sociology</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><span>I&rsquo;ll first provide a short introduction of problem-solving sociology and show you a diagram for it that I use in my classes. </span>As you may know, Monica Prasad published the book Problem-Solving Sociology in 2021. In the book, she proposes that sociologists may focus on problem-solving by asking what causes social problems and also what causes solutions to those problems. The box you can see on screen is from the book. Prasad says sociologists might focus on these questions listed in the box, primarily the latter three. In these questions, we analyze what causes a given problem, what works to solve it, and what causes the solutions to come about.<br /><span></span></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/box-1-1-the-problem-solving-research-cycle_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">In my classes, we use&nbsp;<a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgATc3LcyOlRQp_gov4AQlONAeD7ySfJxcLkXrrRVrmAPj8?e=53rVQC" target="_blank">this diagram</a>&nbsp;that I created based on Prasad's book and also on my own thinking about this. My own additions here are that I like to think about what the ideal society would be, and to categorize the third and fourth questions as "transition" questions that try to move us from the problematic society we face closer to the ideal society. <br /><br />&#8203;You can see there are two levels here, where the more narrow level asks about a particular problem, but we also keep a broader perspective that the problematic society will have many interdependent elements, and so any individual problem isn't really an isolated issue. In the diagram, this is reflected by having "Problematic Society" leading to "The Ideal Society", in contrast to most of the unbolded questions which are about an individual problem that we are focusing on:</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/2026-02-04th-1202-problem-solving-sociology-diagram-diagram-only_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">I teach students how to think using this framework by getting them to use it as essentially a focused coding scheme for their readings, <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgBh-8EBWQ54QrM-hFXk1-XdAXeiAOER63BysdwokhIBRTw?e=HqBojj" target="_blank">which they enter into a spreadsheet</a>. See <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAJoHgjNyR8RLBr3gfY1TpsAXIaA3T2I4fQur_JgiBpHOA?e=NjUmJb" target="_blank">this link for my instructions</a> to students for how to use the spreadsheet, and the pass/fail grading scheme for it. In the early weeks we talk a lot about Excel skills as well. So for each reading in the course schedule, they use the framework to describe what the reading says is the scope of the problem, what causes the problem, what the ideal society would be like, and how we transition to the ideal society. Students are free to choose what to put where in the spreadsheet, I don&rsquo;t require any particular interpretation, and this is pass/fail assignment.&nbsp;</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/spreadsheet_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Above is a screenshot of part of the spreadsheet, <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgBh-8EBWQ54QrM-hFXk1-XdAXeiAOER63BysdwokhIBRTw?e=HqBojj" target="_blank">which you can also see at this link</a>. Some students say learning Excel skills really helps them in their work/life. Others say they'll drop it immediately once the class is finished &ndash; can't please everyone!</div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="6" color="#3387a2">problem-solving research with students</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph">When I first taught using a problem-solving approach, I had a 400-level undergraduate seminar, with 15 students. I taught the class twice. I thought it would be great if we could produce reports and videos about primary research.<br /><br />I began the process of involving students in primary research, when in Canada, by reaching out to organizations that jointly worked on environmental and social justice issues. I asked them what research question or questions they would like answered, that would help move their own initiatives for sustainability and social justice forward. In my seminar at the University of Toronto, we worked with four Canadian organizations over two rounds of the class: Seniors for Climate Action Now, the Council of Canadians, Grandmother&rsquo;s Voice, and the High Park Nature Centre. As part of starting the research, I proceeded to get ethics approval for the class.<br /><br />There were three projects, one looking to answer what is most effective for engaging older adults in climate action. Another investigating how community organizations in Canada had implemented reconciliation and decolonization initiatives. And finally a project on what moves people in nature programs from perceiving nature as a recreational backdrop to perceiving it as a set of ecological relationships.<br /><br />During these 400-level seminars in Canada, we first checked whether the literature could answer the partner&rsquo;s questions. Then, we conducted primary qualitative research to fill literature gaps.<br /><br />One key aspect of these seminars was group work. The first time I had two groups of about 7, and the second time I had three groups of 5. Managing groups who are just learning how to do primary research is a major task in itself, and this format of the class was a great deal of work on my side.</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/400level_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span>The deliverable was also part of the excessive work. In the first round, we produced <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAaD7Y5jfUkQLWcf-LUVs10AZdrMgn-LGdChQvQe5R8fAg?e=N4RphZ" target="_blank">two very long reports</a>, and in the second class, we produced videos, <a href="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MtmR8q6QUGc" target="_blank">but only one of the videos was really shareable</a>. I found that in general, it wasn&rsquo;t feasible to run the class with primary research leading to long reports and videos. It required too great a time commitment on my side. It was rewarding to some degree, but I wanted to make some adjustments.</span><br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="6" color="#3387a2">policy brief direction</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><span>Starting in 2025, in my 300-level classes, the deliverable has been&nbsp;</span><a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgDoMm5wtf2sTpjovQsVaCBEATCEn2LmX02AGmouQwG3__w?e=wpEtRj" target="_blank">individual policy briefs created by each student</a><span>. We also have a new project, as I&rsquo;m now in the US, in New Mexico, working with the Din&eacute; organization Indigenous Lifeways. The current project is to better understand how to improve oil and gas regulation in New Mexico.</span><br /><span>&nbsp;</span><br /><span>So in my recent classes, I have removed group work, and instead I think of each student&rsquo;s project as a small piece of a broader puzzle. And for now I have paused the primary research, partly because I have changed institutions and need to go through ethics approval again.</span><br /><br /><span>What I really appreciate about the policy briefs is that when the class ends, we have a finalized deliverable.&nbsp;</span><a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgDoMm5wtf2sTpjovQsVaCBEATCEn2LmX02AGmouQwG3__w?e=WgfJSQ" target="_blank">At this link, you can see some of these deliverables</a><span>&nbsp;(policy briefs). And&nbsp;</span><a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAJoHgjNyR8RLBr3gfY1TpsAXIaA3T2I4fQur_JgiBpHOA?e=CbQZVc" target="_blank">at this link, you can see the assignment instructions</a><span>, if you want to see how we get there.&nbsp;</span>&#8203;</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/300level_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span>The way we do it is the policy brief is the main assignment. It is scaffolded. I&rsquo;m currently on a 16-week semester, and <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAJoHgjNyR8RLBr3gfY1TpsAXIaA3T2I4fQur_JgiBpHOA?e=aBTTPL" target="_blank">the first assignment is due about week 5. I call it the Statement of Intent</a>. Essentially, here they need to describe what they are going to do in the policy brief.</span><br /><br /><span>I discuss with the community partner what they would like to see in a policy brief, in terms of meeting their goals. I have, so far let students have some discretion given the broad goals of the partner, but students actually didn&rsquo;t like that &ndash; they wanted more direction. Going forward I&rsquo;m going to assign students topics that more precisely help with the partner&rsquo;s needs.</span><br /><br /><span>Then t<a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAJoHgjNyR8RLBr3gfY1TpsAXIaA3T2I4fQur_JgiBpHOA?e=dzWSa0" target="_blank">he mid-term project</a>, anywhere from week 8 to week 10, is a 4-page policy brief, with 1 or more pages of references. My feedback for the mid-term policy brief is extensive. I go through and a describe everything they need to do for the brief to be professional and ready to be given to a policymaker. Students at the University of New Mexico have access to Adobe Express, and they must produce it in Adobe Express, or Canva if they prefer. To create a policy brief in one of those platforms, you can hotwire a newsletter template. But I also have started to create <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgBKjTAn1ttzSIeBH9g9zV7dAdl6wHSrocHDLIHcxjvydig?e=HFroPp" target="_blank">policy brief templates that I share with the students</a>. I do this because the newsletter template can be quite a bit of work to tailor to a policy brief, and some students will do it and others will not.</span><br /><br /><span>Then for <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAJoHgjNyR8RLBr3gfY1TpsAXIaA3T2I4fQur_JgiBpHOA?e=dzWSa0" target="_blank">the final project</a>, just as in an R&amp;R at an academic journal, they need to reply to each of my mid-term comments. They confirm that they have made each edit and they describe what edits they&rsquo;ve made. They also need to expand the policy brief by one additional page, and add a few more references. In addition, students tell me in writing the degree to which they want their brief to be shared, and so give consent or not by the end of the class, in terms of how far it can go.</span><br /><br /><span>When they &ldquo;submit&rdquo; the assignments, at both the mid-term and final stages, they don&rsquo;t submit a PDF but rather a collaborator link in either Adobe Express or Canva. This is an important detail: it makes sure that if we get to the end of the semester and a few edits need to be made, I can just make them.</span><br /><br /><span>In the end, these briefs are completed in one semester. Using the method of having a small number of pages with a great deal of focus on each, we have produced deliverables that are more useful to the partner and also more feasible for me in terms of time commitment. In this way of doing things, there is no long report that I need to edit, and videos were just too high stakes, hard to edit, and essentially need a film editing class in order to be successful.</span><br /><br /><span>My take home lessons are:</span><br /><br /><span>First, maybe you have figured out a better method for groups, but I found that group work in this problem-solving context was very time consuming for me and for the students. I found that you essentially become a conflict manager at some point, which is a large part of the time commitment.</span><br /><br /><span>My second take-away is that I think it&rsquo;s useful to design deliverables that students can finish at a high standard in one semester. Another benefit of policy briefs is that if you can find some funds and print them, they can actually find their way into the hands of policymakers who are working on the issues important to community partners. In any case, when you can give extensive comments at the mid-term, and ask them to hand in a response memo for the final alongside an edited brief, I have found this to be feasible and successful.</span><br /><br /><span>Thank you for reading, and I hope some of this helps as you develop your own approaches to teaching with problem-solving. If you want to see all of the details of how I run this, <a href="https://1drv.ms/f/c/ffb7e777ec661c25/IgAwkbnWh6HlToil9guNrTpzARGJKoAa8OHLeKOJhDoX8zQ?e=8VLyNb" target="_blank">you can see my current syllabus here.</a></span></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Reading Notes from Students, Winter 2023]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/reading-notes-from-students-winter-2023]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/reading-notes-from-students-winter-2023#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Tue, 09 May 2023 22:34:01 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/reading-notes-from-students-winter-2023</guid><description><![CDATA[I taught a class in Winter 2023 where the students submitted weekly Reading/Listen/Watch notes.For the readings, students were encouraged to use whatever is their current reading method, and to adapt it given our discussions of reading notes each class.For the audio and video sources assigned in the class, students were encouraged to just do a short 100 word summary.Students also wrote a short reflection about how effective the notes were each week at helping them learn the material and creating [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I taught a class in Winter 2023 where the students submitted weekly Reading/Listen/Watch notes.<br />For the readings, students were encouraged to use whatever is their current reading method, and to adapt it given our discussions of reading notes each class.<br />For the audio and video sources assigned in the class, students were encouraged to just do a short 100 word summary.<br />Students also wrote a short reflection about how effective the notes were each week at helping them learn the material and creating a resource that would help them quickly and effectively review the source later.<br />Students were encouraged to focus on the main points in the readings, rather than get lost in all the details. They were also encouraged to find a way to separate out, clearly, the main points from supporting details in their notes.<br />In this post, I'll show you (with their permission) how some of the students' notes progressed over the term.</div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">1. Dania</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Dania started out using a word document bullet-point structure.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-38-32_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Another reading in these notes looked like this:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-38-45_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">After taking these notes, Dania reflected:<br />"I used the outlining method to take my reading notes and I did not really like it at all. It was very time consuming the way in which I did it. This is typically how I will structure my synchronous lecture notes that I take in real time, however this week taught me that it does not translate over as efficiently as a reading notes model. I found that this method was time consuming for me because I really felt like I had to copy all the important points and quotes over from the readings and then add in a little piece of my thoughts at applicable places, just to replace the function of highlighting/annotating. It took a lot more time than I had anticipated. I did, however, enjoy making the summaries of the Listen and Watch materials. In the future, I want to explore the mind map method, the summary method, and the Cornell notes method. I doubt I will come back to this method for readings but I did also enjoy making that T-chart on page 4 [as in the above picture, for the Tuck et al. 2014 reading] based on the information I was reading in the article."<br /><br />For the next class's notes, Dania changed to the Cornell method:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-43-07_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-43-26_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">And for the "Watch"/video:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-46-15_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">She reflected on these notes, "Contrary to last week&rsquo;s method, I actually enjoyed this note-taking style a lot more! It was definitely easier to focus more on the main points and took less time than the old, detailed outline method. While I still think I need to focus more on summarizing and being concise with the information that is being presented in the passages, I definitely enjoyed being able to have key points and definitions on one side and focus on the explanatory information on the other side. I think I would continue to stick with this way of keeping key definitions separate from the main notes because last time I got a bit bogged down by making sure to explain them in depth. I also did not have that hard of a time making summaries for the Watch materials, but when I thought to summarize the reading material I did not think I could do that just yet. I hope to be able to confidently write a summary of the reading materials soon."<br /><br />For the next set of notes, Dania tried out the mapping method:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-18-47-41_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">She reflected, "This week, I used the mind mapping method for the readings, and I actually really liked it. For about 90% of my university career, I have always typed my notes, but returning to pen and paper was very interesting. It was really helpful to make notes and connect concepts and ideas as I read the paper. This method helped me to make connections between the ideas being presented and helped me to finally summarize my notes to one page! However, I did not anticipate the hand cramps that would accompany this much writing. I would be interested in learning about any digital mind mapping tools to make this process easier. But in sum, I did enjoy this method and being able to employ my colour coding in it was nice as well &ndash; I will probably try it again!"<br /><br />Dania then switched to using Miro (miro.com), to taking the notes, using the mind map template from Miro:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/dania-notes-1_orig.jpg" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">She reflected, "For this week I tried something different with my mind mapping method and used the online platform Miro to create my mind maps. This was an interesting way to do my mind mapping, I was still able to use my legend (red = main points, blue = supporting points, pink = examples, purple = definitions, green = discussion points) and I think it helped save me time from copying things down in readings. It also did not hurt my hands as much as making elaborate mind maps by hand did. I think I will continue with this method, I was also able to include page numbers. What I appreciated most however, was the freedom this gave me in making my notes as far reaching as possible without the confines of space that physical paper limits me to."<br />Dania continued with this method for the rest of the class.<br />She reflected, in the last set of notes: "For this week&rsquo;s materials I continued with the mind mapping method using the Miro platform. I think these maps would provide me with a good overview of the reading and its main points if I had to refresh my memory on it. All in all, this mind mapping process continued to be an enjoyable and thought provoking exercise for me to deeply engage with the readings at hand."<br />It was great to see Dania's experiments with note-taking! (And for anyone who knows me, I'm a fan of the map method)<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">2. Kaela</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Kaela experimented a bit at the start of the class, and quickly figured out a Cornell method style, using the note-taking program Notability and a colour-coding system, that she refined over the class.<br />Her first set of notes were in a more basic bullet point format:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-00-14_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-00-22_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">She reflected,<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-02-19_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">In her third set of notes, she changed to the Cornell method, using a template in the Notability app:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-03-51_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">She reflected,<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-05-05_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Kaela kept this system until the end of the class, refining it as she went. This next image is from her last set of notes. You can see that she has a colour coded legend, and also an overall page summary at the bottom of the page, two methods she refined during the course of the semester.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-06-28_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">By the end of the class, after doubting this method a couple of times, she had ended up enjoying it. She reflected,<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-09-46_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">In general, I thought her notes were clear and organized, and allowed for seeing the main points clearly (which she would put in the left side panel, or indicate them with the colour codes).<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">3. Hema</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Hema stuck with an outline method for the semester. She produced clear notes and was consistently refining them to make them as concise as possible, something she explicitly reflected about. She also tried to ensure that the main points of the sources were clearly visible.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-20-27-28_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Reflecting on these notes, she said, "I believe that my reading approaches this week has been effective as I was able to read the papers as well as watch the videos while writing down everything that immediately stood out to me. After I had finished watching doing the readings as a whole <strong>I went back and further condensed my notes</strong> in order to ensure that I was only including what I thought the main take always, that would best help me in my learning".<br /><br />In her fourth set of notes, she tried out writing them by hand:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-20-29-50_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Reflecting on these hand-written notes, Hema said, "For this week's readings, I decided to handwrite my notes to see if it was an effective way of condensing and retaining information. While I found that when I was writing the key points down I was inputting the information on the page in more of my own words rather than simply paraphrasing like I normally tend to do when typing, I found that handwriting my notes were <strong>not as efficient and took me a lot longer </strong>than typing would have. I do find a benefit to handwriting notes however it is not a feasible method when I have readings to complete for five different classes each week. I would use this method when studying for tests."<br /><br />In her remaining notes in the class, Hema used the outline method on Word documents. She also sometimes added, at the end of the notes, a main themes section for the notes for that class as a whole:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-20-33-42_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So she included notes for all of the readings (the above just shows the start of one article's notes), and then wrote:<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-20-33-55_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Overall, her notes were clear and detailed.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">4. Anna</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Anna started with a map method, shifted to a computer-based outline method, and then finished the semester doing the Cornell notes style, but on paper rather than on an app.<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-20-35_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-20-42_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-20-50_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/screen-shot-2023-05-09-at-19-21-08_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Reflecting on her last sets of notes (using the Cornell method), Anna said, "I like this technique because I can go back and I have room to make comments on the side while the lecture answers my questions or adds to it. I like this model for note taking a lot. I like that it leaves space for questions and to extract the main ideas, of my key points further. I am not to good with finding the main themes of my key points as they are broken up, but I am working on it! I will stick with this method."<br />I like that Anna used many visual methods (like arrows to show relationships) and that she had methods to revise the notes and add to them (e.g., listening to lecture and adding to the left column). She also used the left pane to indicate main points, which was great.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">5. Conclusion, and a note for graduate students</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">As these different approaches demonstrate, different methods work for different people. The most important thing is to find a method that works for you. I think all of these students were engaging deeply with the material and they were able to demonstrate that in class discussions.<br />For graduate students, it can be more useful to find a way to take notes that create themes across sources, rather than having per-source notes.<br />Pre-candidacy in graduate school, I used the on-paper map notes method, as Dania demonstrated above. I used fountain pens and 24 lb paper, since that made it possible to have long-lasting notes (high quality ink and paper), to take a lot of notes (fountain pens are ergonomic), and to also scan them easily (the paper was better than a notebook for that, since I didn't have to hold the notebook open).&nbsp; So this was a per-source method, with one set of notes per article or chapter.<br />As graduate school progressed, however, and I moved out of comprehensive exams and classes and into writing literature reviews and discussion sections of journal articles, I changed my method. I now use Atlas.ti and Miro. I first use Atlas.ti to read many articles in a field and come up with a set of common themes across articles, and then I use Miro to summarize the coding structure in a visual way. Atlas.ti is a qualitative coding program, but you can also use it for literature reviews (and it is also advertised for literature reviews). Miro (miro.com), as Dania demonstrated above in her last set of notes, is an online whiteboard. I don't use the stock "map" template that Dania used (Miro has templates), instead I use boxes, add text to them, and add arrows between them. (I don't mean to imply that Dania's method is wrong &ndash; I encourage students to use the methods that work best for them! The Miro map template just doesn't work for me.)&nbsp; This Atlas.ti + Miro method allows for writing most effectively, I find. One is rarely simply summarizing one article or chapter after another in academic writing. Note that Atlas.ti and Miro are both paid &ndash; Atlas.ti is about $150 Canadian for students (2-year license), and Miro is $10 USD/month (that is the monthly plan, it's a bit cheaper with a yearly plan).<br />Thank you to all the students who shared their notes! I hope this post helps you think about and refine your own reading method. If you are reading this and have a note-taking method you really like, I'd be happy to learn about it and perhaps post about it on this blog in the future (you could email me about it at tyler.bateman@mail.utoronto.ca). I know some people like to use spreadsheets, for example, but I haven't described that here, and I'm sure there are many other effective methods I haven't considered &ndash; for undergraduate, graduate students, professors, and people who make the effort to read and learn outside of academia.<br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[A Study of Journal Article Structure]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-study-of-journal-article-structure]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-study-of-journal-article-structure#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Wed, 22 Feb 2023 02:42:33 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/a-study-of-journal-article-structure</guid><description><![CDATA[I studied journal article structure by looking at Jessica Calarco&rsquo;s outline of a journal article (located here as of 21 Feb 2023: http://www.jessicacalarco.com/teaching-resources-1/2019/8/30/article-writing-101 ) and reverse outlining a set of articles by someone in my field.&nbsp;What I found was that, for the 7 articles I coded, Calarco&rsquo;s outline was never exactly applied. Some articles ranged further from the outline in particular sections. Sometimes they followed some of the outl [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">I studied journal article structure by looking at Jessica Calarco&rsquo;s outline of a journal article (located here as of 21 Feb 2023: http://www.jessicacalarco.com/teaching-resources-1/2019/8/30/article-writing-101 ) and reverse outlining a set of articles by someone in my field.<br />&nbsp;<br />What I found was that, for the 7 articles I coded, Calarco&rsquo;s outline was never exactly applied. Some articles ranged further from the outline in particular sections. Sometimes they followed some of the outline and neglected others. Sometimes they did most of the things but did them in a different order.<br />&nbsp;<br />After doing this, I know what <em>usually</em> happens in each section (at least across these 7 articles). Given this study, I came up with an alternative outline to Calarco's.<br /></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">ALTERNATIVE OUTLINE</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">The analysis section for this outline is for a qualitative article.<br /></div>  <div><div style="margin: 10px 0 0 -10px"> <a title="Download file: alternative_journal_article_outline_qualitative.docx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/alternative_journal_article_outline_qualitative.docx"><img src="//www.weebly.com/weebly/images/file_icons/rtf.png" width="36" height="36" style="float: left; position: relative; left: 0px; top: 0px; margin: 0 15px 15px 0; border: 0;" /></a><div style="float: left; text-align: left; position: relative;"><table style="font-size: 12px; font-family: tahoma; line-height: .9;"><tr><td colspan="2"><b> alternative_journal_article_outline_qualitative.docx</b></td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Size:  </td><td>19 kb</td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Type:  </td><td> docx</td></tr></table><a title="Download file: alternative_journal_article_outline_qualitative.docx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/alternative_journal_article_outline_qualitative.docx" style="font-weight: bold;">Download File</a></div> </div>  <hr style="clear: both; width: 100%; visibility: hidden"></hr></div>  <div class="paragraph"><br />If you want to know all the detail, keep reading.<br /><br />In the following sections of this post, I will italicize the codes I used (I used Atlas.ti to code these).<br />&nbsp;<br />I will put numbers in parentheses to mark how many times I coded a particular move in the articles. So this is not number of articles that had these passages, but instead how many times the move happened. So if a paper mentioned the data, then mentioned the findings, then mentioned the data again, in that sequence, there would be <em>Data </em>(2) and <em>Findings</em> (1).<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">ABSTRACTS</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#24678d">This is Calarco&rsquo;s outline for abstracts:<br />&nbsp;<br />250 words or less</font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">State your research question</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Explain how this research question speaks to a larger theoretical puzzle or gap in the literature (<em>Gap in existing literature</em>)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe the data that you use to answer your research question (<em>Data</em>)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">State what you find (<em>Findings</em>)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe what these findings suggest about the answer to your research question</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Explain why these findings are important (<em>Contribution to understanding world / Explain why these findings are important</em>)</font></li></ul><font color="#2a2a2a">&nbsp;<br />The most common moves in abstracts were to talk about <em>Findings</em> (13) and to describe the <em>Data</em> (11). Then the next most common moves were to discuss the <em>Contribution to Literature</em> (9) and to discuss <em>Existing Literature</em> (8).<br />&nbsp;<br />The moderately common moves in the articles were to <em>Identify an empirical case that has had relatively little attention in the literature</em> (5), <em>State the research question</em> (even if it wasn&rsquo;t exactly in the form of a question, something like, &ldquo;This paper analyzes how X and Y relate&rdquo;) (4), and <em>State a fact about the world </em>(such as, &ldquo;ethical consumption is a popular form of everyday politics&rdquo;) (4).<br />&nbsp;<br />Rare in abstracts were to explicitly articulate a <em>Gap in existing literature</em> (2), define a <em>Theory/Concept</em> (2), and mention a <em>Contribution to understanding world / Explain why these findings are important</em> (2).<br />&nbsp;<br />Abstracts ranged from 172&ndash;251 words.</font><br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">INTRODUCTIONS</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#24678d">Calarco&rsquo;s Sections (she says the introduction should be <strong>3 paragraphs</strong>) with my edits<br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Describe the puzzle or gap in the literature that you will address with your data </strong><br /></font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">What do we know?</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">What do we not know (or not know well enough)?</font><br /></li><li><font color="#24678d">What does the existing research suggest might be the answer to that unanswered question?</font></li></ul><font color="#24678d">&nbsp;<br /><strong>Identify your research question and explain how you answer it </strong><br /></font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">What question will you answer? (Or what hypothesis will you test? )</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">What data will you use to answer this question? (Or test this hypothesis? )</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">What do you find?</font></li></ul><font color="#24678d">&nbsp;<br /><strong>Explain the importance of your findings </strong><br /></font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">What is the answer to your research question?</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">CONTRIBUTION: How does this answer broaden, clarify, or challenge existing knowledge/theories? / TB edit: How does the paper&rsquo;s answer to the research question(s) broaden, clarify, or challenge existing knowledge/theories? (I made this edit because sometimes this comes before the authors state the research questions)</font><br /></li><li><font color="#24678d">CONTRIBUTION: How does the paper&rsquo;s answer to the research question(s) broaden, clarify, or challenge existing knowledge/theories?</font></li></ul>&nbsp;<br />&nbsp;<br />Introductions most commonly discussed <em>What we Know</em> (12) and <em>Findings</em> (12).<br />&nbsp;<br />They often discussed <em>What do we not know? </em>(8), discussed the contribution (7), described the data (7), stated the research question(s) (7), and discussed what the existing research suggests might be the answer to the research question (6).<br />&nbsp;<br />They sometimes discussed the general analytical strategy of the paper (4) and clarified a concept (3).<br />&nbsp;<br />The papers rarely mentioned a fact in the world (2) (e.g., &ldquo;a growing cultural narrative that children are &ldquo;at risk&rdquo;&rdquo;), a problem in the world (1), explained theoretical concepts (2), mentioned an exciting new trend in research (1), signposted what was to come in the article (2), provided a data excerpt (1), and gave wider context for findings (1).<br />&nbsp;<br />Introductions ranged from 401&ndash;1,188 words.<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">JUSTIFICATION/LITERATURE REVIEW<br /></font></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#24678d">Calarco&rsquo;s Outline (She says it should be &ldquo;1,000 words or less&rdquo;)<br /></font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">Restate the puzzle or gap in the literature that you will address</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Explain why this puzzle or gap is important to address</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe (in more detail than in the intro) what we know about this topic/issue</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe (in more detail than in the intro) what we do not know about this topic/issue</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">State your research question (i.e., &ldquo;In light of these lingering questions, I seek to examine&hellip;&rdquo;)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Explain how your research question solves the puzzle or fills the gap in the literature (i.e., &ldquo;Answering this question allows me to&hellip;&rdquo;)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Note: The point of a literature review is not actually to review all of the relevant literature. The point is to make the case for why your study is important.</font></li></ul>&nbsp;<br />Calarco calls this the &ldquo;justification&rdquo; section to highlight that &ldquo;The point of a literature review is not actually to review all of the relevant literature &hellip;The point is to make the case for why your study is important.&rdquo;<br />&nbsp;<br />As you can guess, the most common move in the justification section is to talk about <em>What we Know</em> (39). The next common move is to <em>Restate the puzzle or gap in the literature that you will address</em> (12). Then the most common move after that is <em>Justifying choice of literature or concept(s)</em> (5).<br />&nbsp;<br />Then there are several less-common moves, such as: <em>Clarifying/Defining a Concept</em> (4), <em>Contribution(s)/Clarifying the relationship of the paper to what we know</em> (3), mention the research question(s) (3), mention facts about the world (2) or problems in the world (1), mention a general question (&ldquo;how queer people connect in the digital age&rdquo;), coining a concept (1), and discussing a new trend in research (1).<br />&nbsp;<br />Justification sections ranged from 776 &ndash; 3,390 words.<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">METHODS</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#24678d">Calarco says these should be &ldquo;4-6 short paragraphs&rdquo;, and this is her outline:</font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">Provide a brief overview of the study</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe your research site, why you chose it, and how you gained access</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe your research participants (the people you observed)</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Discuss your role in the field and how your identity shaped your observations</font><br /></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe the fieldwork you conducted and the data you collected</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe how you analyzed the data you collected</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Describe the limitations of your study (i.e., explain how your study is limited by your methodological choices)</font></li></ul> &nbsp;<br />Most common in methods sections was <em>Characterizing the Sample / Describe the Data Collected</em> (24). The articles were mostly qualitative, and the next most common codes were <em>Interviewee/Focus Group Recruitment Methods</em> (8), <em>Qualitative Coding Method / Describe how you analyzed the data collected</em> (7), a general discussion of analytical strategy (8) (e.g., &ldquo;By studying the political talk of organizational leaders advocating eat-local food practices in three cities, we aim to capture a sense of<br />the broader discourse animating eat-local activism in the Canadian context&rdquo;.), describing interview questions asked (6), describing the research sites (6), describing the general strategy for data collection (5) (e.g., &ldquo;This geographic range allowed us to access a diversity of perspectives that were not constrained to the specific environmental and regulatory conditions of a single region or province.&rdquo;), and giving a brief study overview (4).<br />&nbsp;<br />Less common moves were to make a statement that all names reported were pseudonyms (3 &ndash; the other articles did this in the analysis sections), make a statement about the representativeness of the findings (3), provide some findings (2), discuss empirical or theoretical literature (1), discuss methodological literature (1), describe political jurisdictions in which the data was collected (1), defining concepts (1), and explaining unfamiliar methods (1) (latent class analysis was the unfamiliar method described).<br />&nbsp;<br />Methods sections ranged from 469&ndash;2,464 words. The article with the 2,464-word methods section was a mixed-methods study. Methods sections had 3&ndash;7 paragraphs.<br />&nbsp;<br />The methods section were called &ldquo;Data and Methods&rdquo; (3), &ldquo;Data and Method&rdquo; (2), &ldquo;Methods and Data&rdquo; (1), and &ldquo;Study Design and Data&rdquo; (1).<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">ANALYSIS</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#24678d">Calarco&rsquo;s outline (she gives no word limit suggestion)</font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">State your argument</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Identify 2-3 supporting points &ndash; how your data support your argument</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Identify 2-3 patterns in the data that provide evidence for each supporting point</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">For each pattern:</font><ul><li><font color="#24678d">Individual Example(s) &ndash; Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Briefly explain how this example represents the larger pattern</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Provide a brief fieldnote, interview, or other data excerpt</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Explain how this subtheme links to the overall theme &ndash; may include developing/enhancing overall theme [TB addition]</font></li></ul></li><li><font color="#24678d">Offer EXPLANATION for observed patterns</font></li><li><font color="#24678d">Caveats and clarifications identify any key exceptions to or variations to the overall patterns, and if possible, offer an explanation for these exceptions/variations</font></li></ul> &nbsp;<br />Most common in analysis sections was to <em>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion (e.g., through a quote)</em> (129), <em>Generalizing Across Sample</em> (64) (e.g., &ldquo;For many mothers, the nutritional importance of meat for a growing child&rsquo;s diet was a matter of common sense.&rdquo;), and <em>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme</em> (52).<br />&nbsp;<br />Calarco, in her outline, talks about the difference between &ldquo;supporting points&rdquo; and &ldquo;patterns in the data that provide evidence for each supporting point&rdquo;. I did not find that distinction intuitive. Instead, I talked about analysis sections as having an &ldquo;overall theme&rdquo; (i.e., the main message of the findings). Then all of the papers broke that overall finding into subthemes. I called those subthemes just &ldquo;subthemes&rdquo; or &ldquo;First Order Subthemes&rdquo;. Then if one of those subthemes had a subtheme, I called that a &ldquo;Second Order Subtheme&rdquo; (I&rsquo;m getting the idea of first, second, etc. &ldquo;order&rdquo; from Greek Philosophy &mdash; I&rsquo;m using the idea loosely, but I wanted to use this language instead of saying things like &ldquo;Sub-sub theme&rdquo; or &ldquo;Sub-sub-sub Theme&rdquo;; so in the way I am using it, a &ldquo;Sub-sub Theme&rdquo; is a &ldquo;Second Order Subtheme&rdquo;). And so on. Some of the papers ended up having Fourth-order subthemes, and one paper even went so far as to have Sixth-order Subthemes. So it just refers to nesting of subthemes within each other.<br />&nbsp;<br />So what I found in terms of that is that there were the overall theme was not mentioned that often, as might be expected (7 times), subthemes were mentioned a lot more (37 times), Second Order Subthemes were a main aspect of the articles (mentioned 45 times), as were Third Order Subthemes (used 58 times). Then the more nested categories beyond that were rare: Fourth Order Subthemes (19), Fifth Order Subthemes (3), and Sixth Order Subthemes (2). So as you can see, most of the papers had 3 levels of <em>subthemes</em>. Something like this:<br />&nbsp;<br />Overall message of paper<ul><li>Subtheme 1<ul><li>Second Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Third Order Subtheme 1<br /></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2</li></ul></li><li>Second Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Third Order Subtheme 1</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 3</li></ul></li></ul></li><li>Subtheme 2<ul><li>Second Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Third Order Subtheme 1</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 3</li></ul></li><li>Second Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Third Order Subtheme 1</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2</li></ul></li></ul></li></ul> &nbsp;<br />That was the typical kind of structure in these articles.<br />&nbsp;<br />Some of the other common moves that happened in the articles were discussing how the findings were consistent with previous literature (31), <em>introducing</em> a set of first/second/third/fourth/fifth/sixth order subthemes (14), and generalizing beyond the sample/contextualizing the findings (12).<br />&nbsp;<br />Less common moves were discussing a conflict between the data and existing literature (7), offering an explanation for the observed patterns (5), stating the research question(s) (4), stating that the respondents&rsquo; names were pseudonyms (3), stating an analytical strategy (3) (e.g., &ldquo;Our focus group data allow us to paint a richer picture of this orientation to food&rdquo;.), and defining or clarifying a concept (2).<br />&nbsp;<br />Analysis sections were 2,859 &ndash; 6,411 words (the highest one there is not the mixed methods study).</div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">DISCUSSION</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">&nbsp;<br />Calarco says that this should be 1,000 words or less. This is Calarco&rsquo;s outline, with additions I made. In general, I found Discussion/Conclusion sections to be the most variable in terms of format. I numbered Calarco&rsquo;s sections and added a &ldquo;title&rdquo; section. &ldquo;TJB&rdquo; are my initials, indicating where I added a section.<br />1 &ndash; TJB &gt; Title of Section<br /><strong>2 &ndash; Summarize your findings </strong><br />2.1 Remind readers of the puzzle/gap in the literature that you are trying to solve<br />2.2. Remind readers of the specific research question that you have answered<br />2.3. Review what you found<br />2.4. Explain what these findings imply about the answer to your research question<br /><strong>3 &ndash; Discuss the implications of your findings </strong><br />3.1. TJB &gt; State Implication(s) of Findings (without doing any of the sub-tasks Calarco outlines)<br />3.2. Explain how your findings solve the puzzle or fill the gap in the literature<br />3.3. Explain how the resolution of the gap/puzzle helps to clarify, challenge, or expand existing knowledge or theory<br />3.3. TJB &gt; Explain how themes and/or subthemes, or the implication(s) of the findings, clarify, challenge, or expand exiting knowledge or theory<br />3.4. Using existing literature, explain why your findings are or are not surprising<br />3.5. TJB &gt; Simply explain how previously published literature relates to your findings, without commenting on whether it is surprising relative to findings, and without saying that your data clarifies, challenges, or expands previous literature<br />3.6. TJB &gt; Identify areas of social life where your argument likely applies<br />3.7. TJB &gt; Draw out implications of your findings, without referring to literature<br /><strong>4 &ndash; Identify possible explanations for your findings </strong><br />4.1. TJB &gt; Identify a possible explanation for your findings without referring to existing research<br />4.2. Use existing research to discuss the most likely explanation for your findings<br />4.3. Consider alternative explanations for your findings and explain (using your data and/or other research) why these alternative explanations do or do not seem plausible<br />4.4. Conclude by reviewing why these findings (and the larger puzzle/gap they address) are important<br />5 &ndash; Apply Findings<br />5.1. TJB &gt; Evaluate social change strategy held by respondents or scholarship activism more broadly by referring to literature and/or through argument referencing the study&rsquo;s data<br />6 &ndash; TJB &gt; Discuss Limitations<br />7 &ndash; TJB &gt; Future Research<br />8 &ndash; TJB &gt; Generalizing Beyond Sample without Referencing Literature<br />&nbsp;<br />The titles were pretty boring and consistent &mdash; either &ldquo;Discussion&rdquo; or &ldquo;Discussion and Conclusion&rdquo;.<br />&nbsp;<br />Most of the articles didn&rsquo;t have a separate &ldquo;Conclusion&rdquo; section. So I just lumped them together. It seems, in general, that it is conventional enough to just forego the conclusion, unless you want a dedicated place to talk about future research. Future research isn&rsquo;t in Calarco&rsquo;s outline.<br />&nbsp;<br />The most common move in the Discussion was to review the findings (13).<br />&nbsp;<br />Then the general &ldquo;implications&rdquo; move was to <em>3.3. Explain how the resolution of the gap/puzzle helps to clarify, challenge, or expand existing knowledge or theory</em> (8). Sometimes, though, this main implications move was done a bit differently, and I reworded it to <em>3.3. TJB &gt; Explain how implication of findings, themes and/or subthemes clarify, challenge, or expand exiting knowledge or theory</em> (5).<br />&nbsp;<br />Then the most common moves were:<br /><ul><li><em>3.1. TJB &gt; State Implication(s) of Findings (without doing any of the sub-tasks Calarco outlines) </em>(6)</li><li>talk about future research (5), <em>2.1 &ndash; Remind readers of the puzzle/gap in the literature that you are trying to solve</em> (4)</li><li><em>3.6. TJB &gt; <a>Identify areas of social life where your argument likely applies</a></em> (4)</li><li><em>4.4. Conclude by reviewing why these findings (and the larger puzzle/gap they address) are important</em> (3)</li><li><em>Generalizing Beyond Sample without Referencing Literature</em> (3) (e.g., &ldquo;As urban Canadian and American consumers are encouraged to understand how meals arrive on the plate, educating children about &ldquo;where food comes from&rdquo; has become central to an idealized performance of maternal foodwork.&rdquo;)</li><li><em>2.2. &ndash; Remind readers of the specific research question that you have answered</em> (2)</li><li><em>Literature CONSISTENCY </em>(2) (discuss how your findings are consistent with literature)</li><li><em>5.1. Evaluate social change strategy held by respondents or scholarship activism more broadly by referring to literature and/or through argument referencing the study&rsquo;s data</em> (2)</li><li><em>4.2. Use existing research to discuss the most likely explanation for your findings </em>(2)</li><li><em>3.4. Using existing literature, explain why your findings are or are not surprising </em>(2)</li><li><em>3.5. TJB &gt; Simply explain how previously published literature relates to your findings, without commenting on whether it is surprising relative to findings, and without saying that your data clarifies, challenges, or expands previous literature</em> (2)</li><li><em>3.7. TJB &gt; Draw out implications of your findings, without referring to literature </em>(2)<br /></li></ul></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">OVERALL ASSESSMENT</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Overall, I did find Calarco&rsquo;s outline to be a good general guide for understanding the structure of journal articles. But as you can see, the structures varied <em>widely</em>.<br />&nbsp;<br />This is not to say that they <em>should</em> have varied widely. Perhaps it would indeed be better if everyone kept to the exact structure that Calarco outlined. At least in some cases of course (mixed methods or purely quantitative data), you couldn&rsquo;t exactly follow that template.<br />&nbsp;<br />But something I found in these articles is that they weren&rsquo;t trying to deeply change theory. If you just looked at Calarco&rsquo;s outline, you might think that every article had to have a major theoretical contribution. There is this article &hellip;<br />&nbsp;<br />Besbris, Max, and Shamus Khan. 2017. &ldquo;Less Theory. More Description.&rdquo; <em>Sociological Theory</em> 35(2):147&ndash;53.<br />&nbsp;<br />&hellip; where they worry about people trying to revolutionize thinking with every contribution. That is certainly something I have learned in graduate school: that you don&rsquo;t actually have to make ground-breaking theoretical contributions every time or even <em>ever</em>. And if you do that, sometimes you are typecast as a &ldquo;theory&rdquo; person, as in, a particular subfield of sociology. There are many debates about the status of theory and I&rsquo;m not going to give a literature review of that here (e.g., in terms of whether it should be ever considered a sub-category of sociology or whether everyone should engage with theory construction, among other issues). But when you read Calarco's outline and it says identify a &ldquo;puzzle or gap in the literature&rdquo; it doesn't mean a major theoretical gap. Replicating research is, of course, frowned upon in sociology (but not in e.g., biology etc.). So it isn&rsquo;t that you don&rsquo;t have to find some kind of a gap. You do. But the gap doesn&rsquo;t have to be a major modification or take-down of a theory. It can be an empirical gap, and you can just imply that the gap is there, while constructing an argument with important implications.<br />&nbsp;<br />I created this post (and document, see end of post) so that I would have <em>template outlines</em> for my drafts. I added all the quotes for the various coded parts so that I could know what I meant by a particular code. I&rsquo;ve left that all here, you can take it or leave it (or modify it, or whatever). It also led to me drafting an alternative outline to Calarco's (see below).<br />&nbsp;<br />Also, all the codings in the document (attached at the bottom of this post) is a first draft. As I work with this I may re-code something or refine some kind of this structure. The document has all the details of the coding, the kind of behind-the-scenes process that you usually don&rsquo;t get in qualitative coding! And people don&rsquo;t give it out because they don&rsquo;t want to be proven wrong etc. (which some people, like Biernacki, find a way to do anyway! Biernacki, Richard. 2012. <em>Reinventing Evidence in Social Inquiry</em>. New York, USA and Basingstoke, UK: Palgrave Macmillan). So the document's full coding looks messy and I&rsquo;m sure you can find a way to improve the coding structure there (I know I will!). But if you want to see what I see as the outline of these articles (in a structural way) I wanted to provide all the detail, which you may find useful.<br />&nbsp;<br />I outlined more abstracts than the full papers&mdash;at the abstract phase, I was trying to figure out which I wanted a full outline for. So if you open the full document, you'll see more abstracts than the other sections.<br /></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">ALTERNATIVE OUTLINE</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Given all of this, I have made an alternative outline, that I tried to simplify. There are, of course, many other things you can add. But from my reading, these are what are most important.<br />&nbsp;<br /><em>***Many of these are copied from Calarco&rsquo;s outline; in some cases, moves that are distinct in her outline are combined here***</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><strong>Abstract (150&ndash;250 words)</strong><br /><ul><li>Existing literature / What we know<br /></li><li>Research Question / Gap or Puzzle / State that your empirical case has had relatively little attention in the literature / What we do not know</li><li>Data</li><li>Findings</li><li>Contributions to literature</li><li>OPTIONAL: Contribution to how activists [or some other category of social actor &ndash; businesses, governments, etc.] should be thinking about something</li></ul>&nbsp;<br /><strong>Introduction &ndash; Basically it is an extended version of the abstract / a mini version of your full paper</strong><br /><ul><li>Existing literature / What we know<br /></li><li>Research Question / Gap or Puzzle / State that your empirical case has had relatively little attention in the literature / What we do not know</li><li>Data</li><li>Findings</li><li>Contributions to literature</li><li>OPTIONAL: Contribution to how activists [or some other category of social actor &ndash; businesses, governments, etc.] should be thinking about something</li></ul>&nbsp;<br /><strong>Justification</strong><br /><ul><li>Existing literature / What we know</li><li>Research Question / Gap or Puzzle / State that your empirical case has had relatively little attention in the literature / What we do not know</li></ul>&nbsp;<br /><strong>Methods and Data</strong><br /><ul><li>Characterize the sample / Describe the data collected (this is going to happen at several different points in the section &ndash; it&rsquo;s less of a section in itself and more of a move that you do several times in the methods section &ndash; it is for anything that gives some shape or contours to the data collected) (e.g., &ldquo;Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 40 women who saw food as important to their identities&rdquo;) (e.g., &ldquo;Interviewees had varied meat practices and preferences. Sixty-four percent were meat eaters (49), with 6% eating meat at every meal (5), 35% eating it every day (27), and 23% eating it occasionally (18). Purposive recruitment was done to interview a significant number of people who don&rsquo;t eat meat (in order to better understand this relatively unusual choice); as a result, 23% of respondents identified as vegetarian (18) and 12% as vegan (9).&rdquo;)</li><li>Describe how you collected the data (interviewee recruitment methods, etc.)</li><li>Describe some of the instruments (e.g., explain Latent Class Analysis or give a few particularly relevant interview questions)</li><li>Describe the research site(s) (I mean &ldquo;site&rdquo; broadly defined&mdash;online, where interviews were done, fieldwork research site, etc.)</li><li>Describe how you analyzed the data collected</li><li>You may want to mention somewhere in the section that all names are pseudonyms &ndash; otherwise, plan to do that the first time a name is mentioned in the analysis section (e.g., with a footnote/endnote)</li></ul>&nbsp;<br /><strong>Analysis</strong><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>FOR QUALITATIVE ARTICLES ONLY: Have a structure something like this. </em><br /><em>***You do not have to have a certain number of subthemes, second order subthemes, third order subthemes, etc. &ndash; do what you actually have, whatever the nested structure is for your codes.***</em><br /><em>***When you are coding, make sure you nest the codes so that you can write this section with ease when you get to the writing stage.***</em><br />&nbsp;<br /><em>I realize the structure here is very repetitive, but I want to show the general structure.</em> (SEE BELOW FOR A WORD DOC WITH COLOUR CODES, for this and other sections).<br />&nbsp;<br /><ul><li>Overall message of paper</li><li>Introduce the sub-themes<ul><li>Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)<br /></li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature<br /></li><li>Introduce the Second Order Sub-themes<br /></li><li>Second Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)<br /></li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)<br /></li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature<br /></li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li></ul></li><li>Second Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 3<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li></ul></li><li>OPTIONAL: Generalize beyond the sample/contextualize the findings</li><li>OPTIONAL: Offer explanation(s) for the observed findings</li></ul></li><li>Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li><li>Introduce the Second Order Sub-themes</li><li>Second Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 3<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li></ul></li><li>Second Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)<br /></li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li><li>Third Order Subtheme 1<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature</li></ul></li><li>Third Order Subtheme 2<ul><li>Describe data that typifies the pattern under discussion by GENERALIZING across the sample OR providing 1&ndash;5 INDIVIDUAL example(s)</li><li>Briefly explain how an example represents a larger pattern/sub-theme OPTIONALLY mentioning 1-2 pieces of relevant literature<br /></li></ul></li></ul></li><li>OPTIONAL: Generalize beyond the sample/contextualize the findings<br /></li><li>OPTIONAL: Offer explanation(s) for observed findings<br /></li></ul></li></ul></li><li>OPTIONAL: Summarize the analysis sections / Generalize beyond sample / Offer explanation(s)</li></ul>&nbsp;<br /><strong>Discussion/Discussion and Conclusion</strong><br /><ul><li>Review what you found</li><li>OPTIONAL: Generalize Beyond Sample, by referencing literature (or by reasoning)</li><li>OPTIONAL: Explain your Findings, by referencing literature (or by reasoning)</li><li>State implication(s) of findings</li><li>Explain how themes and/or subthemes, or the implication(s) of the findings, clarify, challenge, or expand exiting knowledge or theory</li><li>OPTIONAL: Identify areas of social life where your argument likely applies<br /></li></ul></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">FULL DOCUMENT</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph" style="text-align:left;">Below, you can download the document where I did this work. You can see how I coded each passage from each of the articles. I have this in the document because it helps me see how people dealt with particular issues, which I will have to reference as I continue to write journal articles.<br /><br />I hope this is helpful for you! Certainly for me, randomly finding that outline from Calarco and thinking through it has been an important part of learning how to write journal articles.<br /></div>  <div><div style="margin: 10px 0 0 -10px"> <a title="Download file: reverse_outlines_main_document.docx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/reverse_outlines_main_document.docx"><img src="//www.weebly.com/weebly/images/file_icons/rtf.png" width="36" height="36" style="float: left; position: relative; left: 0px; top: 0px; margin: 0 15px 15px 0; border: 0;" /></a><div style="float: left; text-align: left; position: relative;"><table style="font-size: 12px; font-family: tahoma; line-height: .9;"><tr><td colspan="2"><b> reverse_outlines_main_document.docx</b></td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Size:  </td><td>305 kb</td></tr><tr style="display: none;"><td>File Type:  </td><td> docx</td></tr></table><a title="Download file: reverse_outlines_main_document.docx" href="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/reverse_outlines_main_document.docx" style="font-weight: bold;">Download File</a></div> </div>  <hr style="clear: both; width: 100%; visibility: hidden"></hr></div>  <div class="wsite-spacer" style="height:50px;"></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Carnal Sociology in Black Hawk Hancock's American Allegory]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/carnal-sociology-with-american-allegory]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/carnal-sociology-with-american-allegory#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Sun, 03 Jul 2022 02:43:41 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/carnal-sociology-with-american-allegory</guid><description><![CDATA[This post includes a review of the book American Allegory by Black Hawk Hancock. I then discuss what the book shows, in my view, for how to write as a sociologist, in line with this blog's theme of how to do various academic tasks.American Allegory is about Lindy Hop and Steppin', which are related dances&mdash;Steppin' grew out of dance traditions that the Lindy Hop started. The Lindy Hop, in particular, is an "American Allegory" because the story of the Lindy Hop (created in the 1920s and 1930 [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a">This post includes a review of the book American Allegory by Black Hawk Hancock. I then discuss what the book shows, in my view, for how to write as a sociologist, in line with this blog's theme of how to do various academic tasks.<br /><br />American Allegory is about Lindy Hop and Steppin', which are related dances&mdash;Steppin' grew out of dance traditions that the Lindy Hop started. The Lindy Hop, in particular, is an "American Allegory" because the story of the Lindy Hop (created in the 1920s and 1930s in Harlem) and its revival in the late 1990s is an example of black creativity and labour that was appropriated by white people who then erased the history of that black creativity and labour. This is allegorical to the American story in more general terms, the book argues, where black labour and creativity is hidden underneath the loudly proclaimed expression and successes of whites (or the general &ldquo;American&rdquo; assumed to be white).<br /><br />In Hancock's words,<br /></font></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph"><font color="#2a2a2a">"What was once an African American cultural practice [the Lindy Hop]&mdash;forged as an alternative expression of identity against the context of overt and explicit white racism, segregation, and exploitation that defined the American landscape at the time [the 1920s and 1930s]&mdash;has now become the tribal call of the privileged white middle class [in the late 1990s and early 2000s]" (p.3).<br />&nbsp;<br />The book is an ethnography, and explicitly applies the method of carnal sociology (e.g., see p.28&ndash;29 for his description of carnal sociology). Using carnal sociology means that the body was both the topic of the study and a tool of inquiry. For Hancock, the "tool of inquiry" part is this: he hadn't danced much before starting to check out the Lindy Hop scene in the late 1990s in Chicago. It then became the topic of his dissertation research (which is the basis of this book), and he tried to become, and succeeded in becoming, a skilled Lindy Hop dancer. So much so that he became a Lindy Hop teacher. But he documents how difficult the process was, training his body to learn how to dance (e.g., Chapter 1 is the description of internalizing the embodied skills of the Lindy Hop). Since it was so difficult, he proposes that dancing in general is learned, not something inborn in any race of people. This is the main "tool of inquiry" finding. Since dancing was so hard to learn at the deep-seated level of his body's reflexes and other bodily knowledge, from this we can understand that dancing is not something that comes naturally to any group of people, specifically black people (and to similarly refute that it doesn&rsquo;t come naturally to others, i.e., white people). Dancing is ingrained through socialization.<br />&nbsp;<br />Hancock shows that it is problematic to say that black people are natural dancers because of the history of how black people have been portrayed. In this he connects his "body as tool of inquiry" finding to the idea of the "racial imagination". The "racial imagination" in the US, Hancock shows, has debased black people by emphasizing bodily prowess while otherwise being highly degrading, and even using the idea of inherent bodily skill to denigrate black people. Throughout the book, Hancock draws on Ralph Ellison to frame his own ideas about the racial imagination, and in this vein of natural dancers and the racial imagination, Hancock quotes Ellison as saying, "The Negro is idealized into a symbol of sensation, of unhampered social and sexual relationships" (p.80). Hancock continues, "In relation to what whites perceive as their own "coldness" and rigidity, African Americans are projected as the excess of sensuality and sexuality&rdquo; (p.81) and "the black body has traditionally been mythologized as innately and essentially exotic, sexual, expressive, and naturally rhythmic; this sense of blackness has been constructed as exterior to whiteness, whereas the white body is marked by its rationality, restraint, and rigidity" (p.81). He doesn't, but Hancock could also cite Norbert Elias here, who traced the long historical process whereby restraint became socially constructed as a marker of "civilization" and the "civilized" person (Norbert Elias, in the book The Civilizing Process).<br />&nbsp;<br />Hancock argues that minstrel shows (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Minstrel_show) were an example of the derogatory portrayal of blackness that was part of emphasizing natural bodily skill. Minstrel shows portrayed black people as stupid, lazy, superstitious, etc.&mdash;every horrible racist idea turned into entertainment. Basically, minstrel shows were an exaggeration of racist stereotypes. Minstrel shows connect with the idea that black people are thought to be natural dancers because these shows were part of constructing black people as primitive, which connects with them being seen as naturally rhythmic (p.81-82). Hancock goes on to show that often, white people who danced Lindy Hop in the late 1990s over-exaggerated the expressiveness of the dance, sometimes with explicit and awful racist stereotypes (p.92), which he describes as examples of minstrelsy. At one dance class exclusively for advanced dancers, a female black instructor castigated the (mostly white) women for holding their butts out too much, thus critiquing their caricature of many black women's physiology. To Hancock in an interview, she later said, "Look at the girls, they&rsquo;re trying to dance with their asses way out, in what they think is the way black people dance! But look, I don&rsquo;t stick it out. I&rsquo;ve got a big bum, but I don&rsquo;t stick it out; it does that on its own. But for some of these girls, it looks so outrageous, so I had to confront them on that." The way white women try to emphasize their physiology to approach their image of blackness too, Hancock argues, is an example of minstrelsy.<br />&nbsp;<br />The Lindy Hop also connects with this portrayal of black people as natural dancers because it is "often viewed as an innate African American knowledge or as some sort of racial essence rather than as an historical urban cultural formation" (p.82). Hancock also shows that many white people in the Lindy Hop world saw black Lindy Hoppers as natural dancers, and often complained about their own lack of natural dancing proficiency on account of their whiteness (e.g., p.97).<br />&nbsp;<br />So in general, it is problematic to portray black people as natural dancers because of the history of racial stereotypes that denigrate black people and construct the superiority of white people. Portraying black people as natural dancers is itself a contribution to that tradition of creating and maintaining racial stereotypes that identify blackness with the unthinking, unrestrained, wild body.<br />&nbsp;<br />So in terms of the "body as tool": it is hard to learn how to dance, it takes a lot of time and effort, so there are no natural dancers. It is problematic to say black people are natural dancers, because of the construction of blackness as unthinking, unrestrained, naturally expressive, etc.<br />&nbsp;<br />The "body as tool" part of the book also has another aspect: since Hancock learned how to dance the Lindy Hop, he was also able to enter the world of Steppin'. This dance, unlike the Lindy Hop, was not appropriated by white people. Hancock entered into the all-black world of Steppin' in Chicago with his partner at the time, another highly skilled, and white, Lindy Hop dancer. They went to Steppin' clubs and people were at first very skeptical, but as soon as they saw them dance, the regular Steppers understood that these two white people just wanted to enjoy dancing. Like Lo&iuml;c Wacquant and boxing (in his book, Body and Soul), Hancock says that he entered the Steppin' world without the intention of studying Steppin&rsquo; in these clubs, but just wanted to go to escape what was becoming a stifling world of Lindy Hop (for Wacquant, he similarly says he started boxing simply to have a location to study life in the South Side of Chicago, which later morphed into a study of boxing). Hancock kept bringing up race in the Lindy Hop world and the mostly white Lindy Hop dancers were constantly rejecting him for this&mdash;he found welcome respite in a world where the black history of the dance was not obscured. Steppin' came into his study as a way to show how having a skill that takes an extremely-long time to develop&mdash;proficiency in swing dancing&mdash;indicates that you belong to a social world, even if you don't fit the usual image of a member of that world. (Lindy Hop and Steppin are forms of swing dancing, Lindy Hop being the original form). People quickly could understand that Hancock and his partner were not cops because they could see that they knew how to and relished Steppin, something that can&rsquo;t be faked. In this Steppin&rsquo; chapter (Chapter 4), Hancock shows that many of the black Steppers were surprised that white people could dance well, which Hancock argues demonstrates that the racial imagination where black people are natural dancers and white people are more restrained and can't dance also manifests here (e.g., p.184). One part I really liked about this chapter was this general observation of how embodied competency indicates membership:<br />&nbsp;<br />"here the body is communicating something more important than a racially marked surface: a competence of cultural practice that cannot be faked. Because embodied knowledge cannot be explicitly articulated, they reveal more than can be controlled consciously" (p.188).<br />&nbsp;<br />So the analysis of Steppin&rsquo; also contributes to the "body as tool" arguments, showing that these abilities that he had gained were understood by the Steppers as so hard to gain that he and his partner couldn't have been cops or people there to make fun of Steppin.<br />&nbsp;<br />So overall the argument is that bodily skills are part of racial domination when they are inculcated without an understanding of the history they grew out of, when people learn how to dance without paying respect to and making sure to honour the racial history of the dance. The racial imagination can also impinge upon a situation, inserting stereotypes such as which race are natural dancers, among both white and black groups.<br />&nbsp;<br />So that's it for the "body as tool" part of this review!<br />&nbsp;<br />Many of the other arguments in the book were in a way based on the "body as tool" method, because it was by being a known and respected member of the Lindy Hop world that he was able to get such detailed and wide-ranging data, interviewing many of the most respected teachers and dancers. But other than that, the other points I will discuss here are mostly about interviews and what Hancock observed as a participant-observer.<br />&nbsp;<br />Conceptually, the rest of the book is still based in the idea of the &ldquo;racial imagination.&rdquo; The book is also explicitly a study of whiteness. This book was researched and written from about 1998 to 2013, a period when explicit white supremacy in the US was not as present as it is as I write this review in 2022. So at the time, Hancock wanted to study racism in its more invisible forms, such as in the cultural appropriation of the Lindy Hop, the minstrelsy in the ways white people danced it, the refusal of white people to talk about race and the Lindy Hop (even to link it to the history of black creativity), etc. He says, &ldquo;a paradigm shift from whiteness conceptualized as white supremacy (agents acting in conscious coalition toward maintaining racial supremacy and racial hierarchy) to whiteness as the invisible, underlying, unspoken, normalized operation of the racial organization of society&rdquo; (p.17) was needed. Indeed, even in the context of the increased explicit white supremacy since about 2014 in the US, there are still many forms of this more invisible kind&mdash;it is just that in 2022 we must say that studying both the explicit and less conscious and less visible forms of white supremacy are needed (and even in 2013, I am sure many activists and scholars, particularly Indigenous activists and scholars, but also others, would likely have still critiqued explicit white supremacy). In any case, the book is helpful as a way to make the invisible forms of racism engrained in the Lindy Hop world, and by extension, other forms of cultural appropriation, visible. I appreciated reflecting, as I read the book ,about my own engagement with cultural forms produced by people from historically marginalized groups, and how I could engage in ways that allowed for better understanding of the histories of these cultural forms and use them only if also critically thinking about my engagement in activism in line with that by these groups. For example, I have increasingly engaged with Indigenous writing, music, and other cultural forms, and have felt somewhat uncomfortable doing that, even when encouraged by some Indigenous peoples in activist spaces to do so. The book helped me clarify my feeling of unease about this and helped me understand cultural appropriation in my case, even while I have also consistently listened to the podcast MediaINDIGENA, and talking about it in an Indigenous studies class, and so already have thought about this to some degree.<br />&nbsp;<br />The conclusion of Hancock&rsquo;s book does not merely summarize the book. It is based on another journal article Hancock wrote, which had the purpose of responding to critics and widening the scope of the arguments he developed in the Lindy Hop and Steppin&rsquo; articles/chapters (most of the chapters of this book were published as journal articles in the 2000s). Hancock takes on a lot in this conclusion. For example, he takes on &ldquo;structural accounts of cultural appropriation,&rdquo; where, &ldquo;the structural model guarantees the qualities and characteristics of a particular group by their very structural position, in that culture becomes what is assigned to an already pre-existing identity&rdquo; (p.207) like whiteness. So structural takes on cultural appropriation would define any participation in Lindy Hop by white people as cultural appropriation, by the mere fact of &ldquo;structural position in society&rdquo; (p.207). This argument against the structural understanding of cultural appropriation could take up probably a book by itself, or maybe a career. Hancock dismisses these structural accounts as being essentialist (p.207), and moves on.<br />&nbsp;<br />He similarly dismisses the &ldquo;commodification account&rdquo; of cultural appropriation, a position he summarizes by saying it is the idea that culture is reduced to consumer goods, and then we can &ldquo;know who we are&rdquo; by knowing &ldquo;what race we are&rdquo; so that then &ldquo;we can tell which culture is ours&rdquo; (p.209). The problem with this, Hancock says, is that it doesn&rsquo;t show in detail the &ldquo;social processes&rdquo; that work to define racial domination and racial categories. Rather than only using the culture (defined as consumable practices and objects) from our own racial and ancestral groups, he sees it as possible to engage with culture from groups other than one&rsquo;s own as long as attention is paid to how one&rsquo;s use of culture may contribute to racial (or other forms of) domination. With proper guidance and historical education, people (even white people) can, Hancock argues, engage with culture from other groups in respectful ways that help in creating cross-cultural appreciation, camaraderie, and understanding.<br />&nbsp;<br />Hancock also goes into a few other definitions of cultural appropriation, such as the &ldquo;autonomous&rdquo; definition, and the colonial definition, and the arguments are similar: people should strive to avoid essentialism and look to the precise processes whereby racial domination is produced in order to critique and avoid them.<br />&nbsp;<br />In the conclusion he also discusses the idea that white people are dominated by their racism. The idea is that white people often do have a great deal of bodily shame for awkward movement, such as in dancing, and not realizing how hard dance is for everyone to learn might make some white people not participate in dance classes, or, in other ways going through the labour to learn to dance, thinking themselves genetically incapable. It seems true to me that this is a way that lack of awareness of the racial imagination, and lack of understanding of the kind of bodily sociology Hancock shows in this book, may indeed be part of white people&rsquo;s own self-domination.<br />&nbsp;<br />Hancock then goes on, in the conclusion, to critique the ideas of &ldquo;race traitor&rdquo; and &ldquo;neo-abolitionist&rdquo;, showing that &ldquo;In both cases, identification [with either term] ends up being a white fantasy&rdquo; and that &ldquo;there is no clear way to separate the race traitor or neo-abolitionist from the cultural appropriator&rdquo; (p.218). In general, Hancock is constantly looking to ways to define white identity in non-essentialist and non-performative ways, and here he finds the terms lacking.<br />&nbsp;<br />To finally conclude the book, Hancock returns to Ralph Ellison. As I discussed above, Ellison&rsquo;s ideas are included throughout the book, bringing a dimension of polyvocality to the narrative, to decenter Hancock&rsquo;s whiteness a bit (or, so seems to be the purpose, from what I can tell).<br />&nbsp;<br />So what to do about all the problems raised in the book? Hancock answers dispositionally, in terms of sociology that takes the body seriously. That is, people must not merely think differently. They must engage in different practices: &ldquo;Since the racial order is inscribed in our bodily dispositions, we must also [in addition to consciousness raising] undertake a countertraining of the schemata of perception and appreciation of the social world in order to break with the dominant racial order&rdquo; (p.223). Which basically means that we must not only think differently, but act differently, build new types of practices that develop different bodily skills that allow for better cross-racial understanding and respectful cultural engagement. If people only engage with culture from their own ancestral groups, Hancock argues that they will only have a stereotyped view of the cultural practices of other groups, and will probably not have as positive of an experience with that culture than with one&rsquo;s own well-known and appreciated culture. He says yes, people, especially white people, have to be careful not to appropriate, engaging with the culture of black, Indigenous, or people of colour in respectful ways, conscious of the history of the cultural forms and taking explicit political actions in support of these groups&rsquo; political objectives. He emphasizes that there is value in deeply engaging with culture from groups other than one&rsquo;s own for cross-cultural appreciation and understanding (p.224&ndash;225).<br />&nbsp;<br />He concludes emphasizing the importance of studying the processes that form identities and racial categories, such as those processes he studied in the Lindy Hop and Steppin&rsquo; worlds.<br />&nbsp;<br />- - - - -<br />&nbsp;<br />Methods<br />&nbsp;<br />In terms of what this book demonstrates for how to do a carnal sociology, first of all, the book includes a discussion of Wacquant's work on carnal sociology, to define the field and demonstrate what the aim of carnal sociology is. Citing with, and describing the concepts, from Wacquant's work, is thus one of the important tasks for someone doing this kind of sociology (at least, when using the term "carnal sociology"&mdash;many scholars and activists do talk about "embodiment" without citing Wacquant, such as adrienne maree brown). The general idea of habitus or embodiment as both "topic and tool" is probably required in such studies.<br />&nbsp;<br />Second, the book "extends" (p.30) carnal sociology into the area of "ethnoracial domination" (p.30). So to contribute to sociology with carnal sociology, it is not necessary to change the theory of carnal sociology. As is the case with many sociological contributions, and "extension" is often enough. Nobody had talked about carnal sociology in the context of embodying this kind of skill, and bringing this way of thinking to racial domination changes how we think about it. This is the same kind of contribution that Matthew Desmond made in On the Fireline, although in his case he extends the idea of habitus formation into the theory of risk, and in so doing changes how sociologists think about risk.<br />&nbsp;<br />Third, the book demonstrates that a series of journal articles can later be published as a book. This is also the case with books such as Kimberley Kay Hoang's book Dealing in Desire and Lo&iuml;c Wacquant's book Body and Soul. Hancock's main chapters of this book, including the conclusion, were first published as journal articles. It can be a successful strategy: one gains a name for themselves, as an early-career sociologist, through a series of journal articles, and solidifies this name by writing a book that extends and waves together these articles.<br />&nbsp;<br />This book is also an example of a case where the researcher comes into a conflictual relationship with most of their respondents. Many of the white Lindy Hoppers discussed in the book were critiqued, even if Hancock does take pains to keep emphasizing that he wants to get away from the "logic of the trial" and simply talk about how racial imagination and other structures of race flow and are reproduced via various processes. The stubborn insistence of white erasure, white stereotyping of black people, and the neglect of a critical approach to race among many of the white respondents/participants in the study still did lead Hancock to sometimes critique them. I'm sure many would be interested to take his critiques into account, but others might not. It brings up this important issue of how one relates to their research participants, but in any case, often sociologists will end up critiquing them to some degree. This is also the case in Desmond's On the Fireline, where he very deeply critiques how the US Forest Service sets up a set of safety rules for wildland firefighting that are necessarily broken in every fire, so that they can blame anyone who dies for not following the rules. Sometimes ethnographers, and other sociologists, enter into conflictual relationships with those they research. It is a lesson of this book, and an important part of understanding ethnographic methods.<br />&nbsp;<br />The use of Ellison's work throughout the book was an interesting decision, from this general strandpoint of thinking about academic methods. When reading, it did seem like one way of bringing a powerful black intellectual voice into what could otherwise be a monologic white narrative. I think it is one approach to creating more polyvocality, especially in books written by white people about black, Indigenous, or people of colour. Choosing one author of course opens one to the critique that the particular author chosen wasn't necessarily the best single representative&mdash;with Hancock and Ellison, we still have a discussion centered around the voices of two men, for example. I know that sometimes Ellison has been critiqued, for example by Toni Morrison, on the grounds of often orienting his thoughts toward&nbsp; a white audience (e.g., "invisible man" to whom? White people. I saw that critique in "The Pieces that I Am", a documentary about Toni Morrison and her work). So it is an interesting approach to decenter one's own positionality a bit by interweaving a powerful intellectual voice from the group one is studying. It is certainly a methodological point worthy of discussion.<br />&nbsp;<br />I'll end my discussion there! In any case, the book gives one much to think about.<br />&nbsp;<br />- - - -<br />&nbsp;<br />This book review, minus the part about academic methods, was posted on Goodreads (https://www.goodreads.com/user/show/4228286-tyler).<br />&nbsp;<br /></font></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Academic Methods Bibliography]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/academic-methods-bibliography]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/academic-methods-bibliography#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Sun, 29 May 2022 03:00:47 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/academic-methods-bibliography</guid><description><![CDATA[Often in my university career, I have found that knowing how to do something is what I really needed to learn. Once I figured this out, I started doing much better in my university classes.Here, I provide a set of resources that I hope will help students, authors, and academics to do their work in better ways.Some of the resources are more specific to sociology, but I try in each category to also have many that are general.Please let me know if you read this list and think a source should be add [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">Often in my university career, I have found that knowing how to do something is what I really needed to learn. Once I figured this out, I started doing much better in my university classes.<br /><br />Here, I provide a set of resources that I hope will help students, authors, and academics to do their work in better ways.<br /><br />Some of the resources are more specific to sociology, but I try in each category to also have many that are general.<br /><br />Please let me know if you read this list and think a source should be added. It is an evolving list, and I don't pretend to have an exhaustive bibliography here!<br /><br />These references are biased toward European writers. I've made it a project to correct that over time.<br /></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Epistemology</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">What are you doing when you write, anyway? I've often struggled with understanding the role of writing, and trying to understand how different theorists understand their acts of writing within their theories. This is my working bibliography of discussions about that issue, and in general about the issue of what it means to write as someone attempting to build "knowledge" (if we even want to make a claim that building knowledge is what we're doing).<br /><br />Abbott, Andrew Delano. 2001. Chaos of Disciplines. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Chalmers, Alan F. 1982. What Is This Thing Called Science? St. Lucia, Australia: University of Queensland Press.<br /><br />Devlin, William J., and Alisa Bokulich, eds. 2015. Kuhn&rsquo;s Structure of Scientific Revolutions - 50 Years On. Vol. 311. Cham: Springer International Publishing.<br /><br />Feyerabend, Paul. 1993. Against Method. 3rd ed. London, UK and New York: Verso.<br /><br />Fuller, Steve. 1988. Social Epistemology. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.<br /><br />Goldman, Alvin I. 1999. Knowledge in a Social World. Oxford, UK and New York: Clarendon Press ; Oxford University Press.<br /><br />Goldman, Alvin I., and Dennis Whitcomb, eds. 2011. Social Epistemology: Essential Readings. Oxford, UK and New York: Oxford University Press.<br /><br />Greco, John, and Ernest Sosa, eds. 1999. The Blackwell Guide to Epistemology. Malden, MA: Blackwell.<br /><br />Haddock, Adrian, Alan Millar, and Duncan Pritchard, eds. 2010. Social Epistemology. Oxford, UK and New York: Oxford University Press.<br /><br />Kuhn, Thomas S. 1996. The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. 3rd ed. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Popper, Karl R. 2002. The Logic of Scientific Discovery. London, UK and New York: Routledge.<br /><br />Rawls, Anne Warfield. 2004. Epistemology and Practice: Durkheim&rsquo;s The Elementary Forms of Religious Life. Cambridge, UK and New York: Cambridge University Press.<br /><br />TallBear, Kimberly. 2013. &ldquo;Introduction.&rdquo; Pp. 1&ndash;29 in Native American DNA: tribal belonging and the false promise of genetic science. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.<ul><li>Discusses feminist and social epistemology, esp. that of Donna Harraway.<br /></li></ul></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Graduate School and Jobs after Graduate School</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Calarco, Jessica McCrory. 2020. A Field Guide to Grad School: Uncovering the Hidden Curriculum. Princeton, New Jersey: Princeton University Press.<br /><br />Frank, Frederick, and Karl Stein. 2004. Playing the Game: The Streetsmart Guide to Graduate School. Lincoln, NE: iUniverse.<ul><li>This book is annoying and offensive in a lot of ways, but it is sometimes good for a laugh. It also taught me a lot of the basics of what graduate school was when I had no idea. The author names are pseudonyms (the citation is "Frank and Stein" ...).<br /></li></ul><br />Kelsky, Karen. 2015. The Professor Is in: The Essential Guide to Turning Your Ph.D into a Job. New York: Penguin Random House.<ul><li>I really appreciate this book for its discussion of many issues important for graduate students that are usually not explicitly discussed (e.g., how negotiations of academic job offers work).<br /></li></ul><br />Peters, Robert L. 1997. Getting What You Came for: The Smart Student&rsquo;s Guide to Earning a Master&rsquo;s or a Ph.D. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.<ul><li>This is the main book that prepared me for the PhD. Written by a white conservation biologist, so perhaps that is part of why I identified with it, since I was that at the time, so I can't fully speak on whether it would be appreciated by everyone. But I think beyond any positionality it provides a lot of great information. I don't agree with everything he says, e.g., that you should think of your fellow graduate students as your "competitors", but there is still a lot of good information here. (Yes you're technically in competitions for jobs, but that shouldn't be the main way we frame our colleagues!).<br /></li></ul></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Power and Knowledge Production</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">This kind of discussion is often called "research ethics". I personally prefer "Power and Knowledge Production", because "power" helps me see links between everything under "ethics". It also sometimes seems like we do "research ethics" to get our research "approved", and that's not why I read about power and knowledge production. I read about this topic because I want to carefully think about the power I have when I do research, the power my research and that of my colleagues has, and the many other issues that can be thought of in research that involve power. I want to keep improving my understanding of the implications of my research (and research that I read about) for power&mdash;both in terms of the relations of power implicitly included in the research and in the relations of power that could be altered as a result of research. For example, if my research is aiming to ultimately change something about power relations but doesn't actually threaten current power arrangements, that is something to think about (with the help of sources like those listed here) and take action on.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Power and Knowledge Production: Research and Indigenous Peoples</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">I learned about most of these resources when taking a graduate class with Robin Gray at the University of Toronto called, "Research and Indigenous Peoples". Personally, these sources helped me figure out if I should try to do research that directly involves Indigenous peoples and how I should go about it, if in a given situation I decide that research with Indigenous peoples is something I should do. But these sources go far beyond whether a white settler in Canada should do such research, and none of them are directly about that.<br /><br />Brayboy, Bryan McKinley Jones. 2005. &ldquo;Toward a Tribal Critical Race Theory in Education.&rdquo; The Urban Review 37(5):425&ndash;46. doi: 10.1007/s11256-005-0018-y.<br /><br />Christen, Kimberly, and Jane Anderson. 2019. &ldquo;Toward Slow Archives.&rdquo; Archival Science 19(2):87&ndash;116. doi: 10.1007/s10502-019-09307-x.<br /><br />Cole. 2004. &ldquo;Trick(Ster)s of Aboriginal Research.&rdquo; Native Studies Review 15(2):7&ndash;30.<br />Garrison, Nanibaa&rsquo; A. 2013. &ldquo;Genomic Justice for Native Americans: Impact of the Havasupai Case on Genetic Research.&rdquo; Science, Technology, &amp; Human Values 38(2):201&ndash;23. doi: 10.1177/0162243912470009.<br /><br />Hennessy, Kate, Natasha Lyons, Stephen Loring, Charles Arnold, Mervin Joe, and James Pokiak. 2013. &ldquo;The Inuvialuit Living History Project: Digital Return as the Forging of Relationships Between Institutions, People, and Data.&rdquo; Museum Anthropology Review 7(1&ndash;2):44&ndash;73.<br /><br />Mihesuah, Devon A., ed. 1998. Natives and Academics: Researching and Writing about American Indians. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press.<br /><br />Moreton-Robinson, Aileen. 2006. &ldquo;Towards a New Research Agenda?: Foucault, Whiteness and Indigenous Sovereignty.&rdquo; Journal of Sociology 42(4):383&ndash;95. doi: 10.1177/1440783306069995.<br /><br />Nakata, Martin. 1998. &ldquo;Anthropological Texts and Indigenous Standpoints.&rdquo; Australian Aboriginal Studies 2:8.<br /><br />Nakata, Martin. 2007. &ldquo;The Cultural Interface.&rdquo; The Australian Journal of Indigenous Education 36(S1):7&ndash;14. doi: 10.1017/S1326011100004646.<br /><br />Newsom, Bonnie, Penobscot Nation Intellectual Property Working Group, Julie Woods, and H. Martin Wobst. 2014. Developing Policies and Protocols for the Culturally Sensitive Intellectual Properties of the Penobscot Nation of Maine: Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage (IPinCH). Amherst, MA: Penobscot Nation, University of Massachusetts Amherst, and Intellectual Property Issues in Cultural Heritage.<br /><br />O&rsquo;Brien, Jean M. 2017. &ldquo;Historical Sources and Methods in Indigenous Studies: Touching on the Past, Looking to the Future.&rdquo; Pp. 15&ndash;22 in Sources and Methods in Indigenous Studies. New York: Routledge.<br />Smith, Linda Tuhiwai. 2012. [1999] Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples. 2nd Edition. London, UK and New York: Zed Books.<br /><br />Sunseri, Lina. 2007. &ldquo;Indigenous Voice Matters: Claiming Our Space through Decolonising Research.&rdquo; Junctures 9:93&ndash;106.<br /><br />TallBear, Kimberly. 2013. Native American DNA: Tribal Belonging and the False Promise of Genetic Science. Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press.<br />* This book discusses many issues about power in research that involves Indigenous peoples. The overall point of the book is to argue that research involving Indigenous peoples' DNA is often portrayed by media and scientists as devoid of power and politics. TallBear demonstrates that, actually, power and politics are deeply interwoven with public and scholarly discussions of Native American DNA. Beyond that main point of the book, the introduction also discusses many other issues in the area of Research and Indigenous Peoples, including a discussion of participatory action research, decolonizing methodologies, and the general topic of the politics of knowledge production.<br /><br />TallBear, Kim. 2014. &ldquo;Standing With and Speaking as Faith: A Feminist-Indigenous Approach to Inquiry.&rdquo; Journal of Research Practice 10(2):1&ndash;7.<br /><br />Tuck, Eve. 2009. &ldquo;Suspending Damage: A Letter to Communities.&rdquo; Harvard Educational Review 79(3):409&ndash;28. doi: 10.17763/haer.79.3.n0016675661t3n15.<br /><br />Wilson, Shawn. 2008. Research Is Ceremony: Indigenous Research Methods. Halifax, NS and Winnipeg, MB: Fernwood Publishing.<br /><br />Younging, Gregory. 2018. Elements of Indigenous Style: A Guide for Writing by and about Indigenous Peoples. Edmonton, AB: Brush Education.<br /><br />Younging, Greg. 2010. &ldquo;Gnaritas Nullius (No One&rsquo;s Knowledge): The Public Domain and Colonization of Traditional Knowledge.&rdquo; World Intellectual Property Organization. (This article was also printed in his book, Elements of Indigenous Style).<br /><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Presentations (e.g., Conference presentations)</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">See Talks.</div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Project Management</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Abbott, Andrew. 2014. Digital Paper: A Manual for Research and Writing with Library and Internet Materials. Chicago, IL, USA and London, UK: University of Chicago Press.<ul><li>I use the principles from this book daily. I appreciate the distinction, for exmaple, between puzzles and research questions. It is explicitly only for what he calls "library research", i.e., research involving the kind of material you could find at a library (so, not research where you collect your own survey data, interview data, participant observation data, etc.). But the ideas are still clearly also relevant for research when you collect your own data.</li></ul><br />Huff, Anne Sigismund. 2009. Designing Research for Publication. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Marshall, Catherine, and Gretchen B. Rossman. 2011. Designing Qualitative Research. 5th ed. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Prasad, Monica. 2021. Problem Solving Sociology. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.<ul><li>I greatly appreciate this book, and use principles from it daily.</li></ul><br />Walliman, Nicholas, and Bousmaha Baiche. 2001. Your Research Project: A Step-by-Step Guide for the First-Time Researcher. London ; Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Qualitative Methods</font><br /></h2>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Ethnography</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Becker, Howard S., and Blanche Geer. 1957. &ldquo;Participant Observation and Interviewing: A Comparison.&rdquo; Hunan Organization 16(3):28&ndash;32.<br /><br />Behar, Ruth. 1996a. &ldquo;Anthropology That Breaks Your Heart.&rdquo; Pp. 161&ndash;77 in The Vulnerable Observer: Anthropology that Breaks your Heart. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.<br /><br />Behar, Ruth. 1996b. &ldquo;The Vulnerable Observer.&rdquo; Pp. 1&ndash;33 in The Vulnerable Observer: Anthropology that Breaks your Heart. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.<br /><br />Bucerius, Sandra. 2013. &ldquo;Becoming a Trusted &lsquo;Outsider&rsquo;: Gender, Ethnicity, and Inequality in Ethnographic Research.&rdquo; Journal of Contemporary Ethnography 42(6):690&ndash;721.<br /><br />Carpiano, Richard M. 2009. &ldquo;Come Take a Walk with Me: The &lsquo;Go-Along&rsquo; Interview as a Novel Method for Studying the Implications of Place for Health and Well-Being.&rdquo; Health &amp; Place 15(1):263&ndash;72. doi: 10.1016/j.healthplace.2008.05.003.<br /><br />Contreras, Randol. 2015. &ldquo;Standpoint Purgatorio.&rdquo; Pp. 249&ndash;65 in Violence at the Urban Margins, edited by J. Auyero, P. Bourgois, and N. Scheper-Hughes. Oxford, UK and New York: Oxford University Press.<br /><br />Contreras, Randol. 2017. &ldquo;Recalling to Life: Understanding Stickup Kids through Insider Qualitative Research.&rdquo; Pp. 155&ndash;68 in Qualitative Research in Criminology. Malden, MA, and Abingdon, UK: Routledge.<br /><br />Emerson, Robert M., Rachel I. Fretz, and Linda L. Shaw. 2011. Writing Ethnographic Fieldnotes. 2nd Edition. Chicago, IL and London, UK: Chicago University Press.<br /><br />Geertz, Clifford. 1973a. &ldquo;Deep Play: Notes on the Balinese Cockfight.&rdquo; Pp. 435&ndash;74 in The Interpretations of Culture: Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books.<br /><br />Geertz, Clifford. 1973b. &ldquo;Thick Description: Toward an Interpretive Theory of Culture.&rdquo; Pp. 3&ndash;36 in The Interpretation of Cultures: Selected Essays. New York: Basic Books.<br /><br />Jerolmack, Colin, and Shamus Khan. 2014a. &ldquo;Talk Is Cheap: Ethnography and the Attitudinal Fallacy.&rdquo; Sociological Methods &amp; Research 43(2):178&ndash;209. doi: 10.1177/0049124114523396.<br /><br />Jerolmack, Colin, and Shamus Khan. 2014b. &ldquo;Toward an Understanding of the Relationship Between Accounts and Action.&rdquo; Sociological Methods &amp; Research 43(2):236&ndash;47. doi: 10.1177/0049124114523397.<br /><br />Katz, Jack. 1997. &ldquo;Ethnography&rsquo;s Warrants.&rdquo; Sociological Methods &amp; Research 25(4):391&ndash;423.<br /><br />Kusenbach, Margarethe. 2003. &ldquo;Street Phenomenology: The Go-along as Ethnographic Research Tool.&rdquo; Ethnography 4(3):455&ndash;85.<br /><br />Neto, Pedro Figueiredo. 2019. &ldquo;Surreptitious Ethnography: Following the Paths of Angolan Refugees and Returnees in the Angola-Zambia Borderlands.&rdquo; Ethnography 20(1):128&ndash;45. doi: 10.1177/1466138117724577.<br /><br />Okely, Judith. 2007. &ldquo;Fieldwork Embodied.&rdquo; Sociological Review 55(1):65&ndash;79.<br /><br />Stacey, Judith. 1988. &ldquo;Can There Be a Feminist Ethnography?&rdquo; Women&rsquo;s Studies International Forum 11(1):21&ndash;27.<br /><br />Thorne, Barrie. 1980. &ldquo;&lsquo;You Still Takin&rsquo; Notes?&rsquo; Fieldwork and Problems of Informed Consent.&rdquo; Social Problems 27(3):284&ndash;97.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Interviewing</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Some of the debates that have happened about interviewing, and also some of the best books for figuring out how to do it.<br /><br />Brinkmann, Svend, and Steinar Kvale. [2009] 2015. InterViews: Learning the Craft of Qualitative Research Interviewing. Third Edit. Thousand Oaks, CA, USA and London, UK: Sage Publications. [Has over 14,500 citations on Google Scholar].<br /><br />DiCicco-Bloom, Barbara, and Benjamin F. Crabtree. 2006. &ldquo;The Qualitative Research Interview.&rdquo; Medical Education 40(4):314&ndash;21. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2929.2006.02418.x. [Has over 6,000 citations on Google Scholar]<br /><br />Gerson, Kathleen, and Sarah Damaske. 2021. The Science and Art of Interviewing. New York, NY, USA and Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press.<br /><br />Holstein, James, and Jaber Gubrium. 2003. Inside Interviewing. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks California 91320 United States of America: SAGE Publications, Inc. [Over 850 citations on Google Scholar]<br /><br />Hughes, Jason, Kahryn Hughes, Grace Sykes, and Katy Wright. 2020. &ldquo;Beyond Performative Talk: Critical Observations on the Radical Critique of Reading Interview Data.&rdquo; International Journal of Social Research Methodology 23(5):547&ndash;63. doi: 10.1080/13645579.2020.1766757.<br /><br />Lamont, Mich&egrave;le, and Ann Swidler. 2014. &ldquo;Methodological Pluralism and the Possibilities and Limits of Interviewing.&rdquo; Qualitative Sociology 37(2):153&ndash;71. doi: 10.1007/s11133-014-9274-z. [Over 470 citations on Google Scholar]<br /><br />Lareau, Annette. 2021. Listening to People: A Practical Guide to Interviewing, Participant Observation, Data Analysis, and Writing It All Up. Chicago ; London: The University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Martin, John Levi. 2010. &ldquo;Life&rsquo;s a Beach but You&rsquo;re an Ant, and Other Unwelcome News for the Sociology of Culture.&rdquo; Poetics 38(2):229&ndash;44. doi: 10.1016/j.poetic.2009.11.004. [Has over 140 citations on Google Scholar. From what I've seen, most people don't agree with this article, but some people do hold these views].<br /><br />Pugh, Allison J. 2013. &ldquo;What Good Are Interviews for Thinking about Culture? Demystifying Interpretive Analysis.&rdquo; American Journal of Cultural Sociology 1(1):42&ndash;68. doi: 10.1057/ajcs.2012.4.<br /><br />Seidman, Irving. 2006. Interviewing as Qualitative Research: A Guide for Researchers in Education and the Social Sciences. 3rd ed. New York: Teachers College Press. [Has over 28,000 citations on Google Scholar]<br /><br />Tavory, Iddo. 2020. &ldquo;Interviews and Inference: Making Sense of Interview Data in Qualitative Research.&rdquo; Qualitative Sociology 43(4):449&ndash;65. doi: 10.1007/s11133-020-09464-x.<br /><br />Vaisey, Stephen. 2014. &ldquo;Is Interviewing Compatible with the Dual-Process Model of Culture?&rdquo; American Journal of Cultural Sociology 2(1):150&ndash;58. doi: 10.1057/ajcs.2013.8. [Has over 70 citations on Google Scholar]<br /><br />Weiss, Robert S. [1994] 1995. Learning from Strangers: The Art and Method of Qualitative Interview Studies. New York: The Free Press. [Has over 8,000 citations on Google Scholar]</div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Reading</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Abbott, Andrew. 2014. Digital Paper: A Manual for Research and Writing with Library and Internet Materials. Chicago, IL, USA and London, UK: University of Chicago Press.<ul><li>He talks about different kinds of reading, and the kind of reading environment that is ideal. For example, he talks about "meditative" reading, as reading that you do in depth, spending several minutes on each page. He also talks about "browsing" and "scanning" as other methods.<br /></li></ul><br />Adler, Mortimer J., and Charles Van Doren. 1972. How to Read a Book. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.<ul><li>This book is a bit antiquated, but still helped me start thinking about the methods behind reading when I was an undergraduate student.<br /></li></ul></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Software</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Goodnotes<ul><li>This is a great app for taking notes on an iPad (with an Apple Pencil), in my view.<br /></li></ul><br />Omnigraffle. <ul><li>This is a vector-graphic creation and mind-mapping program for Mac. The analogue on PC is Microsoft Visio. I use it often to create figures for journal articles and talks and to map ideas. When I use figures from it in conference presentations, they often receive compliments!<br /></li></ul><br />Ora (for task management) (https://ora.pm). <ul><li>This app allows you to track time and plan various projects. The free version is basically complete. I use it daily to track my work time.<br /></li></ul>PDF Expert<ul><li>You can make map notes (see my other blog post about that) on this, just as you can on Goodnotes. I use an iPad Pro and an Apple Pencil to do so.<br /></li><li>I also use this for PDF reading. It is, in my view, the most effective PDF reading app, on both Mac and iPad.<br /></li></ul><br />Zotero/Mendeley. <ul><li>I use Zotero. I highly recommend university students use one or the other. The main benefit is that you only have to enter the information for a reference once. If you're able to pay for the program, it also means that you can store all of your documents in it. The main benefit of that is you can make folders within the program for various projects, and then you don't have to duplicate the texts when you use them in different projects. The programs allow you to put a single file in many different folders, unlike a typical computer file management system. So it saves space on your hard drive.<br /></li></ul><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Talks</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Anholt, Robert Rene Henri. 2006. Dazzle &rsquo;em with Style: The Art of Oral Scientific Presentation. 2nd ed. Philadelphia, PA: Elsevier Academic Press.<ul><li>He's a biologist, but many general principles can be gleaned from the book if you're a social scientist.</li></ul><br />Asher, Joey. 2001. Even a Geek Can Speak: Low-Tech Communications Skills for a High-Tech World. Atlanta, GA: Persuasive Speaker Press.<br /><br />Donovan, Jeremey. 2012. How to Deliver a TED Talk: Secrets of the World&rsquo;s Most Inspiring Presentations. North Charleston, SC: CreateSpace.<br /><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Teaching</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Many of these resources were introduced to me by Kathy Liddle at the University of Toronto.<br /><br />Adams, Catherine, and Ellen Rose. 2014. &ldquo;Will I Ever Connect with the Students?&rdquo; Online Teaching and the Pedagogy of Care.&rdquo; Phenomenology &amp; Practice 8(1):5&ndash;16. doi: 10.29173/pandpr20637.<br /><br />Atkinson, Maxine P., and Kathleen S. Lowney. 2016. In the Trenches: Teaching and Learning Sociology. First edition. New York: W.W. Norton &amp; Company.<br /><br />Bain, Ken. 2004. What the Best College Teachers Do. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.<br /><br />Barkley, Elizabeth F. 2009. Student Engagement Techniques: A Handbook for College Faculty. San Francisco, CA, USA: Jossey-Bass.<br /><br />Barkley, Elizabeth F., and Claire Howell Major. 2018. Interactive Lecturing: A Handbook for College Faculty. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass, a Wiley Brand.<br /><br />Berg, Maggie, and Barbara K. Seeber. 2016. The Slow Professor: Challenging the Culture of Speed in the Academy. University of Toronto Press.<br /><br />Brown, Peter C., Henry L. Roediger, and Mark A. McDaniel. 2014. Make It Stick: The Science of Successful Learning. Cambridge, MA, USA and London, UK: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.<br /><br />Carey, Benedict. 2014. How We Learn: The Surprising Truth about When, Where, and Why It Happens. First edition. New York: Random House.<br /><br />Cavanagh, Sarah Rose. 2016. The Spark of Learning: Energizing the College Classroom with the Science of Emotion. First edition. Morgantown, West Virginia: West Virginia University Press.<br /><br />Ciabattari, Teresa, Kathleen S. Lowney, Renee A. Monson, Mary Scheuer Senter, and Jeffrey Chin. 2018. &ldquo;Linking Sociology Majors to Labor Market Success.&rdquo; Teaching Sociology 46(3):191&ndash;207. doi: 10.1177/0092055X18760691.<br /><br />Clever, Molly, and Karen S. Miller. 2019. &ldquo;&lsquo;I Understand What They&rsquo;re Going through&rsquo;: How Socioeconomic Background Shapes the Student Service-Learning Experience.&rdquo; Teaching Sociology 47(3):204&ndash;18. doi: 10.1177/0092055X19832646.<br /><br />Davis, Barbara Gross. 2009. Tools for Teaching. 2nd ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.<br /><br />Freire, Paulo. 2000. Pedagogy of the Oppressed. 30th anniversary ed. New York: Continuum.<br /><br />Gannon, Kevin M. 2020. Radical Hope: A Teaching Manifesto. Morgantown: West Virginia University Press.<br /><br />Harrington, Christine, and Todd Zakrajsek. 2017. Dynamic Lecturing: Research-Based Strategies to Enhance Lecture Effectiveness. First edition. Sterling, Virginia: Stylus Publishing.<br /><br />Herman, Jennifer H., and Linda Burzotta Nilson, eds. 2018. Creating Engaging Discussions: Strategies for &ldquo;Avoiding Crickets&rdquo; in Any Size Classroom and Online. Sterling, Virginia: Stylus Publishing, LLC.<br /><br />hooks, bell. 1994. Teaching to Transgress: Education as the Practice of Freedom. New York: Routledge.<br /><br />hooks, bell. 2003. Teaching Community: A Pedagogy of Hope. New York, NY, USA and Abington, UK: Routledge.<br /><br />Joseph, Cheryl. 2017. You&rsquo;re Hired!: Putting Your Sociology Major to Work. Emerald Publishing Limited.<br /><br />Kaufman, Peter, and Janine Schipper. 2018. Teaching with Compassion: An Educator&rsquo;s Oath to Teach from the Heart. Lanham: Rowman &amp; Littlefield Publishing Group, Inc.<br /><br />Lambert, Stephen E. 2009. Great Jobs for Sociology Majors. 3rd ed. New York: McGraw-Hill.<br /><br />Lore, Nicholas, and Anthony Spadafore. 2008. Now What? The Young Person&rsquo;s Guide to Choosing the Perfect Career. New York: Fireside.<br /><br />Mannon, Susan E., and Eileen K. Camfield. 2019. &ldquo;Sociology Students as Storytellers: What Narrative Sociology and C. Wright Mills Can Teach Us about Writing in the Discipline.&rdquo; Teaching Sociology 47(3):177&ndash;90. doi: 10.1177/0092055X19828802.<br /><br />Nilson, Linda B. 2010. Teaching at Its Best: A Research-Based Resource for College Instructors. San Francisco, CA, USA: Jossey-Bass.<br />Palmer, Parker J. 2007. The Courage to Teach: Exploring the Inner Landscape of a Teacher&rsquo;s Life. 10th anniversary ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.<br /><br />Pike, Diane L., Teresa Ciabattari, Melinda Messineo, Renee A. Monson, Rifat A. Salam, Theodore C. Wagenaar, Jeffrey Chin, Susan J. Ferguson, Margaret Weigers Vitullo, Patrick Archer, Maxine P. Atkinson, Jeanne H. Ballantine, Thomas C. Calhoun, Paula England, Rebecca J. Erickson, Andrea N. Hunt, Kathleen S. Lowney, Suzanne B. Maurer, Mary S. Senter, and Stephen Sweet. 2017. The Sociology Major in the Changing Landscape of Higher Education: Curriculum, Careers, and Online Learning. Washington, D.C.: American Sociological Association.<br /><br />Roberts, Keith A. 1993. &ldquo;Toward a Sociology of Writing.&rdquo; Teaching Sociology 21(4):317. doi: 10.2307/1319080.<br /><br />Schwartz, Harriet L. 2019. Connected Teaching: Relationship, Power, and Mattering in Higher Education. First edition. Sterling, Virginia: Stylus Publishing, LLC.<br /><br />Sousa, David A., ed. 2010. Mind, Brain, and Education: Neuroscience Implications for the Classroom. Bloomington, IN: Solution Tree Press.<br /><br />Whynacht, Ardath, Emily Arsenault, and Rachael Cooney. n.d. &ldquo;Abolitionist Pedagogy in the Neoliberal University: Notes on Trauma-Informed Practice, Collaboration, and Confronting the Impossible.&rdquo; 23.<br /><br />Willingham, Daniel T. 2009. Why Don&rsquo;t Students like School? A Cognitive Scientist Answers Questions about How the Mind Works and What It Means for the Classroom. 1st ed. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Theory and Data</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Different methods for relating theory to data.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Abductive Analysis</font></h2>  <div class="paragraph"><strong>Abductive Analysis</strong><br /><br />Tavory, Iddo, and Stefan Timmermans. 2014. Abductive Analysis: Theorizing Qualitative Research. Chicago, IL, USA and London, UK: Chicago University Press.<br /><br />Timmermans, Stefan, and Iddo Tavory. 2012. &ldquo;Theory Construction in Qualitative Research: From Grounded Theory to Abductive Analysis.&rdquo; Sociological Theory 30(3):167&ndash;86. doi: 10.1177/0735275112457914.<br /><br /><strong>Extended Case Method</strong><br /><br />Burawoy, Michael. 1998. &ldquo;The Extended Case Method.&rdquo; Sociological Theory 16(1):4&ndash;33.<br /><br /><strong>Grounded Theory</strong><br /><br />Charmaz, Kathy. 2006. Constructing Grounded Theory. London ; Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Clarke, Adele E. 2005. Situational Analysis: Grounded Theory after the Postmodern Turn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Corbin, Juliet, and Anselm Strauss. 2008. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Glaser, Barney G., and Anselm L. Strauss. 2009. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. New Brunswick: Aldine.<br /><br />Strauss, Anselm L. 1987. Qualitative Analysis for Social Scientists. Cambridge, UK and New York: Cambridge University Press.<br /><br />Strauss, Anselm L., and Juliet M. Corbin. 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Extended Case Method</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Burawoy, Michael. 1998. &ldquo;The Extended Case Method.&rdquo; Sociological Theory 16(1):4&ndash;33.</div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font size="3" color="#2a2a2a">Grounded Theory</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Charmaz, Kathy. 2006. Constructing Grounded Theory. London ; Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Clarke, Adele E. 2005. Situational Analysis: Grounded Theory after the Postmodern Turn. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Corbin, Juliet, and Anselm Strauss. 2008. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2455 Teller Road, Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Glaser, Barney G., and Anselm L. Strauss. 2009. The Discovery of Grounded Theory: Strategies for Qualitative Research. New Brunswick: Aldine.<br /><br />Strauss, Anselm L. 1987. Qualitative Analysis for Social Scientists. Cambridge, UK and New York: Cambridge University Press.<br /><br />Strauss, Anselm L., and Juliet M. Corbin. 1998. Basics of Qualitative Research: Techniques and Procedures for Developing Grounded Theory. 2nd ed. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Theoretical Methods</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Methods for designing social theories.<br /><br />Becker, Howard S. 1998. Tricks of the Trade: How to Think About Your Research While You&rsquo;re Doing It. Chicago, IL, USA and London, UK: The University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Martin, John Levi. 2015. Thinking through Theory. New York: W.W. Norton &amp; Company, Inc.<br /><br />Ragin, Charles C. 2008. Redesigning Social Inquiry: Fuzzy Sets and Beyond. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Stinchcombe, Arthur L. 1987. Constructing Social Theories. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Swedberg, Richard. 2014. The Art of Social Theory. Princeton, NJ and Oxford, UK: Princeton University Press.<br /><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Time Management</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity. 2021 (updated yearly). "SKILL #1: Every Summer Needs a Plan". Accessed October 2021 (https://www.facultydiversity.org/).<ul><li>This workshop outlines their strategic planning method (they apply it to every semester, not just the summer). It has become an essential part of how I plan my academic work.<br /></li><li>Many universities subscribe to the NCFDD's workshops. I'm able to watch these workshops through my institutional subscription.<br /></li></ul><br />National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity. 2021 (updated yearly). "SKILL #2: How to Align Your Time with Your Priorities." Accessed October 2021 (https://www.facultydiversity.org/).<ul><li>This workshop shows their weekly planning method. I also use this in my set of time management methods (in addition to their "Skill #1").<br /></li></ul><br />National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity. 2021 (updated yearly). "SKILL #3: How to Develop a Daily Writing Practice." Accessed October 2021 (https://www.facultydiversity.org/).<br /><br />National Center for Faculty Development and Diversity. 2021 (updated yearly). "SKILL #4: Mastering Academic Time Management." Accessed October 2021 (https://www.facultydiversity.org/).<ul><li>Many great additional tips on time management.<br /></li></ul><br /><br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Twitter Accounts that Post about Academic Methods</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">@raulpacheco<br /></div>  <h2 class="wsite-content-title"><font color="#2a2a2a">Writing</font><br /></h2>  <div class="paragraph">Becker, Howard S. 2007. Writing for Social Scientists: How to Start and Finish You Rthesis, Book, or Article. 2nd ed. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Belcher, Wendy Laura. 2016. Writing Your Journal Article in 12 Weeks: A Guide to Academic Publishing Success. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.<br /><br />Bolker, Joan. 1998. Writing Your Dissertation in Fifteen Minutes a Day: A Guide to Starting, Revising, and Finishing Your Doctoral Thesis. 1st ed. New York: H. Holt.<br /><br />Dunleavy, Patrick. 2003. Authoring a PhD: How to Plan, Draft, Write, and Finish a Doctoral Thesis or Dissertation. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire ; New York: Palgrave Macmillan.<br /><br />Eco, Umberto, Caterina Mongiat Farina, and Geoff Farina. 2015. How to Write a Thesis. Cambridge, Massachusetts: MIT Press.<br /><br />Feak, Christine B., John M. Swales, John M. Swales, and Christine B. Feak. 2009. Telling a Research Story: Writing a Literature Review. Ann Arbor, Mich.: University of Michigan Press.<br /><br />Germano, William. 2016. Getting It Published: A Guide for Scholars and Anyone Else Serious about Serious Books, Third Edition. University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Germano, William P. 2005. From Dissertation to Book. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Graff, Gerald, and Cathy Birkenstein. 2006. They Say, I Say: The Moves That Matter in Academic Writing. New York, NY, USA and London, UK: W. W. Norton &amp; Company.<br /><br />Hall, Trish. 2019. Writing to Persuade: How to Bring People over to Your Side. First edition. New York: Liveright Publishing Corporation, a division of W.W. Norton &amp; Company.<br /><br />Harris, Angelique, and Alia R. Tyner-Mullings. 2013. Writing for Emerging Sociologists. Thousand Oaks, CA, USA and London, UK: Sage Publications.<br /><br />Hart, Chris. 1998. Doing a Literature Review: Releasing the Social Science Research Imagination. London: Sage Publications.<br /><br />King, Stephen. 2000. On Writing: A Memoir of the Craft. Toronto, ON: Pocket Books.<ul><li>This is a mostly a memoir, but content warning: he has struggled with alcoholism, and that struggle is described in great detail here.</li></ul><br />Pinker, Steven. 2014. The Sense of Style: The Thinking Person&rsquo;s Guide to Writing in the 21st Century. New York: Penguin.<br /><br />Rosenwasser, David, and Jill Stephen. 2012. Writing Analytically. Boston, MA: Wadsworth.<ul><li>This book changed the way I write.</li></ul><br />Silvia, Paul J. 2015. Write It Up: Practical Strategies for Writing and Publishing Journal Articles. Washington, D.C.: American Psychological Association.<br />* Some good advice, but you have to take a lot of it with a grain of salt.<br /><br />Silvia, Paul J. 2019. How to Write a Lot: A Practical Guide to Productive Academic Writing. Second edition. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.<ul><li>Basically: set up a writing schedule and write with others.</li></ul><br />Strunk, William, and E. B. White. 2000. The Elements of Style by William Strunk Jr., With Revisions, an Introduction, and a Chapter on Writing by E.B. White. Needham Heights, MA: Allyn &amp; Bacon.<br /><br />Swales, John. 1990. Genre Analysis: English in Academic and Research Settings. Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press.<br /><br />Swales, John, and Christine B. Feak. 2010. Academic Writing for Graduate Students: Essential Tasks and Skills. 2. ed., Ann Arbor, Mich: Univ. of Michigan Press.<br /><br />Swales, John M. 2004. Research Genres: Explorations and Applications. Cambridge, UK ; New York: Cambridge University Press.<br /><br />Swales, John M., and Christine B. Feak. 2000. English in Today&rsquo;s Research World: A Writing Guide. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.<br /><br />Swales, John M., Christine B. Feak, and John M. Swales. 2009. Abstracts and the Writing of Abstracts. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.<br /><br />Sword, Helen. 2012. Stylish Academic Writing. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard University Press.<br /><br />Turabian, Kate L. 2007. A Manual for Writers of Research Papers, Theses, and Dissertations: Chicago Style for Students and Researchers. 7th ed. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.<br /><br />Zerubavel, Eviatar. 1999. The Clockwork Muse: A Practical Guide to Writing Theses, Dissertations, and Books. Cambridge, MA, USA: Harvard University Press.<ul><li>Another book (like Silvia's How to Write a Lot) that emphasizes the importance of a writing schedule.</li></ul><br />Zinsser, William. 2006. On Writing Well. New York, NY, USA: HarperCollins.<br /><br />Zuckerman, Ezra W. 2017. &ldquo;On Genre: A Few More Tips to Article-Writers.&rdquo; Accessed 19 October 2018 from http://mitmgmtfaculty.mit.edu/esivan/reviews_essays/. doi: 10.1086/690762.<ul><li>This changed the way I read and write journal articles.</li></ul></div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[Method I Used to get &gt;90% on Undergrad Exams]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/method-i-used-to-get-gt90-on-undergrad-exams]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/method-i-used-to-get-gt90-on-undergrad-exams#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Sun, 29 May 2022 02:16:52 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/method-i-used-to-get-gt90-on-undergrad-exams</guid><description><![CDATA[It took me a few years to figure out how to get high grades on university exams, but by the end of my degree I could consistently get 90% or above, using this method. Other students I shared this with, in my undergrad and in my role as a university teacher, have also found it effective.This method is difficult. But that is why it works.The general idea is to emulate the test situation. In general, this is a good method for any kind of assessment. But the methods for putting that into action is s [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">It took me a few years to figure out how to get high grades on university exams, but by the end of my degree I could consistently get 90% or above, using this method. Other students I shared this with, in my undergrad and in my role as a university teacher, have also found it effective.<br /><br />This method is difficult. But that is why it works.<br /><br />The general idea is to emulate the test situation. In general, this is a good method for any kind of assessment. But the methods for putting that into action is straightforward with university exams.<br /><br /><span>I called the method, "The Questions Method" I also want to emphasize: I don't own this method, it isn't "my" method&mdash;I'm sure most people who do well on exams have some variation of it. Basically this is what you do:<br /><br />When you go to lecture, and the professor is lecturing about their powerpoint slides, and the slides are all game for exams, you sit there in class and as they go through it, you write questions for all the material on the slides.<br /><br />Then when you do the readings, you also make questions for the material.<br /><br />Then when it comes time to review, you have this comprehensive list of questions.<br /><br />Your "studying" is then answering the questions. It is best if you can print out the questions</span>. (Click "Read More", below, on the right, if you want to read the full post).<br /><br /></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph"><span>So the method is to look at whatever question you're on, and see if you can answer it without looking at your notes. If you can't, then you write a little "x" beside the question, in front of it. Then you go and review the material. If you can answer it, you write a checkmark.<br /><br />That way, you know how to prioritize your time when you come back for a second round: clearly you don't need to review the questions for which you already have the information in your mind.<br /><br />So if you come to a question and write an "x", then you ask yourself the question again immediately, and you see if you can answer it, without looking at the notes. If you can't then you check the course material again, and repeat (asking yourself the question, seeing if you can answer it, if you can't, looking at the course material) until you can answer it without looking at the notes.</span><br /><br /><span>Then you move on to the next question. The questions are not all of the same level of granularity. Say your professor wants you to learn about the causes of climate change. So you could have a question that covers all of them: What are all the causes of climate change?<br /><br />But then you would also have specific questions about each one that can help you learn them during your first pass of the questions without having to answer such an intense question.<br /><br />So smaller scale questions like, "What are the human-based causes of climate change?" and something like, "What are the positive feedback loop causes of climate change?" could be two subquestions.<br /><br />At some point you don't need the subquestions anymore because you can just answer the general question without looking at the notes.<br /><br />Also, I found that making some additional notes was often helpful, especially "concept maps". So when answering the question about, "what are the causes of climate change?" for the first time, I might take out a piece of paper and map them all out, getting them off of the different powerpoint slides (in summary form of course, not copying out everything). Then this would help me remember because I could sort of see the map (I don't have a photographic memory, but I could kind of remember where on the page different parts of the answer were).<br /><br />Usually if I could go through all the questions twice, then I had a very good chance at getting &gt;90% on exams. But the hardest questions often had 3-6 "x" marks beside them, and I'd review those up to the time of the exam. Those were often lists, for which I developed acronyms.<br /><br />Sometimes I would be in class, before a midterm was about to start, and I'd be checking my notes one last time for questions that had like 5 x marks beside them. Sometimes my colleagues would be like: you can only study so much. But I would know that those questions were ones I really needed a bit more time for, because I had tried to answer them like 5 times and didn't make it. So it was actually the most relevant studying I could possibly do at that time, and wasn't, as these other students guessed, a waste of time.<br /><br />This is hard work. So, I did 50 minute periods (with a timer) and then would literally lay down on my bed with my eyes closed for 10 minutes (also timed with a timer) (eyes CLOSED was required! no phone etc.) and then resume.<br /><br />Now, this gets the information in your short term memory. But most of it vanishes within a few weeks. But what can you do, you need the grades! But this is why I'm not a huge fan of exams (who is, really)&mdash;doesn't really lead to deep learning.<br /><br />But of course without enough labour to grade essays it is hard to make every final exam a set of essays. In any case, that's the "Questions Method" that I developed.<br /><br />The last exam I wrote in my undergrad (which had short answers, essays, and multiple choice), I got 100%, and the professor said he had never given that out before but was amazed at how much I had remembered.<br /><br />It wasn't at all me being some kind of genius &mdash; it was the outcome of 4 years of perfecting this method. In general, that is how I see successful academic output of any kind&mdash;you primarily need to perfect the methods behind good work.<br /><br />If you try this out, I'd be happy to learn how it goes for you! If it doesn't work for you for some reason, and another method works better, I'd be glad to know.<br /><br />This was also posted on Twitter: </span>https://twitter.com/tylerbateman/status/1483952967917129729</div>]]></content:encoded></item><item><title><![CDATA[How I Read: Map Notes]]></title><link><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-map-notes]]></link><comments><![CDATA[https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-map-notes#comments]]></comments><pubDate>Thu, 28 Oct 2021 00:11:52 GMT</pubDate><category><![CDATA[Uncategorized]]></category><guid isPermaLink="false">https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/academic-methods-blog/how-i-read-map-notes</guid><description><![CDATA[When I first started trying to read non-fiction books and articles seriously, I was often quite lost. I found that I could not just sit there and read a book and retain the argument with its various details.Over time, I found that the way that helped me most thoroughly concentrate on a reading, and that produced something with "added value" that allowed me to very quickly review a reading in the future, was to create what I call "map notes". I don't know what the formal methods are for "mind map [...] ]]></description><content:encoded><![CDATA[<div class="paragraph">When I first started trying to read non-fiction books and articles seriously, I was often quite lost. I found that I could not just sit there and read a book and retain the argument with its various details.<br /><br />Over time, I found that the way that helped me most thoroughly concentrate on a reading, and that produced something with "added value" that allowed me to very quickly review a reading in the future, was to create what I call "map notes". I don't know what the formal methods are for "mind mapping", but this method appears to be close to that (but I honestly haven't ever read books or anything about mind mapping).<br /><br />There are two ways to make these maps: by "piece" (of writing), or for a field.<br /><br />You can take what I refer to as "piece notes" (notes for one particular article or chapter of a book) in a notebook or on a tablet. The method is pretty simple. At the top of the notes, you write the title of the article/chapter, the author's name, where it was published (if a journal article), and how many Google Scholar citations it has (to give some idea of its current level of influence). Also, as you go, you number the pages.<br /><br />Then the goal is to map the MAIN ARGUMENT. You can add some of the details that branch off of the main argument. But the goal is not to obsess about marginal details. The point is to map the main ideas.<br /><br />I find the mapping technique to be nice because it allows for creativity and also allows you to put a LOT of information on one page. (Click below to read the full post).<br /><br /></div>  <div>  <!--BLOG_SUMMARY_END--></div>  <div class="paragraph">This is a page from my "piece map notes" of an article by Ezra Zuckerman on the different genres of sociological journal articles. It was taken on A4 sized paper with a few pens.</div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/ez_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">You can see that a lot of information is there on one page. So it helps to have these notes to quickly review something later.<br /><br />But what I have been doing more recently is making "field level map notes", which is a bit harder to do on paper or on a tablet. I'm currently taking these notes on a Mac program called "Omnigraffle" (it is basically the Microsoft Viso for Mac). So what I do there is I try to figure out how different authors in the field talk about a particular topic. So I have one, for example, for Relational Sociology. A big topic. But I'm able then to take many authors' writings and put them all on one large page, and see how the ideas relate to each other. So these field level map notes are restrained by the amount of RAM you have, but you can still make pretty enormous field level maps before you run out of RAM (or at least I can running an M1 Mac with 16 GB of RAM).<br /><br />This is a picture of those field level map notes (I know you can't really see what is said in any of the boxes, but gives you the idea):<br /><br /><br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/f1_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/f2_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">For most purposes as an undergraduate or graduate student, piece level map notes should be enough. The field level map notes are only needed (for me anyway) when you're being asked to be an expert on a field (like when you publish a journal article in a particular field) and need to be able to see how different authors relate to each other.<br /><br />But you could also take many piece level map notes and then later do summary map notes, relating people together. That is what I did for both of my comprehensive exams, which required me to read about 200 books/journal articles each. So in both of those, I took all my notes as "piece map notes", and then took extra synthesis notes where I related different authors together. I also took all those piece map notes on paper, to reduce the amount of distractions when I had such a massive task to do (read those many sources in a short period of time).<br /><br />Here are some other examples of piece map notes (taken on A4 paper that I cut in half) (and yes, you have to scan them if you take them on paper!):<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c1_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c2_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c3_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c4_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c5_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c6_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c7_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/c8_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">Here are some piece map notes I took on Matthew Desmond's "Becoming a Firefighter" paper. I take a different approach here and give each paragraph a title. I was trying to figure out how to write an ethnography article here, which is why I took this approach (of mapping the structure of the article at the same time as recording the content of it). The notes are a lot messier when trying to write on an iPad screen!<br /></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/d1_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/d2_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/d3_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/d4_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div><div class="wsite-image wsite-image-border-none " style="padding-top:10px;padding-bottom:10px;margin-left:0;margin-right:0;text-align:center"> <a> <img src="https://www.tylerjamesbateman.com/uploads/1/3/9/6/139636543/d5_orig.png" alt="Picture" style="width:auto;max-width:100%" /> </a> <div style="display:block;font-size:90%"></div> </div></div>  <div class="paragraph">So some other aspects of what I do come out in the examples.<br /><br />I put a page number beside anything that is a point made by the author. So that 1) I don't have to go back to the article to check page numbers, and 2) I know what the author said and what I am writing.<br /><br />My own comments always have a date after them (a day and a time, so that I know how my thoughts progressed during the course of reading something).<br /><br />I also colour code different things:<br /><br />Orange: What the author agrees with/their argument/things the author thinks is a good idea<br />Light red: What the author disagrees with<br />Black: What the author is neutral about<br /><br />Green: What I agree with<br />Dark red: What I disagree with<br />Blue: What I'm neutral about<br /><br />Brown: Anything about academic methods. How to write, how to do ethnography etc. Notes I make or that the author makes that are about how to do something, e.g., how to read better etc. You can see this colour when I'm mapping the structure of Desmond's article.<br /><br />I also highlight or underline the actual text with those colours.<br /><br />Now, this is NOT the only effective way to read. If you're reading this and have another very effective reading method that is different from this one (and perhaps better!), please let me know and I'd be happy to talk about you writing a guest post on this blog.<br /><br /></div>]]></content:encoded></item></channel></rss>